Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2006 June 19: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→[[True Torah Jews]]: closing moribund debate |
→[[Sick Nick Mondo]]: closing moribund debate |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
===19 June 2006=== |
===19 June 2006=== |
||
====[[Sick Nick Mondo]]==== |
|||
[[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sick Nick Mondo]] |
|||
The decision of delete has led to the article causing problems among wrestling notability requirements as the wrestler in question, Nick Mondo, has had a DVD about his wrestling career released and is filming documentaries on wrestling. He is also, among the indy and hardcore wrestling scenes, considered especially notable. The article has then been pointed to as a sort of "if Nick Mondo wasn't worthy of an article then X isn't worth either". Another issue is the article already exists at [[Nick Mondo]] and can't be made into a redirect because it was protected. --- [[User:Lid|Lid]] 10:17, 19 June 2006 (UTC) |
|||
*'''Merge contents of [[Sick Nick Mondo]] into [[Nick Mondo]] and redirect'''. <s>The existence of the article at [[Nick Mondo]] was not mentioned on the AfD, and as such it is reasonble to presume the voters in this low-participation AfD were not aware of it.</s> Both "Nick" and "Sick Nick" articles contain assertions of notablity, but there are different ones such that I feel there is information to merge. I think a redirect from one to the other would be fine, I take the "do not redirect" comment in the afd to be referring to earlier suggestion that it should be redirected to [[Brownian motion]]. Redirects from nicknames are standard practice - see [[:Category:Redirects from alternate names]], I don't think the redirect will need protecting. [[User:Thryduulf|Thryduulf]] 12:13, 19 June 2006 (UTC) |
|||
**Following Rossami's comments below about timing, which I admit I neglected to look at, I '''endorse the closure''' as valid at the time of closure, but additional information has been provided and there should be no prejudice against a sourced, notable article. Once the information has been merged, there should be no prejudice against a deletion nomination if it is still felt he is not notable enough. While an article that exists about this person, a redirect is apropriate, per my previous comments. If the article is deleted the redirect can be deleted per [[WP:CSD#Redirects|CSD R1]] - the normal course of events. [[User:Thryduulf|Thryduulf]] 08:07, 20 June 2006 (UTC) |
|||
*<s>Overturn and merge anything useful into [[Nick Mondo]]. This information wasn't presented in the original AfD, and certainly seems to be a valid merge target. --[[User:Deathphoenix|Deathphoenix]] [[User_talk:Deathphoenix|'''ʕ''']] 18:25, 19 June 2006 (UTC)</s> |
|||
**Change to '''Endorse closure''' per Rossami's information. I obviously didn't look deeply enough into the timing of everything. Duh. --[[User:Deathphoenix|Deathphoenix]] [[User_talk:Deathphoenix|'''ʕ''']] 05:37, 20 June 2006 (UTC) |
|||
*<s>'''Overturn and merge''' - sometimes things slip through the cracks and this seems to be such case. [[User:Doc Tropics|Doc Tropics]] 04:35, 20 June 2006 (UTC)</s> |
|||
**Change to '''Endorse closure''' - heh, I didn't think to actually look at dates<Wipes egg off face> Thanks to [[User:Rossami|Rossami]] for a learning experience. [[User:Doc Tropics|Doc Tropics]] 08:49, 20 June 2006 (UTC) |
|||
* The [[Sick Nick Mondo]] article was deleted as the result of an AFD decision on 16 May 2006 (and re-deleted on 26 May). The [[Nick Mondo]] article was first created on 17 June. The [[Nick Mondo]] article is therefore re-created content. (It could not have been mentioned in the AFD discussion because it did not exist at the time.) Reviewing the versions, I consider the newest version to be sufficiently different that it probably does not qualify for the speedy-deletion criteria. However, the core concern of the first deletion decision remains unanswered. I find no new evidence to convince me that the previous decision was obviously wrong. '''Endorse closure''' of the "Sick Nick" deletion discussion pending an immediate AFD discussion of the new version. If and only if the new version is kept, then undelete the old version and allow the redirect. [[User:Rossami|Rossami]] <small>[[User talk:Rossami|(talk)]]</small> 05:30, 20 June 2006 (UTC) |
|||
*'''Endorse closure''' per [[User:Rossami|Rossami]]. [[User:Metamagician3000|Metamagician3000]] 07:41, 20 June 2006 (UTC) |
|||
*'''Endorse closure''' of the original [[Sick Nick Mondo]] decision; should [[Nick Mondo]] come up for AfD I'm pretty sure it'd pass through, because in addition to his body of work in CZW, he's become a video game character, too. I'm adding links to the article now. Once [[Nick Mondo]] is AfD'd or not, there should either be a redirect from [[Sick Nick Mondo]] to [[Nick Mondo]] or the article currently in residence at Nick should be moved to Sick Nick. Try saying THAT three times fast. [[User talk:RasputinAXP|<font color="#FFFFFF" style="background: maroon;"> RasputinAXP </font>]] [[Special:Contributions/RasputinAXP|<small>c</small>]] 10:50, 20 June 2006 (UTC) |
|||