Because the eta function is easy to compute numerically from either power series, it is often helpful in computation to express other functions in terms of it when possible, and products and quotients of eta functions, called eta quotients, can be used to express a great variety of modular forms.
The picture on this page shows the modulus of the Euler function: the additional factor of between this and eta makes almost no visual difference whatsoever (it only introduces a tiny pinprick at the origin). Thus, this picture can be taken as a picture of eta as a function of q.
Eta quotients are defined by quotients of the form
Where is a non-negative integer and is any integer. Linear combinations of eta quotients at imaginary quadratic arguments may be algebraic, while combinations of eta quotients may even be integral. For example, define,
Eta Quotients may also be a useful tool for describing bases of modular forms, which are notoriously difficult to compute and express directly. In 1993 Basil Gordon and Kim Hughes proved that if an eta quotient of the form satisfies
This result was extended in 2019 such that the converse holds for cases when is coprime to , and it remains open that the original theorem is sharp for all integers . This also extends to state that any modular eta quotient for any level congruence subgroup must also be a modular form for the group . While these theorems characterize modular eta quotients, the condition of holomorphicity must be checked separately using a theorem that emerged from the work of Gérard Ligozat and Yves Martin:
If is an eta quotient satisfying the above conditions for the integer and and are coprime integers, then the order of vanishing at the cusp relative to is
These theorems provide an effective means of creating holomorphic modular eta quotients, however this may not be sufficient to construct a basis for a vector space of modular forms and cusp forms. A useful theorem for limiting the number of modular eta quotients to consider states that a holomorphic weight modular eta quotient on must satisfy
where denotes the largest integer such that .
These results lead to several characterizations of spaces of modular forms that can be spanned by modular eta quotients. Using the graded ring structure on the ring of modular forms, we can compute bases of vector spaces of modular forms composed of -linear combinations of eta-quotients. For example, if we assume is a semiprime then the following process can be used to compute an eta-quotient basis of .
Fix a semiprime which is coprime to 6. We know that any modular eta quotient may be found using the above theorems, therefore it is reasonable to algorithmically to compute them.
Compute the dimension of . This tells us how many linearly independent modular eta quotients we will need to compute to form a basis.
Reduce the number of eta quotients to consider. For semiprimes we can reduce the number of partitions using the bound on
and by noticing that the sum of the orders of vanishing at the cusps of must equal
Find all partitions of into 4-tuples (there are 4 cusps of ), and among these consider only the partitions which satisfy Gordon and Hughes' conditions (we can convert orders of vanishing into exponents). Each of these partitions corresponds to a unique eta quotient.
Determine the minimum number of terms in the q-expansion of each eta quotient required to identify elements uniquely (this uses a result known as Sturm's Bound). Then use linear algebra to determine a maximal independent set among these eta quotients.
Assuming that we have not found many linearly independent eta quotients. Find an appropriate vector space such that and is spanned by (weakly holomorphic) eta quotients, and contains an eta quotient .
Take a weight modular form not in the span of our computed eta-quotients and compute as a linear combination of eta-quotients in and then divide out by . The result will be an expression of as a linear combination of eta quotients as desired. Repeat this until a basis is formed.
^Fuchs, Jurgen (1992), Affine Lie Algebras and Quantum Groups, Cambridge University Press, ISBN0-521-48412-X
^Basil Gordon and Kim Hughes. Multiplicative properties of η-products. II. In A tribute to Emil Grosswald:
number theory and related analysis, volume 143 of Contemp. Math., pages 415–430. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence,
^Michael Allen et al. “Eta-quotients of Prime or Semiprime Level and Elliptic Curves”. In:
arXiv e-prints, arXiv:1901.10511 (Jan. 2019), arXiv:1901.10511. arXiv: 1901.10511 [math.NT].
^G. Ligozat. Courbes modulaires de genre 1. U.E.R. Mathématique, Université Paris XI, Orsay, 1974. Publication
Mathématique d’Orsay, No. 75 7411.