Jump to content

Simcha Jacobovici

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Sdoumit (talk | contribs) at 14:51, 15 April 2009. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Simcha Jacobovici (Template:PronEng) (born April 4, 1953 in Petah Tikva, Israel) is an Israeli and Canadian controversial film director, producer and free-lance journalist. He holds a B.A. in Philosophy from McGill University and an M.A. in International Relations from the University of Toronto. He currently hosts the The Naked Archaeologist on VisionTV in Canada and The History Channel in the U.S.

Filmography

Jacobovici's films are (starting with most recent):

Jacobovici misleading the media

Archaeologists and biblical scholars have raised numerous compaints against Jacobovici's films. The complaints range from "controversial claims" that present theory as fact to accusations of the outright falsification of facts; The Exodus Decoded has particularly come up for rebuttal.[1]

Jacobovici and James Cameron's The Lost Tomb of Jesus presented the theory that the Talpiot tomb was the burial place of Jesus' family. The heart of Jacobovici's theory is that while Jesus, Joseph and other names found in the tomb were common names in Jesus' time, the probability of finding the particular combination of names found there pointed to the possibility that this was, in fact, Jesus' family tomb. This theory has been widely denounced by biblical scholars.

A symposium at Princeton University in January 2008 reignited media interest in the Talpiot tomb. Time magazine covered the event as a re-opening of the argument about the tomb.[2] and CNN[3] "I feel vindicated," Jacobovici told TIME. "It's moved from 'it can't be the Jesus' family tomb' to 'it could be.' " [4] After three days of vigorous debate, the panel remained deeply divided. Opinions ranged from "definitely yes" to impossible."

Some scholars present at the symposium accused Simcha Jacobovici and James Cameron of misleading the media by claiming that the symposium bolstered the viability of their theory. Several scholars, including all of the archaeologists and epigraphers, who had delivered papers at the symposium issued an open letter of complaint at what they viewed as misrepresentation, saying that Jacobovici and Cameron's claims of support from the symposium "[could not be]] further from the truth."[5]

The list of scholars who signed the open letter's critical of Jacobovici's presentation of the symposium and its findings included:

Joe Zias, Senior Curator of Archaeology/Anthropology for the Israel Antiquities Authority from 1972-1997, cited a leaked memo issued by James Tabor before the symposium as proof of "outside intervention by Jacobovici and Cameron in order to distort the agenda and skew the proceedings in a way that was favorable to their pre-conceived plan."[6] Geza Vermes issued a statement saying that the arguments for the Talpiot tomb are not "just unconvincing but insignificant."[7] Vermes added, "[d]iscounting a handful, headed by James Tabor and Simcha Jacobovici, the maker of the documentary, The Lost Tomb of Jesus, most of the fifty or so participants shared this opinion"

Princeton Theological Seminary issued a letter following the controversy and reiterated concerns that:

the press following the symposium gave almost the exact opposite impression [of the symposium's results], stating, instead, that the conference proceedings gave credence to the identification of the Talpiot tomb with a putative family tomb of Jesus of Nazareth. As is abundantly clear from the statements to the contrary that have been issued since the symposium by many of the participants, such representations are patently false and blatantly misrepresent the spirit and scholarly content of the deliberations.[7]

Jacobovici has also theorized that the graves found in Mycenae by Heinrich Schliemann belonged to runaway Jews. In particular, he claimed that one of the artifacts found at the site had a visual depiction of the Ark of the Covenant. According to Michael Wood in "In Search of the Trojan War," the graves were 1000 years older than the Trojan War and would, therefore, be about 750-800 years older than the Exodus. Additionally Jacobovici doesn't take his argument further than the supposed visual depiction of the Ark on the artifact. In short Jacobovici's claim is highly conjectural and has less validity than Schliemann's that one of the graves belonged to Agamemnon.

Controversial inferences made by Jacobovici

  • The Trojan gold and graves in present day Turkey are not actually Trojan (or Greek) but are those of a group of Hebrews that were fleeing Egypt, got separated and lost, and somehow ended up in Turkey[8]!
  • Hebrew slaves invented the alphabet. In one of the Naked Archaeologist episodes, Jacobovici makes the argument that Hebrew slaves invented the Proto-Sinaitic script, rather than the Phoenicians.
  • Jacobovici discovered the tomb of Jesus Christ.
  • Jacobovici claims that the reasons why Egyptian authority didn't grant him permission to dig around the border with Gaza and Israel during the making of the The Exodus Decoded[9] was because the Egyptians didn't want him to expose the truth that the biblical story of the Exodus is actually fact.
  • Hebrew slaves built the pyramids of Giza in Egypt. (Although no religious, historical (Egyptologists or other) or scientific proof exists to validate such claim especially when the tombs of the builders have already been found, near the pyramids of Giza[10].
  • Jacobovici claims that the water at El Balah descended into sinkholes so that the Hebrews could pass. [11], although the old testament clearly states that the water parted and the Hebrews walked on dryland.

Personal life

Simcha is an Orthodox Jew.[12] He is married to Nicole Kornberg and has 3 girls and a boy.[13]

Awards

Bibliography

  • Jacobovici, Simcha; Pellegrino, Charles (2007). The Jesus Family Tomb: The Discovery, the Investigation, and the Evidence That Could Change History. New York: HarperLuxe. ISBN 0061252999. {{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |month= ignored (help)

References

  1. ^ http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2006/09/Debunking-The-Exodus-Decoded.aspx
  2. ^ Jesus 'Tomb' Controversy Reopened - TIME
  3. ^ Video - Breaking News Videos from CNN.com
  4. ^ http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1704299,00.html
  5. ^ Duke University Religion Department: The Talpiot Tomb Controversy Revisited
  6. ^ .[1][]
  7. ^ a b 2007 Alumni/ae Reunion
  8. ^ http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2006/09/Debunking-The-Exodus-Decoded.aspx
  9. ^ http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2006/09/Debunking-The-Exodus-Decoded.aspx
  10. ^ ) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giza_pyramid_complex
  11. ^ http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2006/09/Debunking-The-Exodus-Decoded.aspx
  12. ^ SimchaJ Online :: The Faith and Films of Simcha Jacobovici
  13. ^ The Faith and Films of Simcha Jacobovici from www.simchaj.ca Accessed April 3, 2008
  14. ^ a b c d e f g h "About Simcha Jacobovici".
  15. ^ "Broadcast Awards (UK) 2006".
  16. ^ "28th Annual News & Documentary Emmy Awards".
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Simcha_Jacobovici&oldid=284004098"