Jump to content

Comparison of software saving Web pages for offline use

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by KAtremer (talk | contribs) at 14:25, 16 February 2014. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

HTML Content

Name Technology Completeness of saved content Support for collections Ease of adding to existing collections Navigable between saved pages in offline Format of saved files; open/proprietary Compression Notes
wget command line application images and CSS (if -p option is used), but no client-side generated HTML content Yes ? Yes, if -k option is used Open (HTML or WARC) Yes, if WARC files are used
HTtrack command line application has WebHTTrack and WinHTTrack GUI front-ends ? ? ? ? ? ?
Scrapbook Firefox extension Default:
  • images, CSS and other static content; clientside-generated HTML content—all saved fine

Optionally:

  • sound (MP3, WAV, RAM, WMA)
  • video (MPG, AVI, MOV, WMV)
  • archives (ZIP, LZH, RAR, JAR, XPI)
  • custom document extensions
Yes Easy No Proprietary catalog; regular HTML and content for each page No

Extra features:

  • Search across collections

See also "Detailed notes" section below.

Mozilla Archive Format Firefox extension Images, CSS and other static content; clientside-generated HTML content saved fine Yes Impossible No MAFF (=ZIP of regular HTML and web content) Always
Read Later Fast Google Chrome extension Stylesheets are saved incompletely or not at all No N/A No Proprietary; restricted to Google Chrome profile location No
PageArchiver Google Chrome extension Video and audio files (via Flash or HTML5) are not saved Yes Yes (import/export features) No Open; regular HTML for pages, regular zip file for catalog Yes for catalog

Details on specific software

Scrapbook

Known issues:

  • saved pages embedding TED.com presentations (incl. pages on TED.com) cannot be played even when online
  • selecting a piece of page will save only selected piece—inconvenient when you change page title with a quote from the page

Video

To save video embedded on web sites (e.g. YouTube), Download Helper Firefox extension can be used, as well as others for Firefox as well as Chrome.

See also