User:Smbourne/sandbox: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 37: | Line 37: | ||
===Corrective labour without deprivation of freedom=== |
===Corrective labour without deprivation of freedom=== |
||
This is a form of penalty imposed by the court for a term of from one month to one year. With this form of slave labour a certain amount of their earnings is deducted as state income based on gross amount earned before taxes and Benefits for temporary disability, pregnancy and childbirth benefits. This type of labour is imposed by the court in cases in which the person whom committed the crime and the defendant give ground to presume that that the prisoners correction and re-education may be accomplished without isolation from society in collective labour.<ref name="encyclopedia"{{cite book | author = title =The Great Soviet Encyclopedia| year =1979| editor = A.M Prokhorov| pages = publisher = New York: Macmillan, London: Collier Macmillan}}</ref> |
This is a form of penalty imposed by the court for a term of from one month to one year. With this form of slave labour a certain amount of their earnings is deducted as state income based on gross amount earned before taxes and Benefits for temporary disability, pregnancy and childbirth benefits. This type of labour is imposed by the court in cases in which the person whom committed the crime and the defendant give ground to presume that that the prisoners correction and re-education may be accomplished without isolation from society in collective labour.<ref name="encyclopedia"{{cite book | author = title =The Great Soviet Encyclopedia| year =1979| editor = A.M Prokhorov| pages = publisher = New York: Macmillan, London: Collier Macmillan}}</ref><ref name="Harris">{{cite journal | author =Harris, James R. | title = The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region| year =1997 | publisher=Russian Review 56, no. 2 |}}</ref> |
||
===Deprivation of freedom=== |
===Deprivation of freedom=== |
||
This type of penalty consists of enforced isolation of the criminal from society. It is served in special places of confinement designated by the state for this purpose, for example, the Gulag. This may only be assigned by a court for a person who is sentenced to a term of three months to ten years.<ref name="Harris">{{cite journal | author =Harris, James R. | title = The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region| year =1997 | publisher =Russian Review 56, no. 2 |}}</ref>[[File:Вышибем кулаков из колхозов 1930.jpg|Вышибем кулаков из колхозов 1930||left|thumb|Soviet propaganda: We will keep out Kulaks from the collective farms]] |
This type of penalty consists of enforced isolation of the criminal from society. It is served in special places of confinement designated by the state for this purpose, for example, the Gulag. This may only be assigned by a court for a person who is sentenced to a term of three months to ten years.<ref name="Harris">{{cite journal | author =Harris, James R. | title = The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region| year =1997 | publisher =Russian Review 56, no. 2 |}}</ref>[[File:Вышибем кулаков из колхозов 1930.jpg|Вышибем кулаков из колхозов 1930||left|thumb|Soviet propaganda: We will keep out Kulaks from the collective farms]] |
||
This type of punishment is served after part of their sentence. By decision of a court, prisoners from correctional camps with who have made a solid start on the path of rehabilitation were sent to exile colonies. In the exile colonies the prisoners have more freedoms with permission of the administration. The colonies were designed to reinforce the results of the re education of convicts and to create the necessary conditions to assimilate the prisoners back to normal living conditions.<ref name="encyclopedia">{{cite book |author = title =The Great Soviet Encyclopedia| year =1979| editor = A.M Prokhorov| pages = |
This type of punishment is served after part of their sentence. By decision of a court, prisoners from correctional camps with who have made a solid start on the path of rehabilitation were sent to exile colonies. In the exile colonies the prisoners have more freedoms with permission of the administration. The colonies were designed to reinforce the results of the re education of convicts and to create the necessary conditions to assimilate the prisoners back to normal living conditions.<ref name="encyclopedia">{{cite book |author = title =The Great Soviet Encyclopedia | year =1979| editor = A.M Prokhorov| pages = publisher = New York: Macmillan, London: Collier Macmillan</ref><ref name="Harris">{{cite journal | author =Harris, James R. | title = The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region| year =1997 | publisher =Russian Review 56, no. 2 |}} |
||
==Kulak== |
==Kulak== |
||
The [[kulak]] were known as the upper class peasantry. They were landowners and they took full advantage of capitalism in pre Soviet-Union Russia but the development of the complete collectivization of agriculture served as the basis for the shift to a policy of liquidating the kulaks as a class <ref name="encyclopedia">{{cite book | author = title =The Great Soviet Encyclopedia| year =1979| editor = A.M Prokhorov| pages = |
