Collision-induced absorption and emission
In spectroscopy, collision-induced absorption and emission refers to spectral features generated by inelastic collisions of molecules in a gas. Such inelastic collisions (along with the absorption or emission of photons) may induce quantum transitions in the molecules, or the molecules may form transient supramolecular complexes with spectral features different from the underlying molecules. Collision-induced absorption and emission is particularly important in dense gases, such as hydrogen and helium clouds found in astronomical systems.
Collision-induced absorption and emission is distinguished from collisional broadening in spectroscopy in that collisional broadening comes from elastic collisions of molecules, whereas collision-induced absorption and emission is an inherently inelastic process.
- 1 Collision-induced spectra of gases
- 2 Interaction-induced dipoles
- 3 Historical sketch
- 4 Collision-induced spectra
- 5 Virial expansions of spectral intensities
- 6 Spectra of van der Waals molecules
- 7 An example of CIA spectra
- 8 Significance
- 9 Data base
- 10 References
Collision-induced spectra of gases
Ordinary spectroscopy is concerned with the spectra of single atoms or molecules. Here we outline the very different spectra of complexes consisting of two or more interacting atoms or molecules: the "interaction-induced" or "collision-induced" spectroscopy. Both ordinary and collision-induced spectra may be observed in emission and absorption and require an electric or magnetic multipole moment - in most cases an electric dipole moment - to exist for an optical transition to take place from an initial to a final quantum state of a molecule or a molecular complex. (For brevity of expression we will use here the term "molecule" interchangeably for atoms as well as molecules). A complex of interacting molecules may consist of two or more molecules in a collisional encounter, or else of a weakly bound van der Waals molecule. On first sight, it may seem strange to treat optical transitions of a collisional complex, which may exist just momentarily, for the duration of a fly-by encounter (roughly 10−13 seconds), in much the same way as this was long done for molecules in ordinary spectroscopy. But even transient complexes of molecules may be viewed as a new, "supermolecular" system which is subject to the same spectroscopic rules as ordinary molecules. Ordinary molecules may be viewed as complexes of atoms that have new and possibly quite different spectroscopic properties than the individual atoms the molecule consists of, when the atoms are not bound together as a molecule (or are not "interacting"). Similarly, complexes of interacting molecules may (and usually do) acquire new optical properties, which often are absent in the non-interacting, well separated individual molecules.
Collision-induced absorption (CIA) and emission (CIE) spectra are well known in the microwave and infrared regions of the electromagnetic spectrum, but they occur in special cases also in the visible and near ultraviolet regions. Collision-induced spectra have been observed in nearly all dense gases, and also in many liquids and solids. CIA and CIE are due to the intermolecular interactions, which generate electric dipole moments. We note that an analogous collision-induced light scattering (CILS) or Raman process also exists, which is well studied and is in many ways completely analogous to CIA and CIE. CILS arises from interaction-induced polarizability increments of molecular complexes; the excess polarizability of a complex, relative the sum of polarizabilities of the noninteracting molecules.
Molecules interact at close range through intermolecular forces (the "van der Waals forces"), which cause minute shifts of the electron density distributions (relative the distributions of electrons when the molecules are not interacting). Intermolecular forces are repulsive at near range, where electron exchange forces dominate the interaction, and attractive at somewhat greater separations, where the dispersion forces are active. (If separations are further increased, all intermolecular forces fall off rapidly and may be totally neglected.) Repulsion and attraction are due, respectively, to the small defects or excesses of electron densities of molecular complexes in the space between the interacting molecules, which often result in interaction-induced electric dipole moments that contribute some to interaction-induced emission and absorption intensities. The resulting dipoles are referred to as exchange force-induced dipole and dispersion force-induced dipoles, respectively.
