Charlotte Frances McLeod
Charlotte Frances McLeod |
|---|
Charlotte Frances McLeod, formerly Charlie Earnest McLeod, was the second American woman to travel to Denmark and undergo a sex change operation. Before her transition, McLeod was a G.I. who served in the army from 1948-1949. She was discharged from the Army for minor medical reasons.[1]
Life before transition
McLeod was originally from New Orleans, Louisiana, but also lived in Miami and Tennessee at different points throughout her life. McLeod's father recalled that she rarely engaged in sports or other games with boys.[2]
McLeod was a GI in the military from 1948-1949 and was discharged for minor medical reasons. When asked about why she left, McLeod stated: "Everyone could see that I was no soldier, and that it was all a mistake.”[3]
McLeod was unable to get the plastic surgery in America she wanted. Instead, American doctors attempted to change her transgender identity: "I’ve never been a boy—not in my mind. American doctors offered to make me more of a man, but could never give me a man’s mind”[4]
McLeod commented several times on the dire emotional state she was in due to her inability to be the gender she felt she truly was. During her time in America she felt suicidal due to her inability to receive surgery in America, stating: “I was treated neither as male or female—more as a nonentity…I was miserable and I wanted to die.”[5]
Surgery
McLeod was living in Dyersburg, Tennessee just before she traveled to Denmark for the surgeries that would allow her to transition from male to female.
McLeod, age 28 traveled to Copenhagen, Denmark in the years 1953-1954 to receive the plastic surgery that would allow her to transition from male to female. McLeod was able to pay for travel because her Great Aunt had provided her with an inheritance.
When McLeod first went to Denmark to receive plastic surgery there was a law that stated they could only perform the operation on Scandinavians. However, McLeod still underwent a sex change surgery that was performed by professors and surgeons free of charge. McLeod's surgery was cited as being rather dangerous and unconventional. However, McLeod's intentions to return home a woman did not falter: “The thought of having come all this way in vain and return as the Charlie I hated was unbearable. So I managed to have the first operation made unofficially. It happened on a kitchen table at midnight and that’s all I want to say about that, but the operation almost killed me.”[5]
Return home
For a short while after her surgery, McLeod lived in a boarding house operated by the Second Baptist Church. They eventually asked McLeod to leave, stating: "We have done what we could for Charlotte and we will continue to do our Christian duty toward a person in distress, but we just cannot take this. We have therefore told Charlotte that we thought it wisest if she found another place to stay until everything is quiet again."[6]
However, upon returning home, McLeod found herself to be very happy and was surrounded by people who loved and supported her: “I fit right in where I left off. It’s wonderful to be back home. Friends don’t feel any different toward me now than before. They’ve accepted the many changes.”[7]
Career
McLeod performed a one woman show once a week at SHO-BAR at 228 Bourbon Street in New Orleans, Louisiana. It was a nine act show where she discussed different aspects of her transition.[8] She also appeared as a Comedienne in Green Village Bistro in Boston in 1954.[9]
McLeod did not have a strong desire for this kind of career, but continued to work in entertainment in order to make enough money to live a normal life. She was quoted telling The San Francisco Examiner that: “She doesn’t look forward to night club work, but thinks it necessary to pay bills. She said she is looking forward to married life and a home of her own.”[6]
Other jobs
McLeod was documented working as a secretary for six weeks, as well as demonstrating cosmetics at a Miami Beach shop.[10]
Lawsuit
Elmo Badon, the owner of the Moulin Rouge at 231 Bourbon Street in New Orleans, sued McLeod in 1954. Badon claimed that McLeod was meant to perform as an entertainer at his club but then had later refused. The judge, Rene A. Viosca, signed a restraining order against McLeod that temporarily stopped her from appearing in any night club as an entertainer. [11]
Badon eventually lost the case and the restraining order was lifted.[12]
Name change
McLeod was able to change her name from Charles Earnest McLeod to Charlotte Frances McLeod at age 29. The petition for the name change was filed by attorney R.C. Colton, Jr., who stated: "Applicant at all times wears women’s clothing and other articles of dress and cosmetics peculiar to the female sex.”[13]
McLeod's passport was issued to "Charlotte Frances McLeod, a female."[13]
Marriage and family life
McLeod was married at age 34 in Miami, Florida.[14] McLeod's husband, Ralph H. Heidal, was from New York and was 36 years old when he married McLeod. The couple were married on October 11th, 1959.[10]
Relationship with father
McLeod's father, Charles McLeod Sr., worked in insurance. He and McLeod's mother divorced and were each remarried. Charles had two other daughters with his second wife. Originally, Charles was against McLeod's operation because American doctors had warned him it would be dangerous for McLeod's health. When he learned that a Memphis psychiatrist was giving her hormones, he walked out of the office in disgust.[2] Because of the threat that surgery would have to McLeod's life, Charles told McLeod that he would not help her.[1]
However, after McLeod returned, her father stated: “I was opposed to the operation, but now that it’s over, I’m ready to support Charlotte as my daughter.” He was also quoted saying other supportive claims such as:
“It’s a little hard to get used to after all these years. But I will, you can bet on that.”
