Talk:Anime Unleashed: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 18:21, 7 January 2006

I've added the "Current Status" of each of the shows, as well as MSAA and Gad Guard to the list.LunarMoon 01:10, 5 Mar 2005 (UTC)

I don't understand the point of this page. Isn't this just an advertizement for Anime Unleashed? How is Anime Unleashed important or noteworthy in the greater scheme of things? How has it contributed substantially to human culture; why is this particular article an expansion of the base of human knowledge? And why do we need to have updated series standings for shows on Anime Unleashed? Doesn't that just make it a programming guide of sorts, putting this article more in the realm of a blatant advertizement in Wikipedia? User: GestaltG

- While the result of the article for deletion debate was to keep this article, it was generally agreed that the list attached to this article is excessive; this article is nothing but a stub plus a program list attached. Please, do not add anything more to this list. Additionally, the "notability" of this subject (i.e. Anime Unleashed) is only U.S. centric and does not apply to the "rest of the world." I believe most agreed that this article could or should be merged with a larger article on anime in Western culture. Unless someone has some factual information to add (which does not include expanding the current program list), this article will remain nothing but a stub with a list of programs attached. GestaltG 18:21, 7 January 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Revision as of 07:36, 6 January 2006 edit Yamamoto Ichiro (talk \| contribs) Administrators 47,174 edits afd result ← Previous edit		Revision as of 18:21, 7 January 2006 edit undo GestaltG (talk \| contribs) 326 edits added post-afd commentary for future editors Next edit →
Line 8:		Line 8:

	I don't understand the point of this page. Isn't this just an advertizement for Anime Unleashed? How is Anime Unleashed important or noteworthy in the greater scheme of things? How has it contributed substantially to human culture; why is this particular article an expansion of the base of human knowledge? And why do we need to have updated series standings for shows on Anime Unleashed? Doesn't that just make it a programming guide of sorts, putting this article more in the realm of a blatant advertizement in Wikipedia? [[User: GestaltG]]		I don't understand the point of this page. Isn't this just an advertizement for Anime Unleashed? How is Anime Unleashed important or noteworthy in the greater scheme of things? How has it contributed substantially to human culture; why is this particular article an expansion of the base of human knowledge? And why do we need to have updated series standings for shows on Anime Unleashed? Doesn't that just make it a programming guide of sorts, putting this article more in the realm of a blatant advertizement in Wikipedia? [[User: GestaltG]]
			**While the result of the article for deletion debate was to '''keep''' this article, it was generally agreed that the list attached to this article is excessive; this article is nothing but a stub plus a program list attached. ''Please'', do not add anything more to this list. Additionally, the "notability" of this subject (i.e. Anime Unleashed) is only U.S. centric and does not apply to the "rest of the world." I believe most agreed that this article could or should be merged with a larger article on anime in Western culture. Unless someone has some factual information to add (which does not include expanding the current program list), this article will remain nothing but a stub with a list of programs attached. [[User:GestaltG\|GestaltG]] 18:21, 7 January 2006 (UTC)