Roger Casement
Roger David Casement (1 September, 1864 – 3 August, 1916) was a British diplomat by profession and a poet, Irish revolutionary and nationalist by inclination. He is famous for his activities against abuses of the colonial system in Africa and Peru, but more well known for his dealings with Germany prior to Ireland's Easter Rising in 1916.
Casement was born in Sandycove, near Dublin to a Protestant father and a Roman Catholic mother, the former Anne Jephson from County Wexford, who had him baptized as a Roman Catholic, but died when he was a baby. By the time he was ten, his father was also dead, and he was afterwards raised by Protestant paternal relatives in Ulster.
Casement in Africa
Casement went to Africa for the first time in 1883, at the age of only nineteen, working in Congo Free State for several companies and for King Léopold II of Belgium's Association Internationale Africaine. While in Congo, he also met the famous explorer Henry Morton Stanley during the latter's Emin Pasha Relief Expedition and became acquainted with the young Joseph Conrad, who was a sailor but had not yet published his novella Heart of Darkness about the Congo.
In 1892 Roger Casement left Congo to join the Colonial Office in Nigeria. In 1895 he became consul at Lourenço Marques (now Maputo).
By 1900 he was back in Congo, at Matadi, and founded the first British consular post in that country. In his dispatches to the Foreign Office he denounced the mistreatment of indigenous people and the catastrophic consequences of the forced labour system. In 1903, after the House of Commons, pressed by humanitarian activists, passed a resolution about Congo, Casement was charged to make an inquiry into the situation in the country. The result of his enquiry was his famous Congo Report.
The Report, issued in 1904 after a struggle to prevent the British government from keeping it secret, provoked a huge scandal. A short time before the issuing of the report, Casement met the journalist E. D. Morel, who led the anti-Congolese campaign by members of the British Press. It was the beginning of a profound relationship of friendship, admiration and collaboration on the Congo issue. Casement, who could not openly participate in the campaign due to his diplomatic status, persuaded Morel to found the Congo Reform Association.
His consular work in exposing Belgian exploitation in the Congo was the principal reason for his being made a KCMG in 1911.
The Putumayo
In 1906 Casement was sent to Santos, Brazil. He had the occasion to do work similar to that which he had done in Congo among the Putumayo Indians of Peru.
Irish revolutionary
Casement resigned from colonial service in 1912. The following year, he joined the Irish Volunteers, and became a close friend of the organisation's chief of staff Eoin MacNeill. When the First World War broke out in 1914, he attempted to secure German aid for Irish independence, sailing for Germany via America. He viewed himself as a self-appointed ambassador of the Irish nation. While the journey was his idea, he managed to persuade the exiled Irish nationalists in the Clan na Gael to finance the expedition. Many members of the Clan na Gael never trusted him completely, as he was not a member of the Irish Republican Brotherhood, and held views considered by many to be too moderate. Casement drafted a "treaty" with Germany, which stated that country's support for an independent Ireland. Most of his time in Germany, however, was spent in an attempt to recruit an "Irish Brigade" consisting of Irish prisoners-of-war in the prison camp of Limburg an der Lahn, who would be trained to fight against England. The effort proved unsuccessful, and was abandoned after much time and money was wasted. The Germans, who were sceptical of Casement but nonetheless aware of the military advantage they could gain from an uprising in Ireland, offered the Irish 20,000 guns, 10 machine guns and accompanying ammunition, a fraction of the amount of weaponry Casement had hoped for.
Casement did not learn about the Easter Rising until after the plan was fully developed. The IRB purposely kept him in the dark, and even tried to replace him. Casement may never have learned that it was not the Volunteers who were planning the rising, but IRB members such as Patrick Pearse and Tom Clarke who were pulling the strings behind the scenes.
The German weapons never reached Ireland. The ship in which they were travelling, a German cargo vessel, the Libau, was intercepted, even though it had been thoroughly disguised as a Norwegian vessel, Aud Norge. All the crew were German sailors, but their clothes and effects, even the charts and books on the bridge, were all Norwegian. The British, however, had intercepted German communications and knew the true identity and exact destination of the Aud. After it was intercepted, the ship's captain scuttled the ship.
Capture
Casement left Germany in a submarine, the U-19, shortly after the Aud sailed. Believing that the Germans were toying with him from the start, and purposely providing inadequate aid that would doom a rising to failure, he decided he had to reach Ireland before the shipment of arms, and convince Eoin MacNeill (who he believed was still in control) to cancel the rising.
In the early hours of 21 April, 1916, two days before the rising was scheduled to begin, Casement was put ashore at Banna Strand in County Kerry. Too weak to travel (he was ill), he was discovered and subsequently arrested on charges of treason, sabotage and espionage against the Crown.
