Nick & Nora
|Nick & Nora|
Original cast recording
|Lyrics||Richard Maltby, Jr.|
|Basis||Characters created by Dashiell Hammett in his novel The Thin Man|
The plot involves witty and urbane high society couple Nick and Nora Charles, characters created by Dashiell Hammett in his novel The Thin Man, which inspired six films, a radio show, and a television series. In this version, the two are attempting to solve the murder of a bookkeeper on a film production in Hollywood. Crucially, the musical departs from the formula of previous incarnations, defined by the chemistry between Nick and Nora, by creating a subplot of marital woes and tensions between them.
Citing high costs, the producers opted to replace out-of-town tryouts (originally scheduled for the Mechanic Theatre, Baltimore, Maryland) with a longer than usual nine-week preview period of 71 previews in New York City. During this time the musical underwent extensive script rewrites, multiple song replacements, and a major cast change. (It was surpassed by a record of 15 weeks of previews for the Broadway musical Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark which finally opened on Broadway in June 2011.)
The Broadway production, directed by Laurents and choreographed by Tina Paul, finally opened on December 8, 1991 at the Marquis Theatre where, unable to overcome the bad publicity and brutal reviews, it ran for only nine performances. The cast included Barry Bostwick (Nick Charles), Joanna Gleason (Nora Charles), Christine Baranski, Debra Monk, Faith Prince, and Chris Sarandon.
In his memoir Original Story By, Laurents confessed he didn't realize until the show was in previews that the characters of Nick and Nora Charles were identified so closely with William Powell and Myrna Loy that the public would have difficulty accepting anyone else in the roles. He also felt the lengthy preview period, during which theatre gossips and newspaper columnists spread largely unfounded rumors about the show's mounting problems, helped destroy any chances of success it may have had.
- Act I
- "Is There Anything Better Than Dancing?"
- "Everybody Wants to Do a Musical"
- "Max's Story"
- "As Long As You're Happy"
- "People Get Hurt"
- "May the Best Man Win"
- "Look Who's Alone Now"
- Act II
- "Let's Go Home"
- "Busy Night at Lorraine's"
- "Boom Chicka Boom"
- "Married Life"
In his review in Time, William A. Henry III called the production "a crashing bore - cranky and arbitrary as a love story, tedious and pointless as a murder mystery, ham-handed as comedy, clubfooted as dance, at best wanly pleasant as music." He added, "A few scenes work, some quite well. The final 10 minutes achieve a truth and simplicity underscoring the barren brittleness of what has gone before. But ultimately the show fails at its most basic task: making audiences care about, or for that matter simply believe in, the characters."
Frank Rich in his review in the New York Times wrote:"...this musical will no doubt always be remembered, and not without fondness, for its troubled preview period, its much-postponed opening, its hassles with snooping journalists and its conflict with the city's Consumer Affairs Commissioner. Indeed, the story of 'Nick and Nora' in previews, should it ever be fully known, might in itself make for a riotous, 1930's-style screwball-comedy musical. But the plodding show that has emerged from all this tumult is, a few bright spots notwithstanding, an almost instantly forgettable mediocrity."
- Wynn Rousuck, J. "'Nick & Nora' cancels engagement at Mechanic" Baltimore Sun, November 14, 1990
- Wynn Rousuck, J. "Promoting 'Nick & Nora'" Baltimore Sun, May 22, 1991
- "'Nick & Nora' production notes" Daryl Roth Productions, accessed January 14, 2011
- Willis, John. "'Nick & Nora'"Theatre World 1991-1992, Volume 48, Hal Leonard Corporation, 1994, ISBN 1-55783-142-4, p. 18, accessed January 14, 2011
- Mandelbaum, Ken. "Ken Mandelbaum's Musicals On Disc: Christine Andreas and Nick & Nora" playbill.com, 1997
- Laurents, Arthur, Original Story By. New York: Alfred A. Knopf 2000. ISBN 0-375-40055-9, pp. 417-18
- Henry, William A.Time Review Time Magazine
- Rich, Frank. "Review/Theater; Bostwick and Gleason in 'Nick and Nora'" New York Times, December 9, 1991