Talk:Knocker (folklore)

Cornwall Unassessed

This article is within the scope of WikiProject Cornwall, an attempt to improve and expand Wikipedia coverage of Cornwall and all things Cornish. If you would like to participate, you can edit the article attached to this page, or visit the project member page, where you can join the project and/or contribute to the discussion.CornwallWikipedia:WikiProject CornwallTemplate:WikiProject CornwallCornwall-related articles

???

This article has not yet received a rating on Wikipedia's content assessment scale.

???

This article has not yet received a rating on the project's importance scale.

See drop-down box for suggested article edit guidelines:

Be bold - if you know something about Cornwall then put it in! We value your contributions and don't be afraid if your spelling isn't great as there are plenty of spelling and grammar experts on clean-up duty!
Articles on settlements in Cornwall should be written using the standard set of headings approved by the UK geography WikiProject's guideline How to write about settlements.
At WikiProject Cornwall we subscribe to the policies laid down by Wikipedia - particularly civility and consensus building. We are aware that the wording on Cornish entries can sometimes be a contentious topic, especially those concerning geography. You don't have to agree with everything but there is no excuse for rudeness and these things are best solved through consensus building and compromise. For more information see WP:CornwallGuideline.
These pages are not platforms for political discussion. Issues relating to Cornish politics should be restricted to those pages that directly deal with these issues (such as Constitutional status of Cornwall, Cornish nationalism, etc) and should not overflow into other articles.
Most of all have fun editing - that's the reason we all do this, right?!

There is absolutely nothing I can find anywhere to suggest that Welsh and Cornish coal miners called these beings "Knockers" and that "Tommyknocker" is an American derivation. They were and are called "Tommyknockers" in the land of their origin and the article should reflect that. It was inappropriate license to change the title of the articles.--User:Clarkpark (Howard Evans) 1:, 15 May 2006

Growing up in Cornwall I always knew them as 'knockers', and they were said to be the spirits of Jews brought to Cornwall as slaves by the Romans to work the mines. They would signal the presence of ore (not coal - coal has never been mined in Cornwall). They had to be treated with respect, else they would bring bad luck. I don't have sources to hand, but will find out what I can and come back to the article.--DuncanHill 21:42, 31 July 2006 (UTC)[reply]

I refer you to http://www.blm.gov/heritage/HE_Kids/tommy_knock.htm on the Bureau of Land Management website, and http://www.edcgov.us/stories/tommyknockers.htm on the El Dorado County site. Googling Tommyknockers and Knockers will reveal other data. While coal isn't common in Cornwall, it is in Wales, which is where most of the retreating Brythons wound up. Most of the data used to create this article came from the El Dorado site and a book on American myths and legends. The BLM site confirms the Cornish origin of the term Tommyknockers. The statement that you grew up in Cornwall lends you some credibility, though not nearly as much as you'd have if you could say you grew up in Cornwall two hundred years ago before the Cornish brought these legends here.— Preceding unsigned comment added by Clarkpark (talk • contribs)

Coal is indeed not common in Cornwall - there isn't any (except at the coal-merchants!)DuncanHill 23:39, 10 December 2006 (UTC)[reply]

More seriously, see http://www.mysteriousbritain.co.uk/folklore/english_folk/knockers.html for a British view. DuncanHill 23:42, 10 December 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Here are some further links:

which I hope will be helpful. DuncanHill 23:50, 10 December 2006 (UTC)[reply]

The citations are not just helpful, but fascinating. One problem, though, is that they reflect only the Cornish perspective. Knockers also peopled the Welsh coal and metal mines. That Tommyknockers is an American derivation makes etymological sense since Tommy was American slang for Brits (although I have no idea why). It's reasonable to start with the working assumption that these legends go back to the time before the Welsh and Cornish were sundered by the Anglo-Saxon invasions of the 2nd through 6th centuries, when the Brythons were a geographically contigious cultural group. Also, are the quotes from Kingsley about the souls of diaspora Jews an accurate rendering of oral traditions, or embroidered with artistic license. The pantheon of the Celts, both large and small, is quite varied and many entities and stories differ substantively from place to place. Are you aware of any Welsh data on diminutive mine dwellers? Or legends that predate Anglo-Saxon Britain? ~~Clarkpark~~ (Howard Evans at clarkpark@twcny.rr.com)

confusing

I added the confusing template because the article is indeed very confusing. At points it is difficult to tell weather it is talking about Welsh people or the mythical creatures, and it tries very little to ephasize the mythical side of the stories. Besides there is usage of slang such as "wee miners" and there is simply no source material listed at all.

--Fmafra 17:56, 18 July 2006 (UTC)[reply]

And I just removed it. When a second person tells you it's confusing, put the flag back. Until then, you should assume your confusion to be individual. I reread the article and can see literally no possibility that someone would be confused as to "weather" gnomes or actual miners were being refered to. Moreover, a corroborating source for much of the data herein is cited – the El Dorado County website. Did you actually read this article before you flagged it? It's very hard to find any correlation between it and your comments. ~~Clarkpark~~ Dec 10, 2006 — Preceding unsigned comment added by Clarkpark (talk • contribs)

Knocker vs Tommyknocker

Tommyknocker is not a US derivation of Knocker. The reason both words are used in Cornwall and also in places where Cornish miners influenced mining communities (Especially Canada and USA) is because Tommyknockers and Knockers are not the same the thing. There is a subtle difference. Knockers are members of the "wee folk" that live underground and whose attitude toward miners ranges from malicious to benevolent depending on the amount of respect the miners show to the Knockers. Many miners in Canada and USA (and Cornish miners with whom I've worked) still follow customs intended to show respect for Knockers "just in case", for example; never whistling underground, leaving a tiny bit of food outside your lunch-pail, etc. There is also a belief that if a miner dies underground then his soul will be trapped in the mine and he will be compelled by the Knockers to join them in their labour. The trapped souls of the men who have died in the mine are called Tommyknockers. SGM — Preceding unsigned comment added by 12.42.149.34 (talk • contribs)

I and my sources disagree. However I'd love to see corroboration of your assertion. If you can find any, this should be added to the article, even if prefaced by an alternate theory disclaimer. I find the concept of Tommyknockers as trapped souls to be profoundly poetic and romantic. ~~Clarkpark~~ Dec 10, 2006 — Preceding unsigned comment added by Clarkpark (talk • contribs)