The [[kulak]] were known as the upper class peasantry. They were landowners and they took full advantage of capitalism in pre Soviet-Union Russia but the development of the complete collectivization of agriculture served as the basis for the shift to a policy of liquidating the kulaks as a class <ref name="encyclopedia">{{cite book | author = title =The Great Soviet Encyclopedia | year =1979| editor = A.M Prokhorov| pages = publisher = New York: Macmillan, London: Collier Macmillan</ref>. The first major wave to the GULAG was engineered in the early 1930’s to liquidate the Kulak during the [[great purge]] <ref name="Alexander">{{cite book | author = Alexander Tvardovsky |Title = By Right of Memory | year =2006| editor Adrienne Wilmoth Lerner, Brenda Wilmoth Lerner, and K. Lee Lerner | pages 39|publisher = Detroit</ref><ref name="Harris">{{cite journal | author =Harris, James R. | title = The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region| year =1997 | publisher =Russian Review 56, no. 2 |}}</ref>. [[Dekulakization]] had two powerful drives, it was a threat to agricultural regions in order to maintain collectivisation and it gave regions with labor shortages access to a large labor supply<ref name="Harris">{{cite journal | author =Harris, James R. | title = The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region| year =1997 | publisher =Russian Review 56, no. 2 |}}</ref> |
||
. According to data in the Soviet archives, 1,803,392 Kulak were sent to labor colonies and camps from 1930 to 1931. |
. According to data in the Soviet archives, 1,803,392 Kulak were sent to labor colonies and camps from 1930 to 1931. |
||
Line 51: | Line 50: | ||
===Workday Credit System=== |
===Workday Credit System=== |
||
The principle of the credit system was that prisoners who met production targets (and conformed to disciplinary rules) were to be rewarded by a reducing the amount of time confined in the Gulag <ref>{{cite journal|author=Simon Ertz |title= Trading effort for freedom: workday credits in the Stalinist camp system|journal= Comparative Economic Studies |volume= 47.2|pages=476+ |year=2005|}}</ref>. During the construction of the Baltic White-Sea Canal from 1931 to early 1933, workday credits were often used to motivate forced laborers. After the use of the credit system to successfully do a large scale project in a short period of time the workday credits were established in almost all prison camps. There was a major problem with the workplace credit system though in the fact that they were given to dangerous criminals to make their conviction shorter as well as the productive workers. There was also a problem in the fact that the workplace credit system was only practical in the short run like a period of wartime when much work needed to be done in a short period of time but in the long run the loss of workers due to the early releases caused the workplace credit system to pay for the decreases <ref name="Harris">{{cite journal | author =Harris, James R. | title = The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region| year =1997 | publisher =Russian Review 56, no. 2 |}}</ref> <ref>{{cite journal|author=Simon Ertz |title= Trading effort for freedom: workday credits in the Stalinist camp system|journal= Comparative Economic Studies |volume= 47.2|pages=476+ |year=2005|}}</ref>. |
The principle of the credit system was that prisoners who met production targets (and conformed to disciplinary rules) were to be rewarded by a reducing the amount of time confined in the Gulag <ref name="WCS">{{cite journal|author=Simon Ertz |title= Trading effort for freedom: workday credits in the Stalinist camp system|journal= Comparative Economic Studies |volume= 47.2|pages=476+ |year=2005|}}</ref>. During the construction of the Baltic White-Sea Canal from 1931 to early 1933, workday credits were often used to motivate forced laborers. After the use of the credit system to successfully do a large scale project in a short period of time the workday credits were established in almost all prison camps. There was a major problem with the workplace credit system though in the fact that they were given to dangerous criminals to make their conviction shorter as well as the productive workers. There was also a problem in the fact that the workplace credit system was only practical in the short run like a period of wartime when much work needed to be done in a short period of time but in the long run the loss of workers due to the early releases caused the workplace credit system to pay for the decreases <ref name="Harris">{{cite journal | author =Harris, James R. | title = The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region| year =1997 | publisher =Russian Review 56, no. 2 |}}</ref> <ref name="WCS">{{cite journal|author=Simon Ertz |title= Trading effort for freedom: workday credits in the Stalinist camp system|journal= Comparative Economic Studies |volume= 47.2|pages=476+ |year=2005|}}</ref>. |
||
===Secret Police=== |
===Secret Police=== |
Revision as of 20:55, 15 November 2012
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/e4/Kolyma-goldmine.jpg/220px-Kolyma-goldmine.jpg)
