Jump to content

Wild Life in the Far West

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Shamrox (talk | contribs) at 07:51, 14 February 2022 (→Contemporary reaction). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Wild Life in the Far West
AuthorJames Hobbs
LanguageEnglish
PublisherWiley, Waterman & Eaton
Publication date
1872
Publication placeUnited States

Wild Life in the Far West: Personal Adventures of a Border Mountain Man is a purported memoir of life in the 19th-century American west written by James Hobbs (c. 1819 – 1880)[1] first published in 1872. The text alleges to be a firsthand account of many important events in the early American West: Hobbs claims to have been a member of Kit Carson's exploratory party, fought in the Mexican-American War, and the prospected during the California Gold Rush. Wild Life has been summarized by historical author David Remley as "a fanciful book of 'personal adventures'...much of which is clearly exaggerated and perhaps wholly fabricated."[2]

The book is primarily notable in that—despite numerous falsehoods—it remains in print and a commonly-cited reference by academic authors detailing early California and Native American civilizations. The book covers places and times where firsthand testimonials were rare, and some authors cite Hobbs' book as a reference while simultaneously warning that his testimony is unreliable.[3] Notable texts that have cited Hobbs' book include Captives and Cousins by James F. Brooks, The Comanche Empire by Pekka Hämäläinen,[4] and The Apache Wars by Paul Andrew Hutton.

Original publication and promotional tour

The book was first published in 1872 by the Connecticut firm of Wiley, Waterman & Eaton, with the stories being “taken down from [Hobbs’] own dictation by two different writers in” Hartford.[5] The initial printing was nearly 500 pages and contained a number of elaborate illustrations. The book was heavily advertised in newspapers across the country and was distributed widely upon release.

Following publication of Wild Life in the Far West, Hobbs embarked on speaking tours throughout the eastern half of the United States. At these engagements, he was often billed as "Comanche Jim," and performed a combination of lasso tricks and stories at schools and courthouses.[6][7] One review compared his lecture to a "rehash of Beadle's dime novels."[8]

By 1877, he had begun telling audiences that he was the great-grandson of Tecumseh—a statement that appears to have had no basis in reality.[6] In January 1878, Hobbs was committed to a Cincinnati, Ohio insane asylum “as a lunatic.”[7] Sometime later that year he was moved to the National Soldiers Home in Dayton, where he continued giving his well-rehearsed lectures to the other inmates.[9] Hobbs died at the home of his friend “Rocky Mountain Jim” in Brookville, Ohio on February 22, 1880.[10][1] He is buried at the Dayton National Cemetery.[11]

Contemporary reaction

Several chapters from Wild Life in the Far West are set in California's Inyo County, primarily taking place during the so-called Owens Valley Indian War of the 1860s. Pleasant Chalfant, longtime Inyo resident and senior editor of the Inyo Independent newspaper, was likely an acquaintance of Hobbs and proved a steadfast critic of his writing. In 1874, he ran passages from Wild Life in the Independent under the heading "Another Chapter of Those Lies," while also inviting local citizens to write in with corrected versions of tales from Hobbs' book.[12]

Inyo County Sheriff W.L. "Dad" Moore wrote to the Independent correcting Hobbs' error-filled account of the January 1865 McGuire family murders at Haiwee Meadows and subsequent Native American massacre at Owens Lake. In addition to getting many basic dates, names, and details incorrect, Wild Life also paints Hobbs as a major player in both events. In his letter to the Independent, Moore asserts that Hobbs was not present at all, and in fact "was never in this country until four or five years after these occurrences."[13] Moore further expounded: "During my life I have read a number of fabulous narratives, romances founded on the semblance of facts; but after reading that little yarn of Capt. Hobbs'...I am compelled to say that of the many stupendous frauds submitted to an enlightened public, this story of Hobbs' eclipses anything that has been written. [...] I must say that any person who is familiar with the history of this country will give no credence whatever to any of Capt. Hobbs' stories."[13]

In 1876, an acquaintance of Hobbs wrote Chicago's Inter Ocean newspaper with multiple accusations against the author's character, stating that "he is the author of [Wild Life] about as much as Spotted Tail is of the Pentateuch."[14]

Later reception

In his 2003 book Kit Carson & His Three Wives: A Family History (published by University of New Mexico Press), Marc Simmons notes that Hobbs "claimed to have been a companion of" Kit Carson. Simmons further states that Wild Life in the Far West "popularized the fiction that" Carson's daughter Adaline's Arapaho name was "Prairie Flower," noting that Hobbs plagiarized the concept from the 1853 book Lena Leota, or The Prairie Flower by J.P.R. James.[3]

References

  1. ^ a b The Inter Ocean, Chicago Illinois, 13 Mar 1880, p. 7: “Kit Carson’s Companion.” Obituary for James Hobbs.
  2. ^ Remley, D. (2011). Kit Carson: The Life of an American Border Man. United States: University of Oklahoma Press. Pp. 98
  3. ^ a b Simmons, Marc. Kit Carson & his three wives: a family history. Albuquerque, University of New Mexico Press, 2003. Pp. 90-91.
  4. ^ Hämäläinen, P. (2009). The Comanche Empire. United Kingdom: Yale University Press.
  5. ^ Hartford Courant (Hartford, Connecticut), 26 Aug 1872, p. 2: “The Life of Capt. Hobbs.”
  6. ^ a b The Evansville Journal, Evansville Indiana, 6 Jul 1877, p. 8: “Tecumseh Heard From. His Great Grandson Visits Evansville and Spends the Fourth. Comanche Jim, Indian Scout and Greaser Hunter on the Lecture Trail.”
  7. ^ a b The Evansville Journal, Evansville Indiana, 17 Jan 1878, p. 4: “Comanche Jim.”
  8. ^ The Evansville Journal, Evansville Indiana, 10 Aug 1876, p. 8: "New Harmony."
  9. ^ The Weekly Marysville Tribune, Marysville Ohio, 1 Jan 1879, p. 2: “From Dayton—National Soldiers Home.”
  10. ^ The National Archives in Washington, DC; Washington, DC, USA; Historical Register of National Homes for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers, 1866-1938; Series: M1749 – James Hobbs.
  11. ^ Find A Grave memorial for James Hobbs
  12. ^ Inyo Independent, 5 September 1874, p. 1: "Murder of Hog Rogers: Another Chapter of Those Lies." Viewable through the California Digital Newspaper Collection.
  13. ^ a b Inyo Independent, 5 September 1874, p. 2: "Historical Facts." Viewable through the California Digital Newspaper Collection.
  14. ^ The Inter Ocean (Chicago, Illinois), 17 Feb 1876, p. 2: “Comanche Jim”, letter to the editor from “Dry Prairie” of West Leroy, Michigan.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wild_Life_in_the_Far_West&oldid=1071769543"