The Mind Benders
Book Cover, 1971 Edition, hard cover
|Publisher||Neville Spearman Limited|
|Media type||Print (Hardcover)|
|LC Class||BP605.S2 V68|
The Mind Benders was written by Cyril Vosper, a Scientologist of 14 years who had become disillusioned, Published in 1971 (hardback, Neville Spearman, ISBN 0-85435-061-6) and reprinted in 1973 (softcover, Mayflower, ISBN 0-583-12249-3), it was the first book on Scientology to be written by an ex-member and the first critical book on Scientology to be published (narrowly beating Inside Scientology by Robert Kaufman). It describes the lower levels of Scientology and its philosophy in detail (it does not go into the Operating Thetan levels) and also includes the story of Vosper's expulsion from the Church.
Attempted bans by Scientology
In the UK
In 1972, the Church of Scientology sued to prevent publication, claiming that as a condition of taking the Special Briefing Course at Saint Hill, Vosper had agreed not to divulge its content to anyone who wasn't "Clear". Lord Denning dismissed the case, arguing that the material was sufficiently dangerous for the public interest to override the confidentiality agreement.
The hardback edition was rushed to print owing to the legal action. Vosper regarded the paperback — which was properly proofread and had an extra chapter on the litigation — as the authoritative edition. To this day, the case Hubbard v Vosper is a staple in many classes studying copyright law.
Vosper referenced the legal troubles that the 1971 edition of the book encountered, by titling the 1973 edition The Mind Benders: The Book They Tried to Ban.
The Church of Scientology of Canada attempted to ban the book in libraries in Canada. In June 1974, libraries were advised that if they do not remove the books: Scientology: The Now Religion, Inside Scientology, The Scandal of Scientology and The Mind Benders from their shelves, they would be named in a lawsuit. Two different library boards in Ontario, Canada had been served with writs.
After obtaining out-of-court settlements of US$7,500 and US$500 and apologies from the publishers of two of the works (Dell Publishing and Tower Publications), Scientology further threatened to sue any library or bookstore that carried them. After certain libraries in Canada refused to remove the books from their shelves, they were sued by Scientology. One Canadian library reported the theft of a book critical of Scientology from its shelves.
- Jenkins, Peter (1997), Counselling, Psychotherapy and the Law, SAGE, ISBN 978-0-8039-7987-1
- Chapter 5 The US doctrine of 'fair use' and the UK 'fair dealing' provisions Archived 2007-09-27 at the Wayback Machine, Copyright Law Review Committee, August 23, 2004.
- Libraries Face Libel Threat, Winnipeg Free Press, 27 June 1974
- Anti-Scientology Books Targets of Lawsuits, The Library Journal, November 1, 1974.
- Censorship in British Columbia Archived 2007-03-18 at the Wayback Machine, BCLA Intellectual Freedom Committee, 1970-1979., retrieved 2/28/07.
- The Mind Benders (complete book)
- Cyril Vosper interview, 3-RRR Liars' Club, 10am-11am Sun 03 Sep 1995 (transcript)
- Researching New Religious Movements: Responses and Redefinitions by Elisabeth Arweck, p. 114 (required Google login)
- Hubbard v. Vosper (1972) 2 QB 84 - seminal copyright case