Under the reign of Joseph Stalin, forced labour in the Soviet Union was used in order to achieve the economic goals of the Five-Year Plan.[1] Forced labour was a vital part of the rapid industrialization and economic growth of the Soviet Union. The soviet secret police of the Soviet Union had detained from 1932-1946 approximately 18,207,150 of prisoners. The Gulag prison system had put into practice the use of forced labour by imprisoning not only dangerous criminals but also people convicted of political crimes against the communistic government [2]
Labourers had to work in freezing climates, unhygienic conditions, dangerous circumstances and worked for extensive time periods without a break. Many prisoners were able to perform the forced labour necessary but a large number of prisoners were too hungry, sick, or injured from the intense working conditions to complete the labour. Often prisoners were punished for not reaching targets by getting fewer rations of food than those who did reach production targets; thereby it was not unlikely for prisoners to die of starvation[3][4]
Gulag: Soviet Penal System
The Gulag which is an acronym for Glavnoe Upravlenie Ispravitel-no-trudovykh Lagerei or Chief Directorate of prison camps in former Soviet Union.[2] The Gulag was the main agency that implemented the policy of forced labour during the Stalin Era. It was created after the 1917 revolution and greatly grew throughout the thirties during Joseph Stalin’s reign in order to turn the Soviet Union to an industrialized nation[3]. Many historians believe that the camps were a way of handling any enemies of the regime and used as a threat to millions, others believe that it was created by the means of rapid industrialization and economic growth.[4]
Prisoners had to work in intense climates, unsanitary conditions and work extremely hard for long periods of time. Also the prisoners were fed meager food rations and were punished excessively by the NKVD causing high death rates among the camps [3]Cite error: The <ref>
tag has too many names (see the help page).. Though the prisoners were unskilled and thereby inefficient they were put to work for economic purposes [3][5]The camps were home to many different kinds of people, some were murderers, thieves and rapists but the majority were innocent individuals who were sent to the Gulag without trial due to speculations that they were traitors or capitalists. Millions of people were sent to the Gulag or work camps for reasons including being late for work, saying anything against the government and taking a few potatoes out of a farmer’s field. [3][2]
Daily Life as a Soviet Slave
Prisoners could work up to 14 hours in a single work day or hard strenuous labor. Prisoners did jobs like forestry work with saws and axes,they mined ore by hand where often they suffered painful and fatal diseases from inhalation of ore dust, and they also had to dig at frozen ground with primitive pickaxes for construction, construction of defensive lines, creating railroads, and creating large canals like the workers in Belbaltlag, which is a Gulag camp where the prisoners would work on building the White Sea-Baltic Sea Canal [3][6]Cite error: The <ref>
tag has too many names (see the help page).. Prisoners were meagrely fed and could barely sustain these hard working conditions and freezing cold climate. Typically about thirty percent of the labour force was to sick or weak to work but were punished if they did not show up to perform the labour, thus it was not uncommon for prisoners to drop dead on the job[4]
. The chart below is based on the typical daily schedule at Gulag camp Perm-36.[3]
6:30 AM | Breakfast |
7:00 AM | Roll-call |
7:30 AM | 1 1/2 hour to march to forests, under guarded escort |
6:00 PM | 1 1/2 hour return march to camp |
7:30 PM | Dinner |
8:00 PM | After-dinner camp work duties (chop firewood, shovel snow, gardening, road repair, etc.) |
11:00PM | Lights out |
Women life in the Gulag
Women were housed in separate barracks from the men but often were in the same work camps as the men. They completed the same labor and in many situations worked side by side with them. There were some special camps for children, for mothers with babies, and other special cases[7]. Women in the Gulag were preyed upon from men they were often raped and abused. Upon arrival at the camp, prisoners would be stripped naked where their things would be searched and the guards would pick individual women, promising easier work in exchange for sexual favors.[3][7]
Types of Labor
Corrective labour without deprivation of freedom
This is a form of penalty imposed by the court for a term of from one month to one year. With this form of slave labour a certain amount of their earnings is deducted as state income based on gross amount earned before taxes and Benefits for temporary disability, pregnancy and childbirth benefits. This type of labour is imposed by the court in cases in which the person whom committed the crime and the defendant give ground to presume that that the prisoners correction and re-education may be accomplished without isolation from society in collective labour.Cite error: The <ref>
tag has too many names (see the help page).
