Talk:Norumbega: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 13:46, 18 December 2015

Norse history and culture Start‑class Low‑importance

	This article is within the scope of WikiProject Norse history and culture, a WikiProject related to all activities of the North Germanic peoples, both in Scandinavia and abroad, prior to the formation of the Kalmar Union in 1397. If you would like to participate, you can edit the article attached to this page, or visit the project page, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the discussion.Norse history and cultureWikipedia:WikiProject Norse history and cultureTemplate:WikiProject Norse history and cultureNorse history and culture articles
Start	This article has been rated as Start-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale.
Low	This article has been rated as Low-importance on the project's importance scale.

Video game reference seems trivial in this context. 128.102.107.197 (talk) 07:44, 7 September 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Funny article, no mention of Martin Behaim, an early explorer, who was born in Nuremberg, a still existing town in Germany!22:33, 21 May 2011 (UTC) —Preceding unsigned comment added by 90.186.205.102 (talk)

Speculation

Here's the material that was deleted with that edit summary (except for the lead changes):− An early reference was that of the Luso-French navigator Jean Allefonsce (1542) who reported that he had coasted south from Newfoundland and had discovered a great river. "The river is more than 40 leagues wide at its entrance and retains its width some thirty or forty leagues. It is full of Islands, which stretch some ten or twelve leagues into the sea. ... Fifteen leagues within this river there is a town called Norombega, with clever inhabitants, who trade in furs of all sorts; the town folk are dressed in furs, wearing sable. ... The people use many words which sound like Latin. They worship the sun. They are tall and handsome in form. The land of Norombega lie high and is well situated."^[1]

It often appeared on subsequent European maps of North America, lying south of Acadia somewhere in what is now New England. Norumbega was thought to be a large, rich Native city, and by extension the river it was on, and the region surrounding it.^{[citation needed]}

Samuel de Champlain searched for Norumbega in 1604 and believed he had found Allefonsce's river in the form of the Penobscot, which he called "the great river of Norumbega". He sailed as far as the rapids at what is now Bangor, Maine, but finding only villages, his and subsequent maps deleted reference to Norumbega as a town, region, or even river.^[2] Most historians have subsequently accepted the Penobscot region as Allefonsce's source for Norumbega, though the matter was hotly contested by some nineteenth century antiquarians, who argued that the name should be identified with their own river or region.^[3]

The city of Bangor embraced the Norumbega legend in the nineteenth century, naming their Greek Revival style municipal hall "Norumbega Hall", a venue for public meetings and lectures. The building stood in the center of the city until destroyed in the Great Fire of 1911. A park named "Norumbega Mall" now occupies the site, and an adjacent building housing the University of Maine Art Gallery is now named "Norumbega Hall". There was also a Norumbega Bank in nineteenth century Bangor. In 1886 Joseph Barker Stearns, the inventor of the duplex telegraphy system, built a mansion named "Norumbega Castle", which still stands on US Route 1 in Camden, Maine, overlooking Penobscot Bay.<ref>

References

^ DeCosta, 1890, p. 99.
^ Susan Danforth, The Land of Norumbega: Maine in the Age of Exploration and Settlement (Portland, Me.: Portland Museum of Art, 1988), p. 54
^ John Fiske, The Dutch and Quaker Colonies in America (NY: 1899) p. 70: “the most common opinion is that the Penobscot was the River of Norumbega, with a village on its bank somewhere up country, where European skippers traded with the natives for furs”. Fiske argued for the Hudson being Norumbega.

"Speculation" is not a reason to remove material. Virtually all our articles on archaeology, for instance, include speculation. The comment about appearing on maps is important although obviously needs citing, and isn't speculation. ~~~~

[1] DeCosta, 1890, p. 99.

[2] Susan Danforth, The Land of Norumbega: Maine in the Age of Exploration and Settlement (Portland, Me.: Portland Museum of Art, 1988), p. 54

[3] John Fiske, The Dutch and Quaker Colonies in America (NY: 1899) p. 70: “the most common opinion is that the Penobscot was the River of Norumbega, with a village on its bank somewhere up country, where European skippers traded with the natives for furs”. Fiske argued for the Hudson being Norumbega.

[1]

[2]

[3]

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 Funny article, no mention of Martin Behaim, an early explorer, who was born in Nuremberg, a still existing town in Germany!22:33, 21 May 2011 (UTC)  <span style="font-size: smaller;" class="autosigned">—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[Special:Contributions/90.186.205.102|90.186.205.102]] ([[User talk:90.186.205.102|talk]]) </span><!-- Template:UnsignedIP --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->
+== Speculation ==
+Here's the material that was deleted with that edit summary (except for the lead changes):−
+An early reference was that of the Luso-French navigator [[Jean Allefonsce]] (1542) who reported that he had coasted south from [[Newfoundland]] and had discovered a great river. "The river is more than 40 leagues wide at its entrance and retains its width some thirty or forty leagues. It is full of Islands, which stretch some ten or twelve leagues into the sea. ... Fifteen leagues within this river there is a town called Norombega, with clever inhabitants, who trade in furs of all sorts; the town folk are dressed in furs, wearing sable. ... The people use many words which sound like Latin. They worship the sun. They are tall and handsome in form. The land of Norombega lie high and is well situated."<ref>DeCosta, 1890, p. 99.</ref>
+It often appeared on subsequent [[Europe]]an maps of North America, lying south of [[Acadia]] somewhere in what is now [[New England]]. Norumbega was thought to be a large, rich [[Native Americans in the United States|Native]] city, and by extension the river it was on, and the region surrounding it.{{citation needed|date = January 2015}}
+[[Samuel de Champlain]] searched for Norumbega in 1604 and believed he had found Allefonsce's river in the form of the [[Penobscot River|Penobscot]], which he called "the great river of Norumbega". He sailed as far as the rapids at what is now [[Bangor, Maine]], but finding only villages, his and subsequent maps deleted reference to Norumbega as a town, region, or even river.<ref>Susan Danforth, The Land of Norumbega: Maine in the Age of Exploration and Settlement (Portland, Me.: Portland Museum of Art, 1988), p. 54</ref> Most historians have subsequently accepted the Penobscot region as Allefonsce's source for Norumbega, though the matter was hotly contested by some nineteenth century antiquarians, who argued that the name should be identified with their own river or region.<ref>John Fiske, The Dutch and Quaker Colonies in America (NY: 1899) p. 70: “the most common opinion is that the Penobscot was the River of Norumbega, with a village on its bank somewhere up country, where European skippers traded with the natives for furs”. Fiske argued for the Hudson being Norumbega.</ref>
+The city of [[Bangor, Maine|Bangor]] embraced the Norumbega legend in the nineteenth century, naming their Greek Revival style municipal hall "Norumbega Hall", a venue for public meetings and lectures. The building stood in the center of the city until destroyed in the [[Great Fire of 1911]]. A park named "Norumbega Mall" now occupies the site, and an adjacent building housing the University of Maine Art Gallery is now named "Norumbega Hall". There was also a Norumbega Bank in nineteenth century Bangor. In 1886 [[Joseph Barker Stearns]], the inventor of the duplex telegraphy system, built a mansion named "Norumbega Castle", which still stands on US Route 1 in [[Camden, Maine]], overlooking Penobscot Bay.<ref>
+{{ref talk}}
+"Speculation" is not a reason to remove material. Virtually all our articles on archaeology, for instance, include speculation. The comment about appearing on maps is important although obviously needs citing, and isn't speculation. ~~~~