National fiscal policy response to the Great Recession

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Many nations of the world have enacted fiscal stimulus plans in response to the recent global recession. These nations have used different combinations of government spending and tax cuts to boost their sagging economies. Most of these plans are based on the Keynesian theory that deficit spending by governments can replace some of the demand lost during a recession and prevent the waste of economic resources idled by a lack of demand. The International Monetary Fund has recommended that countries implement fiscal stimulus measures equal to 2% of their GDP to help offset the global contraction.[1]

Americas[edit]

United States[edit]

In 2008 the United States Congress passed—and then-President George W. Bush signed—the Economic Stimulus Act of 2008, a $152 billion stimulus designed to help stave off a recession. The bill primarily consisted of $600 tax rebates to low and middle income Americans.[2]

The United States combined many stimulus measures into the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, a $787 billion bill covering a variety of expenditures from rebates on taxes to business investment. $184.9 billion will be spent in 2009, and $399.4 billion will be spent in 2010 with the remainder of the bill's appropriations spread over the rest of the decade.[3] Announcements of rescue plans were associated with positive returns whereas a public intervention in favor of a specific bank showed negative impacts.[4]

Asia[edit]

Japan[edit]

In April 2009 Japan announced a third stimulus plan of 15.4 trillion yen stimulus ($153 billion). This new plan includes 1.6 trillion yen investment in low-carbon technology, 1.9 trillion yen on employment programs, and 370 billion yen for new car subsidies.[5] The legislature responded to a request from Prime Minister Taro Aso for a stimulus that equal to 2% of GDP. Japan has been one of the hardest hit nations during the recession, having already experienced a lost decade when economic growth stagnated.[6] Japan's total stimulus amounts to 5% of its GDP. Since taking office, Prime Minister Aso has passed 25 trillion yen ($250bn) in stimulus.[7] Japan has basically exhausted its conventional monetary policy options with a near zero nominal interest rate.[8]

South Korea[edit]

South Korea 14 trillion won ($10.8bn) stimulus package in November 2008. The November package includes 4.6 trillion won for regional infrastructure and 3 trillion won in tax break—mainly for factory investment. South Korea's stimulus totaled [9]

In April 2009 South Korea enacted a "cash for clunkers" program that will give a tax break of 2.5 million won ($1,900) to drivers who replace a car nine years old or older with a new car.[10] The tax break will be in effect from May to December 2009 and is estimated to boost Hyundai sales from 530,000 to 580,000 and Kia sales from 327,000 to 357,000.[11]

South Korea's 2009 budget includes $13bn in employment stimulus including handouts, training, and infrastructure. South Korea's total stimulus in 2008-2009 amounts to about $69 trillion won ($52bn).[12]

Europe[edit]

European Union[edit]

The European Union passed a 200 billion euro plan with member countries developing their own national plans, worth 170bn to 200bn euro in total, and an EU-wide plan of 30bn euro coming from EU funding.[13] The European Commission recommends that member nations' stimulus plans amount to at least 1.2% of GDP.

Germany[edit]

Compared to other European nations, Germany is in a unique position: It has low debt, a high balance of trade, and an export driven economy. The recession has led to a decline in German exports, but Germany has the capacity to replace some of the export demand with domestic stimulus.[14] The Germans were initially hesitant to pass a large stimulus bill; however, in 2009, the Germans passed a 50bn euro stimulus bill that focused on taxes, a child tax credit, and spending on transportation and education.[15] Prior to the 2009 stimulus, one of Germany's largest stimulus efforts had been a scrappage program. The German stimulus program includes a "cash for clunkers" program that offers rebates of $3,172 to Germans who scrap their old cars for new, more efficient models.[16] The program totals about 5bn euros.[17]

Hungary[edit]

Hungary has a high level of debt and cannot effectively raise the money needed for deficit spending. They have unveiled a $7bn package of tax cuts and loan guarantees directed towards businesses, especially small and medium sized enterprises.[18]

The Netherlands[edit]