Other dipole induction mechanisms also exist in molecular (as opposed to monatomic) gases and in mixtures of gases, when molecular gases are present. Molecules have centers of positive charge (the nuclei), which are surrounded by a cloud of electrons. Molecules thus may be thought of being surrounded by various electric multipolar fields which will polarize any collisional partner momentarily in a fly-by encounter, generating the so-called multipole-induced dipoles. In diatomic molecules such as H2 and N2, the lowest-order multipole moment is the quadrupole, followed by a hexadecapole, etc., hence the quadrupole-induced, hexadecapole-induced,... dipoles. Especially the former is often the strongest, most significant of the induced dipoles contributing to CIA and CIE. Other induced dipole mechanisms exist. In collisional systems involving molecules of three or more atoms (CO2, CH4...), collisional frame distortion may be an important induction mechanism. Collision-induced emission and absorption by simultaneous collisions of three or more particles generally do involve pairwise-additive dipole components, as well as important irreducible dipole contributions and their spectra.
Collision-induced absorption was first reported in compressed oxygen gas in 1949 by Harry Welsch and associates at frequencies of the fundamental band of the O2 molecule. (Note that an unperturbed O2 molecule, like all other diatomic homonuclear molecules, is infrared inactive on account of the inversion symmetry and does thus not possess a "dipole allowed" rotovibrational spectrum at any frequency).
Molecular fly-by collisions take little time, something like 10−13 s. Optical transition of collisional complexes of molecules generate spectral "lines" that are very broad - roughly five orders of magnitude broader than the most familiar "ordinary" spectral lines (Heisenberg's uncertainty relation). The resulting spectral "lines" usually strongly overlap so that collision-induced spectral bands typically appear as continua (as opposed to the bands of often discernible lines of ordinary molecules).
Collision-induced spectra appear at the frequencies of the rotovibrational and electronic transition bands of the unperturbed molecules, and also at sums and differences of such transition frequencies: simultaneous transitions in two (or more) interacting molecules are well known to generate optical transitions of molecular complexes.
Virial expansions of spectral intensities
Intensities of spectra of individual atoms or molecules typically vary linearly with the numerical gas density. However, if gas densities are sufficiently increased, quite generally contributions may also be observed that vary as density squared, cubed... These are the collision-induced spectra of two-body (and quite possibly three-body,...) collisional complexes. The collision-induced spectra have sometimes been separated from the continua of individual atoms and molecules, based on the characteristic density dependences. In other words, a virial expansion in terms of powers of the numerical gas density is often observable, just as this is widely known for the virial expansion of the equation of state of compressed gases. The first term of the expansion, which is linear in density, represents the ideal gas (or "ordinary) spectra where these exist. (This first term vanishes for the infrared inactive gases,) And the quadratic, cubic,... terms of the virial expansions arise from optical transitions of binary, ternary,... intermolecular complexes, which are (often unjustifyably) neglected in the ideal gas approximation of spectroscopy.
Spectra of van der Waals molecules
Two kinds of complexes of molecules exist: the collisional complexes discussed above, which are short lived. Besides, bound (i.e. relatively stable) complexes of two or more molecules exist, the so-called van der Waals molecules. These exist usually for much longer times than the collisional complexes and, under carefully chosen experimental conditions (low temperature, moderate gas density), their rotovibrational band spectra show "sharp" (or resolvable) lines (Heisenberg uncertainty principle), much like ordinary molecules. If the parent molecules are nonpolar, the same induced dipole mechanisms, which are discussed above, are responsible for the observable spectra of van der Waals molecules.
Figure 1 (to be included)
An example of CIA spectra
Figure 1 shows an example of a collision-induced absorption spectra of H2-He complexes at a variety of temperatures. The spectra were computed from the fundamental theory, using quantum chemical methods, and were shown to be in close agreement with laboratory measurements at temperatures, where such measurements exist (for temperatures around 300 K and lower). The intensity scale of the figure is highly compressed. At the lowest temperature (300 K), a series of six striking maxima is seen, with deep minima between them. The broad maxima roughly coincide with the H2 vibrational bands. With increasing temperature, the minima become less striking and disappear at the highest temperature (curve at the top, for the temperature of 9000 K).
