Wikipedia:WikiProject Spoken Wikipedia: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Bowie60 (talk | contribs)
Removed notice of work on Warren G. Harding
Line 126: Line 126:
| [[2008-08-09]]
| [[2008-08-09]]
| {{User|Maedin}}
| {{User|Maedin}}
|-
| [[Warren G. Harding]]
| [[2008-08-10]]
| {{User|Bowie60}}
|}
|}



Revision as of 21:59, 16 August 2008

The WikiProject Spoken Wikipedia aims to produce recordings of Wikipedia articles being read aloud. See Spoken articles for articles that have already been recorded, and Requests for instructions on how to request a recording of a particular article.

Template:RSS2

How to create a spoken article

  1. Choose an article
  2. Record
    (optionally, see reading guidelines (under construction) for help on how to read an article when recording)
  3. Upload
  4. Add to article
  5. Add to Spoken articles list

Benefits

Some people wonder why creating spoken recordings of articles is worthwhile, so a quick discussion of the unique benefits is in order.

  • Spoken articles make Wikipedia content available to those who can understand English but cannot read it.
  • Users can listen to Wikipedia articles while they perform tasks that preclude reading but not concentration (such as biking, running, doing housework, etc.).
  • Visually-impaired users can use screen readers, of course, but with current technology, they may not be as accurate as a human vocal performance. This is particularly true of articles relating to science, mathematics, linguistics, and other areas where unusual pronunciation or symbols are prevalent.
  • They are a valuable learning tool for those learning English, but only if a link is given to the version of the page that is read. This allows readers to listen to the words being pronounced while reading the words.
  • Some may find it easier to concentrate on reading an article while listening to it, especially in an environment with distracting sounds (with the use of headphones).
  • In performing the articles aloud, readers end up catching inconsistencies, redundancies, and awkward phrases that might have been missed by other editors. In this way, the written version of Wikipedia improves.

Problems

However, the project does have some difficulties and drawbacks that one should be aware of:

  • Recording and editing articles can be time-consuming, and recordings are sometimes abandoned or have their source text dramatically changed before they are finished.
  • Incorrect pronunciation can mislead non-English-speaking users.
  • To maintain a consistent vocal sound and to avoid the degradation in sound quality that comes from re-editing compressed audio files, edits to an existing recording should be done by the original recorder. Thus, in cases where a recording needs to be modified and the original recorder is not available to do it, the recording may need to be re-recorded entirely or removed.
  • The audio file format used in Wikipedia is the open source standard, Ogg Vorbis, which avoids proprietary formats which may include DRM provisions. However, audio files encoded in Ogg Vorbis are not widely supported in many portable digital music players. For information on how to play Ogg Vorbis files on a computer, see the Ogg media help page.
  • Wikipedia articles are constantly evolving. Once created, audio versions become less and less accurate when compared with the current article (unless updated too).
  • There is no way to follow or indicate links. One possible solution is Audio Hyperlinks

Alternatives

For people wishing to listen to articles that don't yet have a spoken version:

  • Software that converts text to voice is readily available and can be easily used to read out Wikipedia pages on-the-fly.
  • The web-based Pediaphon service uses speech synthesis to generate MP3 audio files and podcasts from all English, French and German language Wikipedia articles.

In progress

Recordings

The following articles are currently being recorded or edited. This list is maintained to prevent duplicate recordings, and to keep other project members informed of a recording's progress. Please only place yourself on the list once you have begun work on a recorded version, not before you've actually started. If an article has been on this list for several weeks the user may have become too busy for the project and you should feel free to drop them a reminder on their talk page. If the user updates the list to indicate that the recording process has finished, they may appreciate help in editing the recordings so feel free to offer.

Article Date User
Template:FA Commonwealth of Nations 2008-02-14 Robert Beck (talk · contribs)
Template:FA Archimedes 2008-03-22 Pejore (talk · contribs)
Template:FA Screen Reader 2008-03-24 Alanajordan (talk · contribs)
Template:FA William Gibson 2008-04-20 Dfmclean (t)
Duran Duran 2008-04-24 Seraphim♥ Whipp
Template:FA Crazy Taxi (series) 2008-05-03 browndj3 (t)
Template:FA Super Smash Bros. Melee 2008-05-05 User:Youre dreaming eh? (t)
Template:FA Make Way For Ducklings 2008-05-22 Kaloethos (talk · contribs)
Template:FA Siege of Antioch 2008-06-04 PhoenixOwl (talk · contribs)
Template:FA Trafford 2008-06-22 Hassocks5489 (talk · contribs)
Great Barrier Reef 2008-06-23 Dskluz (talk · contribs)
Template:FA Doomsday (Doctor Who) 2008-06-25 Buc (talk · contribs)
Heroes (TV Series) 2008-07-05 Padillah (talk · contribs)
Template:FA History of Texas A&M University 2008-07-14 Fliry Vorru (talk · contribs)
Template:FA Copyright 2008-07-27 Rfwoolf (talk · contribs)
Wikipedia:About 2008-08-04 Collegebookworm (t)
Template:FA Greater Manchester 2008-08-07 Hassocks5489 (talk · contribs)
Template:FA Noble gases 2008-08-14 Wiki_Roxor (talk · contribs)
Template:FA History of timekeeping devices 2008-08-09 Maedin (talk · contribs)

Review

There is a process for reviewing Spoken Wikipedia recordings to ensure quality control as discussed in Wikipedia:WikiProject Spoken Wikipedia/Review. Please add your name to the table below if you are reviewing an article to prevent duplicated reviews. A list of reviewed files can be found here.

Article Date Reviewing user Progress
Template:FA Freak Out! 2008-06-01 Hassocks5489 (Talk) Completed
Template:FA Grim Fandango 2008-06-03 PopularOutcast (Talk) Completed
Template:FA Edward Low 2008-06-04 Hassocks5489 (Talk) Completed
George Washington 2008-06-01 Hassocks5489 (Talk) Pending
Christopher Cox 2008-08-01 Hassocks5489 (Talk) Completed
Template:FA Isaac Newton 2008-08-01 Hassocks5489 (Talk) Completed
Template:FA Black Seminoles 2008-08-09 Maedin (Talk) Completed

Active participants

Please click here to view the users who participate in this Wikiproject.

Task forces

Award

Barnstar
Barnstar

This project has its very own official barnstar.

According to Wikipedia:Barnstars on Wikipedia (Wikipedia:WikiProject awards):

The Spoken Barnstar may be awarded to an editor who makes outstanding contributions in the form of spoken articles for Wikipedia. Outstanding contributions may include: recording ten good articles, recording three featured articles, or doing an incredibly good job of recording one long, complex, excellent, featured article despite all odds.

See also