In November 2008 the Dutch government passed a 6bn euro plan that mainly consisted of tax breaks for businesses that made larger investments and hired short-term workers. The package also included a new program to help find work for the unemployed,[19] and faster public sector investment.[13] In January 2009 the Dutch added a variety of guarantees to help ensure and encourage exports, corporate loans, and home and hospital construction.[13]

United Kingdom[edit]

The United Kingdom has been one of the major economies leading calls for fiscal action to stimulate aggregate demand. Throughout 2008 a number of fiscal measures were introduced including a £145 tax cut for basic rate (below £34,800 pa earnings) tax payers, a temporary 2.5% cut in Value Added Tax (Sales Tax), £3 billion worth of investment spending brought forward from 2010 and a variety of other measures such as a £20 billion Small Enterprise Loan Guarantee Scheme.[20] The total cost of these measures, mostly announced in the November 2008 Pre-Budget Report was roughly £20 billion (not counting loan guarantees).[21] Further limited measures worth £5 billion were unveiled in the 2009 budget including training help for the young unemployed and a "car scrappage" scheme which offered £2,000 in subsidy for a new car purchase for the scrapping of a car more than 10 years old (similar to schemes in Germany and France).[22]

The UK has been limited in its ability to take discretionary fiscal action by the significant burden that bank bail-outs have had on public finances. This has contributed to a significant rise in the deficit to an estimated £175 billion (12.4% of GDP) in 2009-10 and a rise in the national debt above 80% of GDP at its peak.[22] Furthermore, the UK has significant automatic stabilisers which have contributed far more than discretionary action and more than most other countries.[23] As a result, further discretionary fiscal action is unlikely.

Oceania[edit]

Australia[edit]

A school in Australia with signage proclaiming the works as part of the "Economic Stimulus Plan"

First stimulus[edit]

In October 2008, the Rudd government implemented a A$10 billion stimulus package with the support of the Senate crossbench. The package included:[24]

  • $4.8 billion down payment on long-term pension reform
  • $3.9 billion for low and middle income families ($1000 per child, pensioners $1400, pensioner couples $2100)
  • $1.5 billion investment to help first home buyers
  • $187 million to create 56,000 new training places in 2008-09
  • Accelerate three nation-building funds and investment in nation building projects to 2009

Second stimulus[edit]

In February 2009, the Rudd government implemented a A$42 billion stimulus package again with the support of the Senate crossbench. The package included:[25]

  • $12.7 billion for immediate one-off payments to working Australians, families with school-age children, farmers, single income families and for those undergoing training (A$900 for the average single worker)
  • $14.7 billion to be spent on the Building the Education Revolution program which built school infrastructure and maintenance and brought forward funding for trade training centres
  • $6.6 billion to increase the national stock of public and community housing by about 20,000
  • $3.9 billion to provide free insulation to 2.7 million homes and solar hot water rebates
  • $2.7 billion in small and general business tax breaks to provide deductions for some equipment purchases before the end of June 2009.
  • $890 million to fix regional roads and blackspots, to install railway boom gates and for regional and local government infrastructure.

Outcome[edit]

Australia avoided recession and its growth figures were internationally very high, whilst unemployment remained comparatively low, despite net public sector debt remaining substantially low.[26][27][28]

