Edward Solly

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
For other people of the same name, see Edward Solly (disambiguation).
Portrait of Edward Solly, (Gemäldegalerie, Berlin)

Edward Solly (25 April 1776 – 2 December 1844) was an English merchant living in Berlin, who amassed an unprecedented collection of Italian Trecento and Quattrocento paintings and outstanding examples of Early Netherlandish painting, at a time when those schools were still largely unappreciated.[1] In 1821 Gustav Waagen assisted the purchase for the new art museum being created at Berlin, of about 3000 works from Solly's collection, 677 of them forming a core of the Gemäldegalerie, Berlin. Solly acquired a second collection during his years in London after 1821. Solly is also credited for having undertaken a perilous journey to deliver the first news of Napoleon's defeat at Leipzig to the English.[2]

Solly was a younger brother in an English merchant family headed by Isaac Solly that were engaged in the Baltic timber trade, with offices in the city of London.[3] As Non-Conformists the family suffered social restrictions in the higher levels of English society. During the Napoleonic Wars the firm secured immense contracts for the supply of Prussian and Polish oak timber and ship's stores from the Baltic. Solly removed to Stockholm and then in 1813 to Berlin, overseeing the family firm's bulk purchases on the part of the European continent not covered by Napoleon's Continental System. In Berlin he married the daughter of Auguste Krüger in 1816. His great personal charm and intelligence opened the highest social circles, and as his business affairs prospered he was on good terms with ministry officials, the Prussian court, artists,[4] connoisseurs and intellectuals.[5]

In his travels he began to take an interest in paintings. The social turmoil of the wars and the dissolution of monasteries brought many works of art onto the market, and Solly proved a discerning buyer, concerned with the provenance[6] and documentation of works he bought, to an extent unusual in his generation.[7] Though he owned one of the finest interior views by Pieter de Hooch[8] and possibly Vermeer's Lady Standing at a Virginal (National Gallery, London),[9] both falling within the desirable contemporary category of "cabinet pictures", he was not drawn to the Seicento and Baroque Old Masters that formed the main other interest of contemporary collectors and connoisseurs, but rather to the early Byzantinising Italian paintings of the 13th and 14th centuries, which had been preserved largely in the churches and monasteries for which they had been commissioned. He had a judicious eye also for early Netherlandish painting: his most famous purchase in that field were the wings of the Ghent Altarpiece of Hubert and Jan van Eyck, which was sold by the cathedral canons soon after it had been returned to Ghent in 1816; Solly purchased the panels through the paintings dealer Nieuwenhuys.[10]

Solly and the firm suffered a major setback when twenty of their merchantmen, running the Napoleonic blockade on behalf of the Allies, were captured by Danes within the Napoleonic system and taken to Copenhagen. Only after years of pressuring was any compensation effected.

Raphael's Solly Madonna

Solly continued collecting nevertheless, increasingly with the idea that his paintings might be purchased by the Prussian State, to form a public collection.[11] In 1815 Frederick William III had bought the remains of the Giustiniani collection for just such a purpose, but resisted this purchase. Solly's financial situation became straitened. After years of negotiations, in 1821 Solly's entire collection of some 3,000 pictures was bought for the newly founded Alte Nationalgalerie and 677 paintings were selected for display in the museum; others were hung in the Hohenzollern palaces to replace those that had been removed to the museum. Though Solly was an early admirer of early Netherlandish painting, Solly's first collection was mostly Italian, including Raphael's Solly Madonna (illustration, right). Under National Socialism, some of Solly's Italian pictures were traded for those by native German masters and, some through Duveen, found their way into the Samuel Henry Kress and Andrew W. Mellon collections; thus Fra Filippo Lippi's Madonna of the Niche[12] and Duccio's Nativity triptych are both now in the National Gallery, Washington.[13]

Following the successful sale that he had urged so long, in 1821 Solly moved to London, where he retired from shipping and dealt in works of art, which filled his house at 7, Curzon Street, Mayfair.[14] His interests narrowed to the High Renaissance.[15] He acted on occasion as advisor to John Bowes, whose collection forms the Bowes Museum.[16] Often sensing himself in financial trouble, in eight London sales between 1825 and 1837 Solly sold paintings, drawings and engravings, according to Frits Lugt,[17] although the records now online through the Getty Provenance Index show a total of 1306 lots in many auctions, with small paintings of the Dutch Golden Age predominating, at least numerically, in a very varied range of works.[18]

