|This article needs additional citations for verification. (June 2010)|
Shakespeare mentions the mustard in Henry IV, Part 2, where Falstaff has the line: “his wit’s as thick as Tewkesbury Mustard” (Act 2, Scene 4, Line 244), describing the character of his friend Poins.
Originally the mustard was prepared by grinding the mustard seeds into mustard flour, combining this with finely-grated horseradish (and sometimes herbs and spices), then forming the mixture into balls which were then dried to aid preservation. The mustard balls would then be transported and sold in this form.
To use the balls they would be broken apart then mixed with a liquid such as water, vinegar, wine, ale, beer, cider or fruit juice to soften them and mixed to a thick, creamy consistency. Often a sweetener such as honey would be added.
The resulting mixture would then be used as a condiment just as mustard is used today, or as a cure for ailments.
At the time of the Tewkesbury Festival in 1971 (a major programme of events commemorating the 850th anniversary of the consecration of the Abbey and the 500th anniversary of the Battle of Tewkesbury), the mustard was re-created on a commercial basis from the original recipe, though it is not made in Tewkesbury. Hand-made mustard using local ingredients can still be purchased in Tewkesbury. The mustard can still be bought in ball format and even covered in gold-leaf.
There are now several manufacturers producing the mustard and it is readily found in Tewkesbury’s shops and elsewhere; Fortnum & Mason in London stocks it and Waitrose supermarkets sell their own-label jars of it.
There is some evidence that “Tewkesbury Mustard” came to be used as slang for incendiary 'fire-balls'. Robert Hugh Benson’s historical novel “Oddfish!” contains the text: “Workmen, too, were set to search and dig everywhere for "Tewkesbury mustard-balls," as they were called—or fire-balls, with which it was thought that the Catholics would set London a-fire” which suggests that the term was used to describe some sort of early day incendiary device.
A similar line also appears in Alfred Marks' book "Who Killed Sir Edmund Godfrey?"
Thomas Firminger Thiselton-Dyer in his book “The Folk-lore of Plants”  (pub. 1889) gives evidence that the phrase “He looks as if he lived on Tewkesbury mustard” came to be used as slang in Gloucestershire for those "who always have a sad, severe, and terrific countenance".
- "Henry IV, Part II, Scene 4". opensourceshakespeare.org. Retrieved 2008-05-10.
- Bennett, James (1830). The History of Tewkesbury. James Bennett, Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown and Green, London. p. 201
- Erlington, C (1968). A History of the County of Gloucester: volume 8. Victoria County History. pp. 137–146
- "Tewkesbury Mustard". Retrieved 2008-05-11.
- Benson, Robert Hugh (1914). Oddfish!. Hutchinson, London
- Thiselton-Dyer, Thomas Firminger. "The Folk-Lore of Plants". Project Gutenberg. Retrieved 2008-05-11.