A Short Film About Love
|A Short Film About Love|
Theatrical release poster
|Directed by||Krzysztof Kieślowski|
|Produced by||Ryszard Chutkowski|
|Based on||Decalogue VI
by Krzysztof Kieślowski
|Music by||Zbigniew Preisner|
|Edited by||Ewa Smal|
Zespol Filmowy "Tor"
|Distributed by||Film Polski|
A Short Film About Love (Polish: Krótki film o miłości) is a Polish romantic drama film directed by Krzysztof Kieślowski and starring Grażyna Szapołowska and Olaf Lubaszenko. Written by Krzysztof Kieślowski and Krzysztof Piesiewicz, the film is about a young post office worker deeply in love with a promiscuous older woman who lives in an adjacent apartment building. After spying on her through a telescope, he meets and declares his love for this jaded woman who long ago gave up on believing in love. She responds to his innocence by initiating him on the basic fact of life—that there is no love, only sex. A Short Film About Love is an expanded film version of Decalogue VI, part of Kieślowski's 1988 Polish language ten-part television series, The Decalogue. The film is set in Warsaw.
Nineteen-year-old Tomek (Olaf Lubaszenko) is living in an apartment complex in Warsaw with his godmother—staying in her son's room while he's away. Raised in an orphanage, the shy Tomek has few friends and works as a postal clerk. Tomek has been spying on a beautiful older woman, Magda (Grazyna Szapolowska), who lives in an adjacent apartment complex. Using a telescope, he watches her every night performing mundane tasks, working on her artwork, and entertaining men. To get closer to her, he slips fake postal notices in her mailbox for a nonexistent money order at his post office. He also calls her anonymously to hear her voice. Tomek's obsession is focused more on her everyday activities rather than her sex life; when he sees her becoming sexual with men, he trains the telescope away and does not watch.
Tomek learns there is a problem with the milk deliveries for Magda's apartment complex, so he takes the delivery job to be closer to her. One night he sees her return home after breaking up with her latest boyfriend, spilling a bottle of milk, and then weeping over another failed relationship. Later, Tomek asks his godmother, "Why do people cry?" After receiving another fake postal notice, Magda has a confrontation with the postmistress who accuses her of extortion. When Magda walks away upset, Tomek follows her and admits that he has been leaving the fake postal notices, that he saw her crying, and that he's been watching her. That night, Magda arranges her bed so that Tomek can see her with another boyfriend. When they're in bed, she tells him that they're being watched by someone across the way. The boyfriend rushes down to the street, calls out to Tomek who comes downstairs, and then punches him in the face for peeping.
The next day, while delivering milk to Magda, Tomek admits that he loves her and that he expects nothing in return. Overwhelmed by his feelings, Tomek rushes up to the roof of the building, and then returns to Magda's apartment and asks her for a date—and she accepts. An elated Tomek races through the courtyard with his milkcart. During their date at a cafe, Magda learns that Tomek has been watching her for a year and that he stole letters mailed to her by an old boyfriend. At first she's upset, but then she dismisses it saying, "What does it matter." In response to his earlier declaration of love, she tells him that love doesn't exist—only sex. She shows him how to caress her hands the way lovers do.
Later that night at her apartment, after she showers and changes into a short bathrobe, he gives her a small gift, but she says she's not a good person and doesn't deserve gifts. Crouching in front of him, she guides his hands onto her thighs and he has an orgasm. Magda says, "Love ... that's all it is." After Tomek rushes out of her apartment embarrassed and upset, Magda feels guilty and tries to communicate to him at her window—gesturing for him to call her and holding up a sign that reads, "Come back. Sorry." But there is no response. Back in his apartment, Tomek cuts his wrists with a razor blade. Later, Magda comes to Tomek's apartment to return the coat he left behind and learns from his godmother that he tried to kill himself and was taken to a hospital. Magda tells her, "I think I hurt him." Tomek's godmother shows her Tomek's room and his telescope and tells her, "He's fallen in love with you." When asked if he's "fallen for the wrong woman," Magda responds, "Yes."
In the coming days, Magda is unable to find Tomek—she is clearly worried and concerned about his wellbeing. One night, she receives a phone call, and thinking it is Tomek, she acknowledges that he was right about love (the call is actually from someone with phone trouble). After days of waiting and watching Tomek's window with her small binoculars, she finally sees he's returned. Magda goes to Tomek's apartment and his godmother shows her to his room where she sees Tomek sleeping, his wrists still bandaged. The godmother prevents her from getting too close to him—even preventing her from touching his bandaged wrist.[Note 1] Noticing the telescope, Magda looks through it toward her own apartment and imagines what Tomek must have seen that night, watching her come home, spilling the milk, and weeping over another failed relationship. Then she closes her eyes and imagines Tomek in her apartment with her, reaching out to comfort her—and she smiles.
