Talk:Six Kalimas

Vowelling

Do we really need to include the vowelling? It makes the Arabic script a bit messy and cluttered.

Yeah, because it helps people who aren't necessarily experts at reading arabic script...

Referencing

The introductory paragraph is profoundly simplistic. The Six Kalimas (or Six "Words") are recorded in various books of knowledge can you name one of these books at least? I regularly read Islamic books in both Arabic and English and have yet to have even heard of this. and are recited (and remembered) by Muslims across the globe I am assuming these "Muslims across the globe are a particular sect, perhaps mystical. These kalimas were compiled together for people to memorize and learn the basic fundamentals of Islam.Who compiled them together? And as they are prayers or adhkar how does one learn the basic fundamentals of Islam from them? They are not found altogether complete in any one hadith or narration from the Islamic prophet Muhammad. What are those hadith they are found in? Supertouch (talk) 14:19, 9 March 2008 (UTC)

First Kalima

I always thought that the last part of the first Kalima was "Mohammad ur rasul-allah" "not wa Mohammadan rasulul-llah" Puck42 (talk) 14:39, 4 August 2008 (UTC)

• I hope I didn't do this wrong - I'm not a muslim, so I'm sort of guessing - but I noticed an error in the syntax of the first kalima preventing the romanization from displaying correctly. I wasn't sure how to restore it, and I also noticed that the text didn't match the text from the article about the Shahada. I'm guessing there might be some difference of opinion as to which version is correct, أشهد أن] لا إله إلاَّ الله و [أشهد أن ] محمد رسول الله ] (from Six Kalimas) or أشهد أن لا إله إلاَّ الله و أشهد أن محمد رسول الله, and maybe that was where the error crept in, but I'm really not knowledgeable at all and couldn't find it in the history. Under the assumption that the Shahada version might be watched more closely and therefore more "correct," I've pasted the version of the first kalima from there. I hope this was the correct thing to do, please fix it if I've gotten it wrong :) stephan.com (talk) 04:23, 31 March 2009 (UTC)

The Kalimah vs 6 Kalimas

There should be a seperate page for just the Kalimah. The idea of the 6 kalimas is practically unknown outside of the Indian subcontinent, it is something specific to a portion of the Muslim community and in all honesty, means absolutely nothing to the rest. The Kalimah however is THE symbol of Islam, and as such it deserves its own page, so 'kalimah' should not redirect to this page any longer.Musa abu A'isha (talk) 11:15, 15 September 2008 (UTC)

Second Kalima

the second kalima (arabic script) is incomplete

urdu

it seems it was an urdu speaker who made this article. Urdu is not the language of islam, arabic is the language of islam.

please remove urdu sentences and replace them with arabic ones.

thank u