Antinarcissism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Penbat (talk | contribs) at 21:39, 15 October 2016 (→‎Other Formulations). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Antinarcissism is a specific form of narcissistic character that, rather than aggrandising the ego, restricts its scope without diminishing the amount of self-investment involved.

Self-limitation

Christopher Bollas introduced the concept of antinarcissism to describe a self-limiting kind of narcissist who refuse to develop themselves or use their talents,[1] so as to maintain their exaggerated sense of self-importance in defeat. "This anti-elaborative person 'stews in his own juice' and adamantly refuses to nurture himself".[2] The antinarcissist may preserve a hostile, even sadistic, core behind a self-effacing facade of care and consideration for others.[3]

André Green similarly wrote of antinarcissism as a negative narcissism that seeks self-destructively to abolish the ego.[4]

Other formulations

  • Hélène Cixous saw as anti-narcissistic the female internalisation of the male gaze as an alien standard to live up to, as opposed to developing their own selves.[5]
  • Fritz Wittels earlier described as antinarcissistic the tendency of two lovers to lose themselves each in the other.[6]

See also

3

References

  1. ^ Tod Sloan, Damaged Life (2002) p. 116
  2. ^ Bollas, quoted in N. Symington, Narcissism (2003) p. 113
  3. ^ A. Gratch, If Men could Talk (2009)
  4. ^ A. M. Cooper et al ed., Psychoanalysis on the Move () p. 79
  5. ^ L. Hart, Fatal Women (2005) p. 65
  6. ^ F. WIttels, Sigmund Freud (2013[1923]) p. 207

External links