Deprivation of freedom
This type of penalty consists of enforced isolation of the criminal from society. It is served in special places of confinement designated by the state for this purpose, for example, the Gulag. This may only be assigned by a court for a person who is sentenced to a term of three months to ten years.[4]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/ef/%D0%92%D1%8B%D1%88%D0%B8%D0%B1%D0%B5%D0%BC_%D0%BA%D1%83%D0%BB%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2_%D0%B8%D0%B7_%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%85%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%BE%D0%B2_1930.jpg/220px-%D0%92%D1%8B%D1%88%D0%B8%D0%B1%D0%B5%D0%BC_%D0%BA%D1%83%D0%BB%D0%B0%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2_%D0%B8%D0%B7_%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%BB%D1%85%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%BE%D0%B2_1930.jpg)
This type of punishment is served after part of their sentence. By decision of a court, prisoners from correctional camps with who have made a solid start on the path of rehabilitation were sent to exile colonies. In the exile colonies the prisoners have more freedoms with permission of the administration. The colonies were designed to reinforce the results of the re education of convicts and to create the necessary conditions to assimilate the prisoners back to normal living conditions.[8]Cite error: A <ref>
tag is missing the closing </ref>
(see the help page).. The first major wave to the GULAG was engineered in the early 1930’s to liquidate the Kulak during the great purge [9][4]. Dekulakization had two powerful drives, it was a threat to agricultural regions in order to maintain collectivisation and it gave regions with labor shortages access to a large labor supply[4]
. According to data in the Soviet archives, 1,803,392 Kulak were sent to labor colonies and camps from 1930 to 1931.
Productivity
Workday Credit System
The principle of the credit system was that prisoners who met production targets (and conformed to disciplinary rules) were to be rewarded by a reducing the amount of time confined in the Gulag [10]. During the construction of the Baltic White-Sea Canal from 1931 to early 1933, workday credits were often used to motivate forced laborers. After the use of the credit system to successfully do a large scale project in a short period of time the workday credits were established in almost all prison camps. There was a major problem with the workplace credit system though in the fact that they were given to dangerous criminals to make their conviction shorter as well as the productive workers. There was also a problem in the fact that the workplace credit system was only practical in the short run like a period of wartime when much work needed to be done in a short period of time but in the long run the loss of workers due to the early releases caused the workplace credit system to pay for the decreases [4] [10].
Secret Police
The Cheka, GPU, OGPU, NKVD, MVD, and KGB were the political police in the Soviet Union. They stood as a threat to whoever was not being productive enough in a non competitive society. They were the main punishers and supervision held in and out of the GULAG and sped up the process of citizen assimilation to a collective lifestyle. The NKVD sent millions of peasants, intellectuals, religious believers, and dissidents to the GULAG [9].
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/f6/Emblema_NKVD.svg/220px-Emblema_NKVD.svg.png)
Numbers
[11] Amount of people in GULAG corrective camps and labour colonies
Year | Total |
1934 | 510307 |
1935 | 965742 |
1936 | 1296494 |
1937 | 1196369 |
1938 | 1881570 |
1939 | 1672438 |
1940 | 1659992 |
1941 | 1929729 |
1942 | 1777043 |
1943 | 1484182 |
1944 | 1179819 |
1945 | 1460677 |
1946 | 1703095 |
Economic Incentives
The GULAG began as a place to house criminals, traitors and socialists but eventually became an important part in the Soviet Union’s economy and rapid industrialization. The Five Year Plans gave production targets that relied on the expansion of forced laborers to meet the industrial targets. The Gulag system allowed for inexpensive laborers to develop the rapid industrialization to meet the target recommendations thereby an economic motivation was for finding a sufficient number of "enemies of the people" to keep Gulag production in line with targets.[1] The Gulag forced labour industry was intended to be a mobile, cheap workforce that can be easily replenished and is able to advance on inhospitable areas that were plentiful in resources.