A similar picture is to be expected for the CIA spectra of pure hydrogen gas (i.e. without admixed gases) and, in fact for the CIA spectra of many other gases. The main difference, say if nitrogen CIA spectra are considered instead of those of hydrogen gas, would be a much closer spacing, if not a total overlapping, of the diverse CIA bands which appear roughly at the frequencies of the vibrational bands of the N2 molecule.
Herzberg pointed out direct evidence of H2 molecules in the atmospheres of the outer planets. The atmospheres of the inner planets (including Earth) and of Saturn's big moon Titan show strong CIA in the infrared, due to concentrations of molecular gases such as nitrogen, oxygen, carbon dioxide, etc. exist. In more recent years extrasolar planets were discovered, whose atmospheres are hot (thousand kelvin or more), but resemble otherwise Jupiter's atmosphere (mixtures of mostly H2 and He), where strong CIA exists.
Cool white dwarf stars
Stars that burn hydrogen are called main sequence (MS) stars - these are by far the most common objects in the night sky. When the hydrogen fuel is exhausted and temperatures begin to fall, the object undergoes various transformations and a white dwarf star is eventually born, the ember of the expired MS star. Temperatures of a new-born white dwarf may be in the hundreds of thousand kelvin, but if the mass of the white dwarf is less than just a few solar masses, burning of 4He to 12C and 16O is not possible and the star will slowly cool down forever. The coolest white dwarfs observed have temperatures of roughly 4000 K, which must mean that the universe is not old enough so that lower temperature stars cannot be found. The emission spectra of "cool" white dwarfs does not at all look like a Planck blackbody spectrum. Instead, nearly the whole infrared is attenuated or missing altogether from the star's emission, owing to CIA in the hydrogen-helium atmospheres surrounding their cores. The impact of CIA on the observed spectral energy distribution is well understood and accurately modeled for most cool white dwarfs. For white dwarfs with a mix H/He atmosphere, the intensity of the H2-He CIA can be used to infer the hydrogen abundance at the white dwarf photosphere. However, predicting CIA in the atmospheres of the coolest white dwarfs is more challenging, in part because of the formation of many-body collisional complexes.
Other cool stars
The atmospheres of low metallicity cool stars are composed primarily of hydrogen and helium. Collision-induced absorption by H2-H2 and H2-He transient complexes will be a more or less important opacity source of their atmospheres. For example, CIA in the H2 fundamental band, which falls on top of an opacity window between H2O/CH4 or H2O/CO (depending on the temperature), plays an important role in shaping brown dwarf spectra. Higher gravity brown dwarf stars often show even stronger CIA, owing to the density squared dependence of CIA intensities, when other "ordinary" opacity sources are linearly dependent on density. CIA is also important in low-metallicity brown dwarfs, since "low metallicity" means reduced CNO (and other) elemental abundances compared to H2 and He, and thus stronger CIA compared to H2O, CO, and CH4 absorption. CIA absorption of H2-X collisional complexes is thus an important diagnostic of high-gravity and low-metallicity brown dwarfs. All of this is also true of the M dwarfs, but to a lesser extent. M dwarf atmospheres are hotter so that some increased portion of the H2 molecules is in the dissociated state, which weakens CIA by H2--X complexes. The significance of CIA for cool astronomical objects was long suspected or known to some degree.
Attempts to model the formation of the "first" star from the pure hydrogen and helium gas clouds below about 10,000 K show that the heat generated in the gravitational contraction phase must be somehow radiatively released for further cooling to be possible. This is no problem as long as temperatures are still high enough so that free electrons exist: electrons are efficient emitters when interacting with neutrals (bremsstrahlung). However, at the lower temperatures in neutral gases, the recombination of hydrogen atoms to H2 molecules is a process that generates enormous amounts of heat that must somehow be radiated away in CIE processes; if CIE were non-existing, molecule formation could not take place and temperatures could not fall further. Only CIE processes permit further cooling, so that molecular hydrogen will accumulate. A dense, cool environment will thus develop so that a gravitational collapse and star formation can actually proceed.
