Jump to content

Sulky Girl

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Beatleswhobeachboys (talk | contribs) at 04:41, 18 September 2023 (→Critical reception). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

"Sulky Girl"
Single by Elvis Costello
from the album Brutal Youth
B-side"A Drunken Man's Praise of Sobriety"
Released21 February 1994
GenreNew wave
LabelWarner Bros.
Songwriter(s)Elvis Costello
Producer(s)Mitchell Froom
Elvis Costello singles chronology
"Jacksons, Monk and Rowe"
(1993) 		"Sulky Girl"
(1994) 		"13 Steps Lead Down"
(1994)

"Sulky Girl" is a song written and performed by new wave musician Elvis Costello that was first released on his 1994 album Brutal Youth. The song was one of those on the album that featured Costello performing with his longtime backing band the Attractions, who reunited during the course of the album's recording. As such, Costello singled out the song as an instance of the band's ability to play loudly and aggressively.

"Sulky Girl" was released as the first single from Brutal Youth in 1994 and became Costello's highest charting UK single in eleven years, although Costello chalked up this success to successful promotion by Warner Bros. as opposed to organic commercial appeal. The song's classic Attractions style garnered the song critical acclaim and the song has since appeared on Costello compilation albums.

Background

Costello wrote "Sulky Girl" shortly after a one-day writing spree by Costello where he composed six of the songs that would appear on the Brutal Youth album.[1][2]

The track was one of the songs on Brutal Youth that featured Costello's reunited backing band the Attractions. Costello later named "13 Steps Lead Down" and "Sulky Girl" as "reminders that [the Attractions] could also be a pretty great rock and roll band".[2] Recalling the sessions in a 1994 interview, he stated:

We hit the end of the chorus, and it was just roaring. Everybody was taking it as far as they could. It was the first time we'd played anything hard since coming back. Mitchell Froom came out of the control room, and it looked like what he'd heard had parted his hair. This band can plaster you against the back wall when it wants to.[3]

Release

"Sulky Girl" was released as the first single from Brutal Youth in the UK. The B-side is "A Drunken Man's Praise of Sobriety", where Costello sings the Yeats poem of the same name over an instrumental.[4] The song's traditional sound made it a candidate for commercial success, to the point that Phillip Leblond of Rock & Folk said of the song, "Think of that: on this album, there is a single by Elvis Costello THAT COULD BECOME A HIT! Don't move, I'm going to call Warner..."[5]

The single reached number 22 in the UK, the highest charting Costello single there since "Pills and Soap" in 1983. Despite this, Costello did not view the single as an organic hit and credited it to record company promotion: "'Sulky Girl' they'd managed to chart and we'd gone on Top of the Pops — but basically it was the usual major record company hocus-pocus that got us into the charts, it didn't actually sell convincingly."[6] The song was not released as a single in the US; a writer for the Washington Post described it as "a great new song that radio won't play."[7]

The song has since appeared on an EP of the same name as well as on the compilation albums Extreme Honey and The Very Best of Elvis Costello.

Critical reception

"Sulky Girl" saw positive reception from music writers upon its release. In a column for Melody Maker, Greg Dulli of Afghan Whigs praised the song, commenting, "This is a throwback for Elvis. But he's throwing back to himself. I like this, A lot of sounds going on. He sings the hell out of a tune. Layer after layer of irony, he can't be any other way. ... He's a brilliant satirist — he should probably write books. It's very bitter. I wonder if he wrote it about Cait?"[8] Rolling Stone noted, that the "signature riff of 'Sulky Girl' harkens back to the stripped-down style of My Aim Is True,"[9] while CD Review wrote, "'Sulky Girl' trots out three different chorus hooks, all of them killer."[10] Hot Press observed, that on the song, Costello and the Attractions are "revamping their typically abrasive and claustrophobic sound and soldering the whole lot to a thoroughly modern 1990's sensibility. All the word play of Armed Forces is present but so too, in an uncanny and rather frightening manner, is that unmistakable sound of the cascading keyboards of 'Oliver's Army.'"[11]

Retrospectively, Jeremy Allen of The Guardian called it a "classic",[12] while Anthony Breznican wrote, "I fell hard for 'Sulky Girl,' as I tended to do in real life."[13] Gary Stewart of Trunkworthy praised "the chorus and that melody, which is instantly catchy and so inspired it makes even the most jaded music snob think of the dreaded cliche, 'How does he come up with this?'"[14] Diffuser.fm praised the song's "raw vitality."[15]

Paste Magazine ranked "Sulky Girl" as the fourth greatest Elvis Costello song, stating that on Brutal Youth, "Costello was free to let his ravaged vocals tatter in and around soaring power-pop ballads, the best of which is 'Sulky Girl,' a song comparing the narrator’s current partner with another, less sure but still desirable woman who ran away from home, dyed her hair and adopted a new name."[16]

Charts

Chart (1994) Peak
position
UK Singles (OCC)[17] 22

References

Citations

  1. ^ Thomson 2006.
  2. ^ a b Brutal Youth (Liner notes). Elvis Costello. 2002.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
  3. ^ Moon, Tom (March 8, 1994). "Elvis Costello looks back". Philadelphia Inquirer: E1–E6.
  4. ^ Mason, Stewart. "Elvis Costello - Sulky Girl". AllMusic. Retrieved 11 February 2023.
  5. ^ Leblond, Philippe (April 1994). "Brutal Youth". Rock & Folk. 320.
  6. ^ Doggett, Peter (October 1995). "Elvis Costello: The Record Collector Interview, Part 2". Record Collector. 194.
  7. ^ Leiby, Richard (June 18, 1994). "Elvis lives! A trip with the angry '70s rocker through the Ohio of his soul". Washington Post.
  8. ^ Dulli, Greg; Stubbs, David (1994-02-26). "Singles: Mr. Digable (aka Greg Dulli of Afghan Whigs) and Mr. Agreeable". Melody Maker: 29.
  9. ^ O'Connor, Rob (24 March 1994). "Brutal Youth". Rolling Stone. Retrieved 11 February 2023.
  10. ^ Milano, Brett (March 1994). "Elvis Costello: A Brutal Youth". CD Review: 12–13.
  11. ^ Brennan, Patrick (March 9, 1994). "Sulky Girl". Hot Press.
  12. ^ Allen, Jeremy. "Elvis Costello: 10 of the best". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 18 February 2019. Retrieved 17 February 2019.
  13. ^ Breznican, Anthony. "Disappearing Ink: A tribute to Elvis Costello's 'Brutal Youth,' released 21 years ago". Entertainment Weekly. Retrieved 11 February 2023.
  14. ^ Stewart, Gary; Gorman, David. "The Elvis Costello Song of the Week: Sulky Girls & The Men Who Stalk Them". Trunkworthy. Retrieved 11 February 2023.
  15. ^ Wawzenek, Bryan. "Elvis Costello Albums Ranked in Order of Awesomeness". Diffuser.fm. Retrieved 11 February 2023.
  16. ^ Prado, Ryan J. (23 May 2014). "The 20 Best Songs By Elvis Costello". Paste. Retrieved 11 February 2023.
  17. ^ "Official Singles Chart Top 100". Official Charts Company. Retrieved 27 February 2019.

Sources

  • Thomson, Graeme (2006). Complicated Shadows: The Life and Music of Elvis Costello. Canongate U.S. ISBN 978-1841957968.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sulky_Girl&oldid=1175898681"