When the cream of his collection, those paintings he had reserved for himself, were sold by order of his heirs, his daughters Sarah and Lavinia and his son Edward Solly F.R.S.,[19] at Christie's, 8 May 1847,[20] a few were held back, or "bought in" at the sale when they failed to reach their reserve, as was one of the two works attributed to "Lionardo da Vinci" (sic). Sarah Solly donated five of the paintings to the National Gallery in 1879,[21] including a Portrait of Giovanni della Volta with his Wife and Children by Lorenzo Lotto (bought in at the 1847 sale), and two Dutch Golden Age paintings.[22]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ "His collection contained a number of pictures of the first importance, belonging to schools which were universally neglected a hundred years ago," observed a Times correspondent on the occasion of the new Berlin museum gallery opening (The Times, 22 November 1905, quoted in J. Raymond Solly, Notes & Queries 12 March 1910.
  2. ^ The full account of the perilous journey undertaken in "the face of hostile forces and the disturbed state of the country" to delivery the despatch into the hands of the Foreign Secretary Lord Castlereagh is recounted by his son Edward Solly, F.R.S. in (News, and Newspapers" ') The Bibliographer, Elliot Stock, March 1884; Volumes 5–6, pg. 91.
  3. ^ The biographical notes are largely drawn from Frank Herrmann, 1972. The English as Collectors: "Edward Solly" pp. 202–08; Herrmann rediscovered Solly's career in articles in The Connoisseur April, May, July, September 1967, September 1968 and April 1971.
  4. ^ Marsha L. Morton, "Johann Erdmann Hummel and the Flemish Primitives: the forging of a Biedermeier style and intellectuals", Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte, 1989.
  5. ^ Herrmann 1972.
  6. ^ An outstanding provenance is that of Filippo Lippi's signed Adoration commissioned by Cosimo de' Medici for the family chapel in Palazzo Medici and sold in 1814.(Palazzo Medici Adoration).
  7. ^ Frank Herrmann, 1991. "Peel and Solly: two nineteenth-century art collectors and their sources of supply", Journal of the History of Collections, 3.1 pp. 81–96.
  8. ^ Sold from the Berlin museum about 1830, it was sold in 1992 for £4.4 million (Geraldine Norman, "The Art Market", The Independent, 20 December 1992).
  9. ^ Essential Vermeer: Lady Standing at a Virginal
  10. ^ One of the Solly paintings at the Kaiser Friedrich Museum, Berlin, it was returned to Saint Bavo, Ghent, as part of German reparations under the Treaty of Lausanne, 1920.
  11. ^ Maria Dietl, 1993. "The Picture Gallery of Berlin: The Formation of the Solly Collection," in iovanni Morelli e la cultura dei conoscitori. Atti del Convegno internazionale, Bergamo 1987, Bergamo, pp. 49–59.
  12. ^ Meryle Secrest, 2004. Duveen: a life in art, p. 457; National Gallery: Madonna and Child, Fra Filippo Lippi
  13. ^ Carpaccio's Flight into Egypt at the National Gallery also came from Solly's collection, de-accessioned by the Kaiser Friedrich Museum (National Gallery: Carpaccio, Flight into Egypt)
  14. ^ The architect of the Berlin museum Karl Friedrich Schinkel and the art historian Gustav Waagen were his guests there, in 1821 and 1835 (Waagen, Treasures of Art in Great Britain, Letter I).
  15. ^ "Mr. Solly is one of those rare characters who have attained the complete conviction that the works of the historical painters of the time of Raphael are at a height of perfection with which no others can bear a comparison" (Waagen, Works of Art and Artists in England, London 1838, vol. II, letter XVI dated 10 July 1838, which includes descriptions of some paintings in Solly's London collection)
  16. ^ Herrmann 1972.
  17. ^ Frits Lugt, Répertoire des catalogues de ventes publiques; Hermann 1972.
  18. ^ Getty Provenance Database search page – enter "Solly" for "Buyer or Seller Name"]
  19. ^ Edward Solly, F.R.S. (1843), F.S.A. 11 October 1819 – 2 April 1886) a professor of chemistry, was a book collector, whose library was sold at Sotheby's after his death in 1886; he was a frequent contributor to Notes and Queries on genealogical and literary points, and a founder of the Folk-Lore Society (Obit. The Antiquary 13, 1886, p. 228; Solly 1910).
  20. ^ There were 42 lots, most of which had appeared in the privately printed A Descriptive Catalogue of some Paintings of the Rafaelle Period; the sale was reported in The Art Union, 1847, pp215f (Solly 1910). All the catalogue descriptions and prices are now online at the Getty Provenance Index.
  21. ^ Jordanna Bailkin, 2004. "Picturing feminism, selling liberalism", in Bettina Messias Carbonell, Museum studies: an anthology of contexts, p. 271 note 29.
  22. ^ National Gallery "key facts" for the Lotto; a search for "Solly" produces all five.