- Grażyna Szapołowska as Magda
- Olaf Lubaszenko as Tomek
- Stefania Iwinska as Godmother
- Piotr Machalica as Roman
- Hanna Chojnacka as Miroslawa
- Artur Barcis as Young Man
- Stanislaw Gawlik as Postman
- Krzysztof Koperski as Gasman in Magda's Apartment
The film is based on Kieślowski's Decalogue VI, with minor changes and expansions to the script. The most significant change is to the ending, which was rewritten at the suggestion of lead actress Grażyna Szapołowska, who wanted the film to have a "fairytale ending". The original version ends with Tomek back at work, recovered from his attempted suicide, and telling Magda that he does not watch her anymore. The film ends with Magda's more developed concern for Tomek mirroring his earlier obsession with her. The film concludes in Tomek's room after his return from hospital. She looks through his telescope into her own apartment and Kieślowski replays an earlier scene of Magda crying in her kitchen, which had led Tomek to reveal his feelings to her, only this time she is joined and comforted by Tomek. Like Kieślowski's other Decalogue films, it features the mysterious angelic Man in White.
- Warsaw, Poland
A Short Film About Love received very positive critical reviews, with many of the critics noting that the film points to Kieslowski's later masterworks. In his review in The New York Times, Stephan Holden wrote that the film "which has rich, subtly shaded performances by Mr. Lubaszenko and Miss Szapolowska, has a bleak eloquence."
In his review in the San Francisco Chronicle, Edward Guthmann called the film "well-crafted and satisfying" and prefigured Kieślowski's film Three Colors: Red.
Also reviewing at the San Francisco Chronicle, Gary Kamiya wrote, "Kieslowski has crafted a compelling portrait of love, that weed that forces its strange way through life's hardest cement."
In his review on Cinema Sights, James Blake Ewing called the film "a complex and perplexing examination of a simple rule" and praised outcome:
It's this synthesis of emotionally powerful storytelling and cinematic overdrive that makes A Short Film About Love such an unforgettable and unrelenting experience on every level. By the end, you’ve been rocked about and blown away by the power of the piece. And yet, somehow, it’s with a grace. Kieslowski doesn’t bring you down with a sledgehammer blow, but by softly and slowly picking away until he breaks you down.
On the aggregate reviewer web site Rotten Tomatoes, the film received a 100% positive rating from top film critics based on 13 reviews, and a 93% positive audience rating based on 5,273 reviews.
Awards and nominations
- 1988 Polish Film Festival Award for Best Actress (Grazyna Szapolowska) Won
- 1988 Polish Film Festival Award for Best Cinematography (Witold Adamek) Won
- 1988 Polish Film Festival Award for Best Supporting Actress (Stefania Iwinska) Won
- 1988 Polish Film Festival Golden Lion Award (Krzysztof Kieślowski) Won
- 1991 Belgian Syndicate of Cinema Critics - Grand Prix Won
- 1988 San Sebastián International Film Festival OCIC Award (Krzysztof Kieślowski) Won
- 1988 San Sebastián International Film Festival Special Prize of the Jury (Krzysztof Kieślowski) Won
- 1989 São Paulo International Film Festival Audience Award for Best Feature (Krzysztof Kieślowski) Won
- 1988 National Board of Review of Motion Pictures Award Nomination for Outstanding Achievement in Foreign Film Award
- 1988 Venice Film Festival FIPRESCI Award Nomination
- 1988 Chicago Film Critics Association Award Nomination for Best Foreign Language Film
A Short Film About Love was remade in Hindi in the 2002 film Ek Chhotisi Love Story.
- The opening scene of the film shows Magda's hand trying to touch Tomek's bandaged wrist as a flash-forward to this final scene.
- "A Short Film About Love". Internet Movie Database. Retrieved February 26, 2012.
- Insdorf 1999, p. 97.
- "Full cast and crew for A Short Film About Love". Internet Movie Database. Retrieved February 26, 2012.
- Grażyna Szapołowska, 2003 interview on American and Artificial Eye Region 2 DVD releases of A Short Film About Love.
- Holden, Stephan (December 29, 1995). "A Short Film About Love: Kieslowski's Drama of a Voyeur in Love". The New York Times. Retrieved February 26, 2012.
- Guthmann, Edward (August 4, 1995). "Short Film That's Long on Desire". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved February 26, 2012.
- Kamiya, Gary (August 4, 1995). "Kieslowski's Short Film has substance". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved February 26, 2012.
- "A Short Film About Love". Cinema Sights. Retrieved February 26, 2012.
- "A Short Film About Love". Rotten Tomatoes. Retrieved February 26, 2012.
- "Awards for A Short Film About Love". Internet Movie Database. Retrieved February 26, 2012.
- A Short Film About Love at the Internet Movie Database
- A Short Film About Love at AllMovie
- A Short Film About Love at Rotten Tomatoes