Talk:Bob Noel/GA1: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively

← Previous edit Next edit →

Content deleted Content added

VisualWikitext

Inline

Revision as of 23:30, 25 April 2024

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Nominator: BeanieFan11 (talk · contribs) 22:49, 24 April 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Reviewer: Gonzo fan2007 (talk · contribs) 22:54, 24 April 2024 (UTC)[reply]

I'll review this tomorrow. « Gonzo fan2007 (talk) @ 22:54, 24 April 2024 (UTC)[reply]

GA review (see here for what the criteria are, and here for what they are not)
It is reasonably well written. a (prose, spelling, and grammar): b (MoS for lead, layout, word choice, fiction, and lists): It is factually accurate and verifiable, as shown by a source spot-check. a (references): b (citations to reliable sources): c (OR): d (copyvio and plagiarism): It is broad in its coverage. a (major aspects): b (focused): It follows the neutral point of view policy. Fair representation without bias: It is stable. No edit wars, etc.: It is illustrated by images, where possible and appropriate. a (images are tagged and non-free images have fair use rationales): b (appropriate use with suitable captions):
Overall: Pass/Fail:
· · ·

Comments

I'm wondering if American football is necessary in the first sentence. Maybe American equipment manager? Would get ride of the consecutive linking and add in his ethnicity.
Noel attended Central Catholic High School in Wisconsin and while attending there enlisted in World War II at the age of 18. is a bit choppy. Maybe Noel attended Central Catholic High School in Wisconsin; while still in high school, he enlisted in World War II at the age of 18.?
and a "lot of smaller things" needed by the team for each game --> and a "lot of smaller things" needed for each game
as well as 30 balls for games --> as well as 30 game balls
11 head coaches you could link to List of Green Bay Packers head coaches
I don't know what in the hell I could've done more."[8] and He served the team faithfully and well for a long time."[13] I think the period needs to go after the quotation mark
For the image, you need to do a few things: change the link to be the non-Wikimedia Library link. Also, the copyright holder is the Green Bay Press-Gazette (the image caption notes "Press-Gazette Files". Lastly, add a caption to the infobox, something like "Noel working on a helmet in an undated photo". Also, the image needs to be downsized, which the bot will do at some point.
Spot checks look good. Ref 6, 11 and 14 needs an access date (I typically do them for all citations, but I think you don't; I think thats ok for the Newspaper.com sources, but the others are just live web pages, and thus need access dates).

Looks good, putting on hold. « Gonzo fan2007 (talk) @ 23:30, 25 April 2024 (UTC)[reply]

@@ Line 10: / Line 10: @@
 I'll review this tomorrow.<span style="white-space:nowrap; font-family:Harlow Solid Italic;"><span style="font-size:small; color:teal;"> « Gonzo fan2007</span> [[User talk:Gonzo_fan2007#top|<small style="color:#2A2722">(talk)</small>]] @ </span> 22:54, 24 April 2024 (UTC)
+{| class="wikitable" style="width: 100%; width:50em"
+|-
+! height=50 | [[Wikipedia:Good article nominations|GA]] review<br>{{small|(see [[Wikipedia:Good article criteria|here]] for what the criteria are, and [[WP:GACN|here]] for what they are not)}}
+|-
+|
+#It is '''reasonably well written'''.
+#:a ''(prose, spelling, and grammar)'': {{GAList/check|h}}<br/> b ''([[Wikipedia:Manual of Style|MoS]] for [[WP:LEAD|lead]], [[WP:LAYOUT|layout]], [[WP:WTW|word choice]], [[WP:WAF|fiction]], and [[Wikipedia:Embedded list|lists]])'': {{GAList/check|y}}
+#It is '''factually accurate''' and '''[[Wikipedia:Verifiability|verifiable]]''', as shown by a [[WP:GAN/I#R3|source spot-check]].
+#:a ''(references)'': {{GAList/check|h}} <br/>b ''(citations to [[WP:RS|reliable sources]])'': {{GAList/check|y}} <br/>c ''([[Wikipedia:No original research|OR]])'': {{GAList/check|y}} <br/>d ''([[Wikipedia:Copyrights|copyvio]] and [[Wikipedia:Plagiarism|plagiarism]])'': {{GAList/check|y}}
+#It is '''broad in its coverage'''.
+#:a ''(major aspects)'': {{GAList/check|y}} <br/>b ''(focused)'': {{GAList/check|y}}
+#It follows the '''[[WP:NPOV|neutral point of view]] policy'''.
+#:''Fair representation without bias'': {{GAList/check|y}}
+#It is '''stable'''.
+#:''No edit wars, etc.'': {{GAList/check|y}}
+#It is illustrated by '''[[Wikipedia:Images|images]]''', where possible and appropriate.
+#:a ''(images are tagged and non-free images have [[Wikipedia:Non-free_use_rationale_guideline|fair use rationales]])'': {{GAList/check|hold}} <br/>b ''(appropriate use with [[WP:CAP|suitable captions]])'': {{GAList/check|hold}}
+|-
+| style="text-align:center;" |
+'''Overall''':<br/>
+''Pass/Fail'': {{GAList/check|hold}}<!-- Template:GAReview -->
+|-
+|-
+! height=30|[[File:Symbol_support_vote.svg|15px]] · [[File:Symbol_oppose_vote.svg|15px]] · [[File:Symbol_wait.svg|15px]] · [[File:Symbol_neutral_vote.svg|15px]]
+|-
+|}
+===Comments===
+*I'm wondering if [[American football]] is necessary in the first sentence. Maybe {{tq|American equipment manager}}? Would get ride of the consecutive linking and add in his ethnicity.
+*{{tq|Noel attended Central Catholic High School in Wisconsin and while attending there enlisted in World War II at the age of 18.}} is a bit choppy. Maybe {{tq|Noel attended Central Catholic High School in Wisconsin; while still in high school, he enlisted in World War II at the age of 18.}}?
+*{{tq|and a "lot of smaller things" needed by the team for each game}} --> {{tq|and a "lot of smaller things" needed for each game}}
+*{{tq|as well as 30 balls for games}} --> {{tq|as well as 30 game balls}}
+*{{tq|11 head coaches}} you could link to [[List of Green Bay Packers head coaches]]
+*{{tq|I don't know what in the hell I could've done more."[8]}} and {{tq|He served the team faithfully and well for a long time."[13]}} I think the period needs to go after the quotation mark
+*For the image, you need to do a few things: change the link to be the non-Wikimedia Library link. Also, the copyright holder is the [[Green Bay Press-Gazette]] (the image caption notes "Press-Gazette Files". Lastly, add a caption to the infobox, something like "Noel working on a helmet in an undated photo". Also, the image needs to be downsized, which the bot will do at some point.
+*Spot checks look good. Ref 6, 11 and 14 needs an access date (I typically do them for all citations, but I think you don't; I think thats ok for the Newspaper.com sources, but the others are just live web pages, and thus need access dates).
+Looks good, putting on hold.<span style="white-space:nowrap; font-family:Harlow Solid Italic;"><span style="font-size:small; color:teal;"> « Gonzo fan2007</span> [[User talk:Gonzo_fan2007#top|<small style="color:#2A2722">(talk)</small>]] @ </span> 23:30, 25 April 2024 (UTC)