Macginitiea

Macginitiea Temporal range:
Macginitiea gracilis
Scientific classification
Kingdom:	Plantae
Clade:	Tracheophytes
Clade:	Angiosperms
Clade:	Eudicots
Order:	Proteales
Family:	Platanaceae
Genus:	†Macginitiea Wolfe & Wehr (1987)
Type species
Macginitiea gracilis
Species
See text

Macginitiea is an extinct genus in the family Platanaceae ranging from the Late Paleocene to Late Eocene of North America, known from the Clarno Formation of central Oregon and other areas ranging from California to Texas and North to Alberta. The genus is strictly used to describe leaves, but has been found in close association with other fossil platanoid organs, which collectively have been used for whole plant reconstructions. Macginitiea and its associated organs are important as together they comprise one of the most well-documented and ubiquitous fossil plants, particularly in the Paleogene of North America.

Because paleobotanical material is often found in disarticulation, different species names are often used to refer to different organs (e.g. leaves, fruits, wood) even if those organs might have belonged to the same plant. When these organ species are considered together as a whole plant, the study is known as a whole plant reconstruction. Some localities have enough co-occurrences of different fossil plant organs that whole plant reconstructions are possible, one example being the Cercidiphyllum-like Joffrea from the Joffre Bridge locality of Alberta, Canada.

Discovery and naming

The genus Macginitiea was named after the prominent paleobotanist Harry MacGinitie, who was the first person to suggest the close relationship of Macginitiea to the family Platanaceae. Though fossils of Macginitiea were originally classified under the genus Aralia, MacGinitie noticed that the venation patterns of Aralia angustiloba more closely resembled that of Platanus rather than Aralia, and reclassified Aralia angustiloba as Platanophyllum angustiloba. Later, Jack Wolfe and Wesley Wehr found that the genus Platanophyllum to be problematic, first being named for Cretaceous fossils of uncertain affiliation with the family, and therefore erected the new genus Macginitiea for these leaves.

Description

Palinactinodromous primary venation.

Macginitiea leaves are readily recognizable by their three to nine, equally spaced, palmate lobes. Like other Platanaceae, Macginitiea has palinactinodromous primary venation, a type of venation wherein primary veins fork multiple times. Macginitiea also has an inflated petiole base, which in modern counterparts encloses the underlying axillary buds for the next year, indicating their deciduous nature. The branching of primary veins often occurs basally, rather than suprabasally (as encountered in some modern species). Although the secondary veins of modern Platanus are usually straight, the secondary veins of Macginitiea are so regular and prominent compared to other platanoids that this recognizable "chevron" pattern has been considered a primary characteristic of the species. Margins are usually entire in all Macginitiea species, but can sometimes have minor teeth.

Macginitiea differs from modern Platanus with its often greater number of lobes and narrower angle between adjacent primary veins.

Different species of Macginitiea can be distinguished on the basis of lobe depth, extent of chevrons, prevalence of teeth, and partly lobe number. In total, 5 species of Macginitiea leaves have been described.

Species	Locality	Age	Number of lobes	Depth of sinuses	angle between primaries	Chevroning	Marginal teeth	Basal lobes	Image
M. angustiloba	Clarno Formation, Oregon	Eocene	5-7(-9)	40-70%	~15-40°	Entire leaf	Rarely	Uncommon
M. basilobata	Fort Union Formation, Montana	Paleocene	3	Approx 38%	~30-50°	Basal	none	Frequent
M. gracilis	Klondike Mountain Formation Republic Washington, Western U.S.	Paleocene - Eocene	3-5	~30-45%	~15-30°	entire	none	Rare
M. grandifolia	Kinkil Series, Russia	Eocene	5	50%?	40°	basal?	yes	?
M. latiloba	Kamchik & Tkaprovayam Formations, Russia	Eocene	3	?	~20-40°	Basal(?)	present	none
M. nascens	Fort Union Formation, South Dakota, USA	Paleocene	3	?	~20-40°	Basal (?)	yes	Absent
M. nobilis	Paskapoo Formation, Alberta, Canada	Paleocene	3	around 30%	30-35° Basally actinodromous	basal	yes	occasional
M. rannii	Aycross Formation, Wyoming, USA	Ypresian	3-5	45-65%	~45-75°	Basal	yes, some compound	Frequent
M. rileyi	Fayette Sandstone, Texas, USA San Jose Formation, New Mexico, USA	Eocene	5-7	~30%	~35-40°	(?)	rare	Frequent
M. whitneyi	Chalk Bluffs, California	Ypresian	5-7 (7-9)	very shallow, 25-35%	Palinactinodromous, 15-30°	Entire leaf	Absent	occasional
M. wyomingensis	Green River Formation, Western U.S.	Ypresian	5	~36%	15-30°	Entire	yes compound	Absent

Table adapted from Pigg and Stockey (1991) with updates from Huegle and Correa Narvaez (2023)

Whole plant reconstructions

The Clarno Plane

The "Clarno Plane" was established as an informal name to refer to the whole plant recognized from five fossil species: Macginitiea angustiloba (leaves), Plataninium haydenii (wood), Macginicarpa glabra (infructescences), Platananthus synandrus (staminate inflorescences), and Macginistemon mikanoides (isolated stamen clusters). The Clarno Plane is known from the west coast of North America across several states, including central California, Oregon, and northern Washington.

