Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Airlines Flight 1118: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 23:01, 4 April 2024

Doesn't meet WP:Notability, and its also missing the main flight template box. The whole article is unorganized. — Preceding unsigned comment added by ZAviation21 (talk • contribs) 4 April 2024 at 21:39 (UTC)

Keep: As article creator. Also, that reasoning is very short, I doubt it's going to go very far. First AFD by creator and it's already an erroneous one. In addition, lack of templates is not a reason to nominate an article for deletion. If it's unorganized, why don't you be bold and fix it yourself? thetechie@wikimedia: ~/talk/ $ 22:02, 4 April 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Delete: That is only part of the problem. The big problem with this article is that it isn't a notable event. Compressor stalls happen all the time so if Wikipedia considers compressor stall events a "notable event", there would be hundreds of articles about that in list of accidents and incidents involving commercial aircraft. Ok here is an example of a removed article that was pulled last month. UA35, you now what that is right? if not, it was a United 777 that lost a wheel on take off and hit a parked car. that was pulled due to it not meeting the notability criteria. I admire that you want to add an event to the list but it just isn't relevant enough to be added to the list. IDKUggaBanga (talk) 22:34, 4 April 2024 (UTC)[reply]

also shameless plug, if you want to read that article and read why it was pulled, go to the internet archive, I saved those pages to read if one wants to. IDKUggaBanga (talk) 22:35, 4 April 2024 (UTC)[reply]

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 * '''Keep''': As article creator. Also, that reasoning is very short, I doubt it's going to go very far. '''First AFD by creator and it's already an erroneous one.''' In addition, lack of templates is not a reason to nominate an article for deletion. If it's unorganized, why don't you [[WP:BOLD|be bold and fix it yourself]]? <span style="background:black; color: white"><span style="color:LimeGreen">[[W:EN:User:TheTechie|<span style="color:LimeGreen">thetechie@wikimedia</span>]]</span>: [[User talk:TheTechie|<span style="color:DodgerBlue">~/talk/</span>]] <span style="color:White">$</span></span> 22:02, 4 April 2024 (UTC)
-:That is only part of the problem. The big problem with this article is that it isn't a notable event. Compressor stalls happen all the time so if Wikipedia considers compressor stall events a "notable event", there would be hundreds of articles about that in list of accidents and incidents involving commercial aircraft. Ok here is an example of a removed article that was pulled last month. UA35, you now what that is right? if not, it was a United 777 that lost a wheel on take off and hit a parked car. that was pulled due to it not meeting the notability criteria. I admire that you want to add an event to the list but it just isn't relevant enough to be added to the list. [[User:IDKUggaBanga|IDKUggaBanga]] ([[User talk:IDKUggaBanga|talk]]) 22:34, 4 April 2024 (UTC)
+* '''Delete''': That is only part of the problem. The big problem with this article is that it isn't a notable event. Compressor stalls happen all the time so if Wikipedia considers compressor stall events a "notable event", there would be hundreds of articles about that in list of accidents and incidents involving commercial aircraft. Ok here is an example of a removed article that was pulled last month. UA35, you now what that is right? if not, it was a United 777 that lost a wheel on take off and hit a parked car. that was pulled due to it not meeting the notability criteria. I admire that you want to add an event to the list but it just isn't relevant enough to be added to the list. [[User:IDKUggaBanga|IDKUggaBanga]] ([[User talk:IDKUggaBanga|talk]]) 22:34, 4 April 2024 (UTC)
 ::also shameless plug, if you want to read that article and read why it was pulled, go to the internet archive, I saved those pages to read if one wants to. [[User:IDKUggaBanga|IDKUggaBanga]] ([[User talk:IDKUggaBanga|talk]]) 22:35, 4 April 2024 (UTC)