How Are We to Live?
Cover of the first edition
|Publisher||Text Publishing, Melbourne|
|Media type||Print (Paperback)|
How Are We to Live?: Ethics in an Age of Self-Interest is a book on applied ethics by bioethical philosopher Peter Singer. It was first published in 1993, with subsequent editions in later years. Singer argues that doing the right thing involves attending to the sufferings and preferences of other sentient beings.
Singer presents a history of ethical thought, and attempts to refute the popular idea that humans are genetically driven to be selfish. He explains how this idea has been attributed to Thomas Hobbes and Adam Smith, and how politicians like Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan tried to persuade people that self-interest was good. Singer takes a contrary view, and argues that self-interest is a time-bomb for society.
Singer discusses Japanese culture and hows its ethical perspective differs from that of modern western culture, and attempts to infer a few properties of the development of ethical thought. Singer argues in favour of a form of R. M. Hare's notion of universalizability as a basis for ethics: he argues we should make choices with reference to the whole universe. He proposes that ethical behavior is in fact beneficial for the individual under real-life conditions, and proposes five practical ethical rules based on a computer simulation of the Prisoner's Dilemma. He draws on the Golden Rule, and explains how the broad cross-cultural support for it gives it a central role in ethics. Singer elaborates on the reasons for behaving ethically and how they apply on actual everyday life.
Singer discusses various philosophical perspectives on ethics, including Christian and Kantian ones. The book asserts that "In a society in which the narrow pursuit of material self-interest is the norm, the shift to an ethical stance is more radical than many people realize."
Singer attempts to show how the key for a satisfactory life resides on its purpose and how crucial for that purpose a commitment to an ethical life is. This connects with the argument that the pursuit of self-interest is self-defeating. He argues that altruism can be genuine - not just enlightened self-interest, and offers examples of people who sacrificed their lives to save people from Nazis to make this point. Singer comments on the effect of having the widest perspective possible on our ethical decisions; on how our rational capability sometimes leads us to change our goal; and on the paradoxical opportunity that the existence of so many ills on the world brings to us by way of showing plenty of clearly worthwhile goals. To live a good life, the book prescribes: "You can rethink your goals and question what you are doing with your life. That might mean quitting your job, selling your house, and going to work for a voluntary organization in India. More often, the commitment to a more ethical way of living will be the first step of a gradual but far-reaching evolution in your lifestyle and in your thinking about your place in the world. One thing is certain: you will find plenty of worthwhile things to do."
Critics have suggested Singer misrepresents the role of self-interest in some religions, such as the prospect of rewards in heaven.
Singer has said, "I am not really satisfied with the book". He has expressed concerns that his argument that an ethical life makes for a fulfilling life "contains an element of wishful thinking", as he does not always do everything that he believes to be morally right and so might have underestimated how demanding morality can be, set against other things that might be fulfilling in life.
Editions and translations
The German translation, by Hermann Vetter, was published by Harald Fischer Verlag in 1996 as Wie sollen wir leben?: Ethik in einer egoistischen Zeit. A paperback was produced by Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag in 1999 and went through several reprints, most recently in 2004.
- Pickering, Neil (November 1998). "Review: How Are We To Live? Ethics in an Age of Self-Interest". Journal of Medical Ethics. 24 (5): 353–354. doi:10.1136/jme.24.5.353-a. PMC .
- Jeffries, Stuart (22 July 2005). "Moral maze" – via The Guardian.
- "How are we to Live? by Peter Singer - Issue 24 - Philosophy Now".
- "Excerpts from How Are We To Live? by Peter Singer - Vegan Outreach".
- Schaler, Jeffrey A. (30 September 2011). Peter Singer Under Fire: The Moral Iconoclast Faces His Critics. Open Court. pp. 56–7. ISBN 9780812697698.
- bethinking.org (27 June 2006). "Life after God? - The Ethics of Peter Singer".
- Singer, Peter (1 January 1995). "How Are We to Live?: Ethics in an Age of Self-Interest". Oxford University Press – via PhilPapers.