“I guess he always wanted to be a girl.”
“I was happy to see her. I hope that this change will be better. I hope she’ll be happy.” [7]
Comparisons to Christine Jorgenson
Christine Jorgenson was the first widely known transgender woman to travel to Denmark in order to have operations that would allow her to transition from male to female. [6] McLeod had stated to newspapers that she had planned to go to Denmark to receive surgery before Jorgenson.[5]
Charlotte McLeod was known to have a dislike towards Jorgenson. At one of her one-woman shows, she was quoted saying: “I just wish she’d come in here some night so I could yell ‘Check your hat, mister.” [15]
McLeod's story was written in the press to be very different from Jorgenson's. Generally, Jorgenson was presented as a positive example of a trans woman, while McLeod was often mocked by the press. Time magazine wrote: “Charlotte’s story resembles Christine’s. He was a sensitive boy, quiet and lonely, with a penchant for dressing up in women’s clothing. Like Christine, he was drafted into the Army; unlike Christine, he found it too hard.” [6]
McLeod stated that since controversy arose from Christine's transformation, McLeod had to go about hers in secret.
Christine Jorgenson, when told about McLeod, said she had no advice to give: “People get exactly what they give out. I feel that a person makes his own way and his attitudes are reflected through other people. I cannot offer advice to anyone else. I can say only what I have done. At all times, I have conducted myself like a lady.”[2]
Press
An incident between McLeod and the press was discussed frequently in many articles just after her arrival to America from Denmark. Upon returning home, McLeod was being photographed leaving the Hotel Statler, where she was staying. Overwhelmed by all the chaos, McLeod hit a photographer by the name of Glenn D. Everett with her umbrella. McLeod declined going to the hospital afterwards despite her stomach pains.
During the incident, McLeod was quoted stating: "Go away...I can't say anything."[16]
Everyone involved in the incident was taken to the police station.[16]
Charges of assault against McLeod were initially filed but were then taken down.[10]
Autobiography
McLeod published an autobiography discussing her life and her transition in Mr. Magazine. In her autobiography she discussed issues such as the distinction between homosexuals and drag queens. She also displayed a dislike towards New Orleans gay counterculture, stating: “I was appalled at their insincerity, insecurity, and promiscuity practiced among them. I did feel a great sympathy for many of these young men and women who I met, but I could find no peace of mind among them.” [6]
References
- ^ a b "American Youth Encounters Trouble in Seeking Change of Sex in Denmark - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ a b c "Now His Daughter, Says Ex-GI's Dad - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ "Danish Doctors Again Change Sex of American - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ "Danes Change 2d GI to Girl".
- ^ a b c "New Case Parallels Jorgensen's - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ a b c d e Skidmore, Emily (2011). "Constructing the "Good Transsexual": Christine Jorgensen, Whiteness, and Heteronormativity in the Mid-Twentieth-Century Press". Feminist Studies. 37 (2): 270–300. JSTOR 23069901.
- ^ a b "Sex Change or Suicide Choice - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ "A Few Days Left!: Charlotte McLeod - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ "Charlotte McLeod Will Appear as a Comedienne - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ a b c "Bridge Revealed As Former GI - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ "Charlotte Halted by Court Action - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ "Charlotte M'Leod Suit Lost by Badon - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ a b "Asks Charles Be Charlotte - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ Bowman, Karl M.; Engle, Bernice (1960). "Sex Offenses: The Medical and Legal Implications of Sex Variations". Law and Contemporary Problems. 25 (2): 292–308. doi:10.2307/1190379. JSTOR 1190379.
- ^ "Midtown New York: Employe [sic] Welfare and Morale - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
- ^ a b "Charlotte in Seclusion After Umbrella Affray - Digital Transgender Archive". www.digitaltransgenderarchive.net. Retrieved 2018-10-19.
