Port Arthur (wargame)
Port Arthur is a board wargame published by Game Designers' Workshop (GDW) in 1975 that simulates combat during the Russo-Japanese War of 1904-1905. Port Arthur was part of a two-game collection titled The Russo-Japanese War. The second game in the box was Tsushima, which covered the naval combat during the war. The two games could either be played separately, or combined into one master game.
Background
[edit]The expanding geographical interests of Russia and Japan collided in the late 19th century, and resulted in a formal declaration of war in 1904. In 1904 and 1905, the opposing forces engaged in both land and sea combat in which Japanese forces proved they were the equal and often superior to the European forces.[1]
Description
[edit]Port Arthur is a two-player game in which one player controls Russian forces and the other player controls Japanese forces in the struggle for the vital Port Arthur.[2] If not played together with Tsushima, then naval combat becomes an off-map abstraction.[3] On its own, with only a 22" x 28* paper hex grid map and 240 die-cut counters, the game is not complex. If played in concert with Tsushima, some have suggested making it a four-player game, with two naval players and two land generals.[4]
Gameplay
[edit]The game uses a simple "I Go, You Go" system of alternating turns, where the Japanese player goes first, followed by the Russian player. Each has the following phases:[3]
- Movement
- Combat
- Supply and Reinforcement
This completes one game turn, which represents one month of game time.
Publication history
[edit]In 1976, GDW published The Russo-Japanese War, a two-game collection of Tsushima (naval combat) and Port Arthur (land combat). Both were designed by Marc Miller, and featured the artwork of Rich Banner.[5]
Following the demise of SPI, Hobby Japan acquired the rights to The Russo-Japanese War and printed a Japanese-language version in Command #55 (March–April 2004).[5]
Reception
[edit]In the 1977 book The Comprehensive Guide to Board Wargaming, Nicholas Palmer commented "The crucial struggle is for the port itself, the only warm-water one available to the Russians in the area; this makes the joint game with Tsushima particularly interesting, though Port Arthur can be played on its own with abstract naval rules." Palmer noted several issues with the rules about supply and stacking.[2]
In Issue 10 of Phoenix, Ralph Vickers was highly critical of the historicity of the game, and he also found issues with the rules for troop movement. After a lengthy and critical analysis, he concluded, "If GDW happened to ask me what I thought of this game before they published it, I would have looked at all that talent and said, 'Well, the game's okay, but you guys can do better than this. Get back to the drawing board!"[3]
In Issue 27 of Moves, Richard Berg complained about the "loose" style of the rules that he thought had been written "very explanatorially, rather than legalistically", saying, "If a new person picked up [Tsushima], they wouldn't know what the hell [the game designers] were talking about. [...] The main problem with rules that are loosely written, or written in a rather offhand fashion, is that the designer makes assumptions that you cannot assume that the player is going to make."[6]
In The Guide to Simulations/Games for Education and Training, Martin Campion warned teachers looking to use this game in the classroom that "Some of the rules need to be interpreted in the spirit of the game rather than by their letter, so active refereeing is necessary if you want to use this game."[7]
Other reviews and commentary
[edit]- The Wargamer Vol.2 #18
- Perfidious Albion #16
References
[edit]- ^ Connaughton, R. M. (1988). The War of the Rising Sun and the Tumbling Bear: A Military History of the Russo-Japanese War 1904–5. London: Routledge. ISBN 0-415-00906-5.
- ^ a b Palmer, Nicholas (1977). The Comprehensive Guide to Board Wargaming. London: Sphere Books. p. 167.
- ^ a b c Vickers, Ralph (March–April 1977). "The Russo-Japanese War". Phoenix. No. 10. pp. 6–9.
- ^ Easton, William (March 1978). "War Games and Maps". In Murphy, Mary (ed.). Bulletin: Geography and Map Division. Washington DC: Special Libraries Association. p. 23.
- ^ a b "Port Arthur(1975)". boardgamegeek.com. Retrieved 2022-12-22.
- ^ Berg, Richard (June–July 1976). "Cases: SPI Staff Seminar on Game Rules". Moves. No. 27. p. 11.
- ^ Campion, Martin (1980). "The Russo-Japanese War". In Horn, Robert E.; Cleaves, Ann (eds.). The Guide to Simulations/Games for Education and Training. Beverly Hills CA: Sage Publications. p. 511. ISBN 0-8039-1375-3.