Because of the great importance of many types of CIA spectra in planetary and astrophysical research, a well known spectroscopy data base has recently been expanded to include a number of CIA spectra in various frequency bands and for a variety of temperatures.
- L. Frommhold (2006) . Collision-induced Absorption in Gases. Cambridge, New York: Cambridge University Press.
- M. Abel; L. Frommhold (2013) . "Collision-induced spectra and current astronomical research". Canadian Journal of Physics. 91 (11): 857–869. Bibcode:2013CaJPh..91..857A. doi:10.1139/cjp-2012-0532.
- J. L. Hunt; J. D. Poll. (1986). A second bibliography on collision induced absorption. Molec. Phys. 59. Department of Physics, University of Guelph. pp. 163–164, Publication 1/86.
- G. Birnbaum, ed. (1985). Phenomena Induced by Intermolecular Interactions. New York: Plenum Press.
- A. Borysow; L. Frommhold (1989). Collision induced light scattering - a bibliography. Adv. Chem. Phys. 75. pp. 439–505.
- M. Moraldi; L. Frommhold (1996). Dipole moments induced in three interacting molecules. J. Molec. Liquids. 70. pp. 143–158.
- M. F. Crawford; H. L. Welsh; J. L. Locke (1949). "Infrared absorption of oxygen and nitrogen induced by intermolecular forces". Phys. Rev. 75 (10): 1607. Bibcode:1949PhRv...75.1607C. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.75.1607.
- M. Abel; L. Frommhold; X. Li; K. L. C. Hunt (2011). Computation of collision-induced absorption by dense deuterium-helium gas mixtures. J. Chem. Phys. 134. pp. 076101:1–076101:2.
- H. L. Welsh (1972). "3". In A. D. Buckingham; D. A. Ramsay (eds.). Pressure induced absorption spectra of hydrogen. Review of Science - Physical Chemistry, Series one. III: Spectroscopy. Butterworths, London: MTP Internat. pp. 33–71.
- G. Herzberg (1952). The atmospheres of the planets. J. Roy. Astron. Soc. Can. 45. p. 100 a.
- G. Herzberg (1952). Spectroscopic evidence of molecular hydrogen in the atmospheres of Uranus and Neptune. Astrophys. J.
- A. A. Vigasin; Z. Slanina, eds. (1998). Molecular Complexes in Earth's, Planetary, Cometary, and Interstellar Atmospheres. Singapore: World Sci.
- C. Camy-Peyret; A. A. Vigasin, eds. (2003). Weakly Interacting Molecular Pairs: Unconventional Absorbers of Radiation in the Atmosphere. 27. Dordrecht. Kluwer. NATO Science Series, Earth and Environmental Sciences.
- A. Coustenis; F. W. Taylor (2008). Titan: Exploring an Earth-like world. World Scientific.
- S. Seager (2010). Exoplanet Atmospheres: Physical Processes. Series in Astrophysics. Princeton U. Press.
- S. T. Hodgkin; B. R. Oppenheimer; N. C. Hambly; R. F. Jameson; S. J. Smart; I. A. Steele (2000). "Infrared spectrum of an extremely cool white-dwarf star". Nature. 403 (6765): 57–59. Bibcode:2000Natur.403...57H. doi:10.1038/47431. PMID 10638748.
- H. L. Shipman (1977). "Masses, radii and model atmospheres for cool white-dwarf stars". Astrophys. J. 213: 138–144. Bibcode:1977ApJ...213..138S. doi:10.1086/155138.
- D. Saumon; S. B. Jacobson (1999). "Pure hydrogen model atmospheres for very cool white dwarfs". Astrophys. J. 511 (2): L107–110. arXiv:astro-ph/9812107. Bibcode:1999ApJ...511L.107S. doi:10.1086/311851.
- Bergeron, P.; Saumon, D.; Wesemael, F. (April 1995). "New model atmospheres for very cool white dwarfs with mixed H/He and pure He compositions". The Astrophysical Journal. 443: 764. doi:10.1086/175566.