Following a highly publicized trial, he was stripped of his knighthood. After an unsuccessful appeal against the death sentence, he was hanged at Pentonville Prison in London on 3 August, 1916, at the age of 51.
He was received into the Roman Catholic Church a few minutes before he was hanged, although his mother had already had him baptized as a child- a fact of which he was evidently unaware due to her death when he was a baby and the fact that he was raised by his Protestant father's family. So he was baptized twice, but never had First Communion or confirmation.
Among the people who pleaded for clemency for him were Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, who had participated in the Congo campaign and George Bernard Shaw. Edmund Dene Morel couldn't visit him in jail, being under attack for his pacifist position. On the other hand Joseph Conrad didn't forgive him for what he saw as his treachery toward Britain.
The Black Diaries and Casement's sexuality
Prior to his execution, pages of a diary which the Crown claimed belonged to Casement were circulated to those urging the commuting of his death sentence. These pages, supplied to King George V, the Archbishop of Canterbury, and others in Britain, Ireland and the United States, suggested that Casement had engaged in homosexual activity, which was a crime in most countries at the time. The effect of what became known as the Black Diary killed off much support for Casement's case. The Diaries are still classified, and are likely to remain so until sometime near 2020.
Most Irish people believed that the diaries were forgeries, much as Charles Stewart Parnell had been the target of the Pigott forgeries implicating him in the Phoenix Park Murders. However a recent study, which compared his White Diaries (ordinary diaries of the time) with the Black Diaries, which allegedly date from the same time-span, judged on the basis of detailed handwriting analysis, that the Black Diaries were indeed genuine, and had been written by Casement. This study is rejected by some people however as it consisted only of comparative handwriting analysis, and did not constitute a full forensic analysis of the diaries. There have been many cases where competent forgers have produced documents which passed a simple handwriting comparison.
It should be noted that the British did not go to the trouble of producing similar smears against anyone else involved in the Easter Rising, even though in the case of Patrick Pearse there are suspicions that he may have been homosexual. Equally, of course, there was no public clamour for mercy in the case of any of the other 1916 leaders condemned to death. The case for forgery of the Black Diaries has always been predicated on the fact that Casement was a uniquely admired and respected public figure in Britain among the 1916 leaders.
It has also been claimed that the Black Diaries describe an extremely active homosexual sex life which is unlikely to be genuine, but it has been argued that this does not refute the authenticity of the diaries, as they could also have been sexual fantasies.
However both these beliefs, that the diaries are forgeries or that they do not describe real sexual encounters, are held by a minority of commentators. Most historians and writers on the subject now accept both the validity of the diaries and the accuracy of the events they describe.
The issue of Casement's sexuality remains controversial. In any case, in the 21st century, this issue is seen by many as no longer relevant to an assessment of his political role. The controversy is sometimes seen as a reflection of a reluctance by conservative Irish Roman Catholics to accept that one of their heroes was gay.
State funeral and burial in Glasnevin Cemetery
As was the custom at the time, Casement's body was buried in quicklime in the yard at Pentonville Prison where he was hanged. In the mid 1960s Casement's body was repatriated and after a state funeral, was buried with full military honours in the Republican Plot in Glasnevin Cemetery in Dublin. The President of Ireland, Éamon de Valera, who in his mid-eighties was the last surviving leader of the Easter Rising, defied the advice of his doctors to attend the ceremony, along with an estimated 30,000 Irish citizens.
Casement is a national hero in Ireland, e.g. in strongly republican west Belfast the Gaelic football ground on the Falls Road is called Roger Casement Park. The character of Lord John Roxton in Arthur Conan Doyle's novel The Lost World is based on Casement.
Are the remains in Glasnevin really Casement's?
In the 1990s, doubts were cast as to whether the skeleton buried in Glasnevin actually was Casement's. It was suggested that when his prison grave was opened, it proved impossible to distinguish his bones from those of other prisoners. As a result a skeleton was assembled from bones found and described as Casement's.
It was even claimed that the remains were actually those of Doctor Crippen, a notorious murderer executed shortly before Casement. However, these claims were rejected by some people involved in the exhumation of Casement's remains.
In some people's opinion, the identity of the remains in Glasnevin Cemetery remains unknown until they are examined using DNA evidence from other descendants of the Casement family. DNA profiling was not available in the 1960s.
Bibliography
- B. Inglis, Roger Casement
- Adam Hochschild, King Leopold's Ghost
- Jeffrey Dudgeon, "Roger Casement: The Black Diaries"
- Roger Sawyer, "Casement: The Flawed Hero"
- Peter DaRosa, "Rebels: The Irish Rising of 1916"