Like the modern Platanus, Macginicarpa has clusters of five carpels per floret. However, in striking contrast to the modern, Macginicarpa flowers have a well-developed perianth and fruits lack the prominent dispersal hairs characteristic of the modern Platanus. Modern carpel numbers are more variable than the consistent five of Macginicarpa, ranging from four to nine.

Photograph of Plataninium haydenii from the Clarno Formation of Oregon.

Staminate flowers (Platananthus synandrus) have an even more developed perianth than pistillate flowers, but similarly have more consistent numbers of parts than the modern, with 5 stamens per floret. P. synandrus pollen appears to be smaller than pollen from modern Platanus. Platananthus synandrus is also distinctive from extant Platanus for the elongation of its connectives, extensions of filament tissue that cover or divide an anther. In Platananthus and in modern Platanus, peltate (shield-like) connectives cover the tops of anthers, but the connectives of Platananthus are 4 to 5 times the length of the modern. Stamens are connate (fused) within each floret, causing them to be shed in clusters of stamen bundles, rather than one at a time as in modern Platanus species. Stamen bundles associated with Macginitiea have been put under the genus Macginistemon.

Plataninium wood is similar, but has wider rays and more scalariform (ladder-like) perforations than that of recent species.

As of 1986, Dr. Steven Manchester said that "The Clarno Plane is currently the most completely documented fossil angiosperm species, known morphologically and anatomically from wood, leaves, pistillate and staminate inflorescences, fruits, and pollen." Associations of multiple organs of the Clarno Plane in various combinations have been found in "more than ten localities" throughout western North America, as of 2008. Other platanoid leaves have since been found in association with reproductive structures, including leaves such as Platimeliphyllum, Ettingshausenia, Evaphyllum, Platanus neptuni, Platanus nobilis, and Sapindopsis.

The Joffre Plane

The Paleocene fossil leaf species Platanus nobilis was established as a species intermediate between Macginitiea and modern Platanus. However, differences between P. nobilis and Macginitiea were later considered too minor to justify placing P. nobilis in a different genus, particularly since P. nobilis was associated with Macginicarpa inflorescences. As such, P. nobilis was reassigned to Macginitiea nobilis.

The "Joffre Plane" as a whole plant reconstruction includes leaves from Macginitiea nobilis, pistillate inflorescences and infructescences from Macginicarpa manchesteri, and staminate inflorescences of Platananthus speirsae. Macginitiea nobilis is set apart from other Macginitiea species by its fewer number of lobes (usually 3, instead of 5-9) and less distinct "chevron" venation pattern. M. nobilis has been found in various stages of development from the Joffre Bridge locality, from seedlings with cotyledonous leaves to mature, true, trilobate leaves.

Ecology

Macginitiea has been known to be the dominant element in many Eocene floras. The Clarno Plane is thought to have occupied open, riparian habitats, similar to that of modern Platanus. They also have been found several times in co-occurrence with Cercidiphyllum-like plants. The association with Cercidiphyllum suggests that the Clarno Plane was tolerant of full sunlight and poorly developed soils.

Artist's depiction of the Eocene Clarno Nut Beds by Larry Felder. Key to illustrated taxa: 1. Cercidiphyllum (tree); 2. Ensete (banana plant); 3. Sabalites (extinct fan palm); 4. Patriofelis (cat-like creodont, the size of a modern panther); 5. Macginicarpa (sycamore); 6. Orohippus (early horse); 7. Dioon (cycad); 8. Cornus (flowering dogwood); 9. Juglans (walnuts); 10. Pinus (pine tree); 11. not labeled in mural; 12. Pristichampsus sp. (3 m long crocodile); 13. Ictalurus cf. (freshwater catfishes); 14. Telmatherium (1.25m brontothere); 15. Castanea (chestnut); 16. Magnolia (magnolia tree); 17. Hyrachyus ('running rhino'); 18. Lauraceae (laurel tree); 19. Cicadidae on Vitis (cicada on grapevine); 20. Meliosma (aguacatillo).

External links

• Media related to Macginitiea at Wikimedia Commons