- Kilic, Mukremin; Leggett, S. K.; Tremblay, P.-E.; Hippel, Ted von; Bergeron, P.; Harris, Hugh C.; Munn, Jeffrey A.; Williams, Kurtis A.; Gates, Evalyn; Farihi, J. (2010). "A Detailed Model Atmosphere Analysis of Cool White Dwarfs in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey". The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series. 190 (1): 77. arXiv:1007.2859. doi:10.1088/0067-0049/190/1/77. ISSN 0067-0049.
- Agüeros, M. A.; Canton, Paul; Andrews, Jeff J.; Bergeron, P.; Kilic, Mukremin; Thorstensen, John R.; Curd, B.; Gianninas, A. (1 June 2015). "Ultracool white dwarfs and the age of the Galactic disc". Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 449 (4): 3966–3980. arXiv:1503.03065. doi:10.1093/mnras/stv545. ISSN 0035-8711.
- Blouin, S.; Kowalski, P. M.; Dufour, P. (2017). "Pressure Distortion of the H2-He Collision-induced Absorption at the Photosphere of Cool White Dwarf Stars". The Astrophysical Journal. 848 (1): 36. arXiv:1709.01394. doi:10.3847/1538-4357/aa8ad6. ISSN 0004-637X.
- A. Burrows; W. B. Hubbard; J. I. Lunine; J. Liebert (2001). "The theory of brown dwarfs and extrasolar giant planets". Rev. Mod. Phys. 73 (3): 719–765. arXiv:astro-ph/9706080. Bibcode:2001RvMP...73..719B. doi:10.1103/revmodphys.73.719.
- D. Saumon; P. Bergeron; J. I. Junine; W. B. Hubbard; A. Burrows (1994). "Cool zero-metallicity stellar atmospheres". Astrophysical Journal. 424: 333. Bibcode:1994ApJ...424..333S. doi:10.1086/173892.
- D. Saumon; M. S. Marley; M. Abel; L. Frommhold; R. S. Freedman (2012). "New H2 collision-induced absorption and NH3 opacity and the spectra of the coolest brown dwarfs". Astrophys. J. 750 (1): 74. arXiv:1202.6293. Bibcode:2012ApJ...750...74S. doi:10.1088/0004-637X/750/1/74.
- A. J. Burgasser; J. D. Kirkpatrik; A. Burrows; J. Liebert; I. N. Reid; J. E. Gizis (2003). "The first stellar subdwarf? Discovery of a metal-poor i dwarf with halo kinematics". Astrophys. J. 592 (2): 1186–1192. doi:10.1086/375813.
- A. J. Burgasser; A. Burrows; J. D. Kirkpatrik (2006). "A method for determining the physical properties of the coldest known brown dwarfs". Astrophys. J. 639 (2): 1095–1113. doi:10.1086/499344.
- B. M. S. Hansen; E. S. Phinney (1998). "Stellar forensics – cooling curves". Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 294 (4): 557–568. doi:10.1111/j.1365-8711.1998.01232.x.
- J. L. Linsky (1969). On the pressure-induced opacity of molecular hydrogen in late-type stars.
- P. Lenzuni; D. F. Chernoff; E. Salpeter (1991). "Rosseland and Planck mean opacities of a zero-metallicity gas". Astrophys. J. 76: 759. doi:10.1086/191580.
- Th. H. Greif; V. Bromm; P. C. Clark; S. C. O. Glover; R. J. Smith; R. S. Klessen; N. Yoshida; V. Springel. (2012). "Formation and evolution of primordial protostellar systems". Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. Bibcode:2012MNRAS.424..399G. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.21212.x.
- C. Richard; I. E. Gordon; L. S. Rothman; M. Abel; L. Frommhold; M. Gustafsson; J. M. Hartmann; C. Hermans; W. J. Lafferty; G. Orton; K. M. Smith; H. Tran. (2012). "New section of the HITRAN database: Collision-induced absorption (cia)". Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer. 113 (11): 1276–1285. Bibcode:2012JQSRT.113.1276R. doi:10.1016/j.jqsrt.2011.11.004.