The packages were praised by various business groups, economists, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD).[29][30][31][32][33]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Group of Twenty: Global Economic Policies and Prospects." http://www.imf.org/external/np/g20/pdf/031909a.pdf
  2. ^ "Bush signs stimulus bill; rebate checks expected in May". CNN. 13 February 2008. Retrieved 19 May 2010. 
  3. ^ H.R. 1 Conference Agreement. (PDF) . Retrieved on 2010-07-20.
  4. ^ Fratianni, Michele; Francesco Marchionne (2009). "Rescuing Banks from the Effects of the Financial Crisis". SSRN Working Paper. 
  5. ^ Rial, Patrick. "Asian Stocks May Climb on Japan Stimulus, China Money Supply." Bloomberg. 13 April 2009. http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=a.Mekf7yvAbg&refer=home
  6. ^ "Japan in 10 trillion yen stimulus." BBC News. 6 April 2009. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/7985239.stm
  7. ^ Kyoko Shimodoi and Keiko Ujikane. "Aso to Unveil 15.4 Trillion Yen Japan Stimulus Plan." Bloomberg. 9 April 2009. http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601068&sid=ajEJpJUo6nGc
  8. ^ Eswar Prasad and Isaac Sorkin. "Assessing the G-20 Stimulus Plans: A Deeper Look." The Brookings Institution. March 2009. http://www.brookings.edu/articles/2009/03_g20_stimulus_prasad.aspx
  9. ^ Seyoon Kim. "South Korea Plans 14 Trillion Won Stimulus in 2009." Bloomberg. 3 November 2008. http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=au_aCj.eWwIE&refer=home
  10. ^ "South Korea offers tax break on old cars in stimulus bid." Agence France-Presse. 13 April 2009. http://www.etaiwannews.com/etn/news_content.php?id=918384&lang=eng_news
  11. ^ "Hyundai Motor, Kia Shares Rise on Tax Breaks." The Korea Times. 13 April 2009. http://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/news/biz/2009/04/123_43059.html
  12. ^ Seyoon Kim. "South Korea Plans to Spend Record 17.7 Trillion Won." Bloomberg. 24 March 2009. http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601068&sid=a1nA3nYgmEdA&refer=home
  13. ^ a b c Sylvester Eijffinger. "Banking rescue and economic recovery plans in the Netherlands and other EU Member States: Why the Dutch should do more." Voxeu.org. 5 February 2009. http://voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/2994
  14. ^ Andrea Boltho and Wendy Carlin. "Germany needs high wage settlements and a serious fiscal stimulus." Voxeu.org. 26 November 2008. http://voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/2613
  15. ^ "Germany agrees 50bn euro stimulus". BBC News. 13 January 2009. 
  16. ^ "Germany's Auto-Woes Fix: Scrap That Clunker!". Time. 12 March 2009. Retrieved 19 May 2010. 
  17. ^ Die Konjunkturpakete - Wir bauen Zukunft - Startseite. Konjunkturpaket.de. Retrieved on 2010-07-20.
  18. ^ UPDATE 2-Hungary plans $7 bln stimulus to fight slowdown. Forbes.com (2008-11-13). Retrieved on 2010-07-20.
  19. ^ "Dutch move on $10 billion rescue program - CNN.com". CNN. 21 November 2008. Retrieved 19 May 2010. 
  20. ^ "Small business loan plan unveiled". BBC News. 14 January 2009. Retrieved 19 May 2010. 
  21. ^ "Darling unveils borrowing gamble". BBC News. 24 November 2008. Retrieved 19 May 2010. 
  22. ^ a b "At-a-glance: Budget 2009". BBC News. 22 April 2009. Retrieved 19 May 2010. 
  23. ^ page 28
  24. ^ Rudd's $10b golden goose: SMH 14 October 2008
  25. ^ $42 billion spent to kickstart economy with Budget going into deficit and handouts for many: News.com.au 3 February 2009
  26. ^ 2009 GDP Real Growth Rate Country Comparison: CIA World Factbook, see map on Wikipedia at Global Financial Crisis
  27. ^ Australia able to avoid recession: BBC News 3 June 2009
  28. ^ Kevin Rudd's BER bungle may have saved Australian economy: News.com.au 3 June 2010
  29. ^ Initial praise for Govt stimulus package - ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation). Abc.net.au (2009-02-03). Retrieved on 2010-07-20.
  30. ^ Stimulus packages can save Australia: IMF - National. BrisbaneTimes (2009-03-20). Retrieved on 2010-07-20.
  31. ^ OECD praise for Canberra's stimulus package. Theage.com.au (2009-09-17). Retrieved on 2010-07-20.
  32. ^ World News Australia - Stimulus package gets thumbs up. Sbs.com.au. Retrieved on 2010-07-20.
  33. ^ Economists praise stimulus package. Businessday.com.au (2009-02-03). Retrieved on 2010-07-20.

External links[edit]