The Gulag was very expensive to maintain being as on its own it required an entire infrastructure. The workers were also unmotivated and weakened by poor living conditions. The prisoners, with few rights of their own, led authorities to decide for projects with little economic use. The best known example of this is the White Sea Canal.[2][1] The White Sea Canal was built in-between 1931 and 1933 and it involved over a hundred thousand prisoners that dug a 141 mile canal in 20 months. Though the canal turned out to be to narrow and shallow to support most sea craft. [3]
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/ef/Kolyma_road00.jpg/220px-Kolyma_road00.jpg)
Kolyma
Kolyma was the most notorious labour camp[3]. It was located at the extreme northeast of Siberia and had a reputation to be the coldest inhabited place on the planet. Kolyma was mined for its rich deposits of gold by the laborers in the Gulag camps though millions of prisoners perished in the camps due to the cold Arctic climates. Stalin used this as free labour to obtain essential resources and a way to get rid of the criminals and communist resistance by sending prisoners to Kolyma [12].
Death of Stalin
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/bd/StalinEnLaConferenciaDeYalta--TR_002828_A.jpg/220px-StalinEnLaConferenciaDeYalta--TR_002828_A.jpg)
Joseph Stalin died on March 5, 1953. By then the Gulag had reached its maximum amount of prisoners at around 2.7 million [3][7]. Over the next few years under Stalin’s successors the population of Gulag prisoners decreased substantially because they were convinced that forced labour was wasteful and inefficient. After Stalin’s death the new Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev moved to relieve Soviet repression and decreased the population to a greater extent. Khrushchev allowed for open discussion of the lifestyles of those living and working in the Gulag, even giving permission for author Alexander Solzhenitsyn to publish “one day in the life of Ivan Denisovich,” a Soviet novel of life in Stalin’s forced labour camps.[3] This period of time was only temporary for Khrushchev was removed from power in 1964 and the subject of the Gulag became forbidden once again until 1985. In 1985 Mikhail Gorbachev came to power and initiated a period of openness called Glasnost. He believed in making a socialist society without repression or violence. The period of openness he titled glasnost allowed for a era of discussing the on goings of the Gulag.[3]
References
- ^ a b c Gregory, Paul R. (2003). The Economics of Forced Labour: The Soviet Gulag. HOOVER INST PRESS PUBLICATION.
- ^ a b c d Applebaum, Anne (2004). Gulag a history. New York: Anchor Books.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m Center for History and New Media. "Gulag:Soviet Forced Labor Camps and the Struggle for Freedom" (PDF).
- ^ a b c d e f g Harris, James R. (1997). "The growth of the Gulag: Forced labor in the Urals region". Russian Review 56, no. 2.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite has empty unknown parameter:|1=
(help); Cite journal requires|journal=
(help) - ^ Davies, R.W. “The Economics of Forced Labor: The Soviet Gulag.” Journal of Cold War Studies 9, no.1(2007): 165-167
- ^ Edwin Bacon (1992). "Glasnost and the Gulag: New information on Soviet forced labor around World War II". Soviet Studies. 6: 1069.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite has empty unknown parameter:|1=
(help) - ^ a b c Daniel W. Michael (2002). "The Gulag: Communism's Penal Colonies Revisited". Journal of Historical Review. 21: 39.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite has empty unknown parameter:|1=
(help) - ^ {{cite book |author = title =The Great Soviet Encyclopedia | year =1979| editor = A.M Prokhorov| pages = publisher = New York: Macmillan, London: Collier Macmillan
- ^ a b {{cite book | author = Alexander Tvardovsky |Title = By Right of Memory | year =2006| editor Adrienne Wilmoth Lerner, Brenda Wilmoth Lerner, and K. Lee Lerner | pages 39|publisher = Detroit Cite error: The named reference "Alexander" was defined multiple times with different content (see the help page).
- ^ a b Simon Ertz (2005). "Trading effort for freedom: workday credits in the Stalinist camp system". Comparative Economic Studies. 47.2: 476+.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite has empty unknown parameter:|1=
(help) - ^ Edwin Bacon (1992). "Glasnost and the Gulag: New information on Soviet forced labor around World War II". Soviet Studies. 6: 1069.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite has empty unknown parameter:|1=
(help) - ^ Stanislaw J. Kowalski. "Kolyma: The Land of Gold and Death" (PDF).