Earned wage access
Earned wage access (EWA), can be referred to as instant pay, earned income, early wage access, accrued wage access or on-demand pay.[citation needed] The official UK government term is Employer Salary Advance Scheme.[1]
Earned wage access is a financial service offered to employees, mostly low-wage and hourly workers, being given access to some of their accrued wages before the end of their payroll cycle.
Earned wage access technology can be implemented in various ways: automatically loaded onto a prepaid card, deposited via ACH onto a user's existing direct deposit, or, in a bifocal approach, accrued earnings are transferred into a bank account facilitated by the EWA provider.[citation needed]
Earned wage access providers have been positioned as an ethical solution to payday lenders as they typically charge a small flat fee rather than interest, and there is no recourse, credit impacts, or underwriting in earned wage access transactions.[2]
In the United States, 20% of all hourly staff are expected to be paid this way by 2023,[3] with many large employers like Walmart and McDonald's already offering it.[4]
History
[edit]Earned wage access programs began to reach the market in the 2010s, due to the receding number of Americans who had access to credit and traditional banking. By integrating with payroll, these promised to usher in a fairer and more inclusive era of personal finance. The concept of Earned Wage Access as we know it today was patented by Jason Lee, Patent Number US11908022B1 [5]which is the “patent for the devices, systems, and methods generating a machine learning model for providing access to earned income.”
In August 2016, Uber pioneered EWA in a partnership with Green Dot by allowing drivers to request their earnings after each drive in exchange for a small payment.[6]
In July 2018, ADP, the largest payroll provider in America, began offering an EWA solution in their marketplace.[7]
In May 2019, Lyft introduced a similar feature to its drivers in a partnership with Mastercard.[8]
UK Market
[edit]Theoretically, 'EWA' has even more potential in the UK where the typical pay cycle is monthly,[9] rather than bi-weekly as is the case in the US.
As recommended by the Financial Conduct Authority, the UK’s leading providers of Earned Wage Access/On-Demand Pay have come together and created the world's first 'EWA' Code of Practice.[10]
Models
[edit]As earned wage access exists today, there are two distinct models. In the employer-integrated earned wage access model, if an employee accesses their earned wages ahead of payday, EWA transaction is adjusted from an employee's paycheck on payday.[citation needed]
In the direct-to-consumer model, users will still receive the entirety of their paycheck at the end of each payroll cycle. At the end of each payroll cycle, however, the advancements made to the user are subtracted from the direct deposit account noted on the user's payday.[11] New laws in Nevada and Missouri protect users from potential overdraft risks in this model.[12]
Benefits
[edit]Earned wage access is promoted as bringing income more inline with expenses, helping workers to avoid cashflow issues that could result in them taking out high-interest debt.[13] The academic consensus supports this claim, with research finding better financial outcomes for users vs. non-users.[14]
There is also a moral argument made by some[who?] that, instead of employers benefiting from the cash flow advantages of paying in arrears, staff are entitled to the pay they've already earned.
Many earned wage access providers also highlight the benefits to the employer, including quicker recruitment, better staff retention, a more motivated workforce and a greater staff appetite for overtime and extra shifts.[15] Marketing claims vary across the industry, from reducing staff turnover by 50%[16] to increasing shift uptake by 26%.
Criticism
[edit]States like Nevada and Missouri have regulated earned wage access providers by creating a new earned wage access license and required them to be licensed.[17]
Monica Burks, of the Center for Responsible Lending, warns that, "[t]he industry is trying to create a new definition for what a loan is in order to exempt themselves from existing consumer protection laws."[18]
In the UK, the government is broadly optimistic about the sector and appears to be encouraging take-up.[19] This is possibly in response to several think tanks and charities throwing their reputation behind the concept.[20]
Risks
[edit]For consumers
[edit]Consumer risk is highly dependent on the specific strategy the EWA provider chooses to take when offering the advances. Some users have been forced into overdraft as they were allowed to advance more than they received in their paycheck.[21] Most reputable providers cap advances well below total income and charge no interest at all.
For EWA providers
[edit]EWA providers are held responsible for recollecting the advances they make the consumers. As such, they face risk if they advance too much to the user and risk the user defaulting. All in all, however, EWA providers face dramatically lower risk than other credit providers as the advances they make are backed by hours the loan recipient has already worked towards.[22]
References
[edit]- ^ "FCA sets out views on Employer Salary Advance Schemes". FCA. 2020-07-29. Retrieved 2021-06-10.
- ^ "Home". Earned Wage Access. Retrieved 2023-09-01.
- ^ Ron, Hanscome. "Empower Workers and Energize Your Employment Value Proposition With Flexible Earned Wage Access". Gartner.
- ^ Jessica, Stillman. "McDonald's Has Started Offering an Innovative New Employee Perk. It's Either Genius or a Total Disaster". Inc.
- ^ US11443392B1, Lee, Jason; Law, II Robert Louis & Getmanchuk, Konstantin, "Methods and apparatus for constructing machine learning models to process user data and provide advance access to payments", issued 2022-09-13
- ^ "Uber Taps Green Dot For Instant Pay Service". PYMNTS.com. 2016-08-17. Retrieved 2020-10-27.
- ^ "ADP Adds DailyPay To Marketplace". 2018-07-26.
- ^ "Mastercard, Lyft launch co-branded banking, debit card with immediate driver pay". www.mobilepaymentstoday.com. 2019-05-15. Retrieved 2020-10-27.
- ^ Bell; Cominetti; Slaughter, Torsten; Nye; Hannah. "A new settlement for the low paid: Beyond the minimum wage to dignity and respect" (PDF). Resolution Foundation.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ "Earned Wage Access (EWA) Code of Practice". www.cipp.org.uk. CIPP. Retrieved September 18, 2023.
- ^ "Earned wage access: the most important benefit in a post-COVID-19 world". Employee Benefit News. 2020-05-05. Retrieved 2020-10-27.
- ^ "Nevada Enacts Nation's First State Licensing Regime for Earned Wage Access Services | Insights | Greenberg Traurig LLP". www.gtlaw.com. Retrieved 2023-09-01.
- ^ "Give your people the flexibility to choose how and when they get paid". Wagestream.
- ^ Hawkins, J (2021). "Earned wage access and the end of payday lending" (PDF). Boston University Law Review. 101: 705.
- ^ Level. "Make Pay Go Further". Level Financial Technology. Level.
- ^ REBA. "Capita experiences 50% reduction in contact centre agent attrition after deploying Level". REBA.
- ^ "Nevada Enacts Nation's First State Licensing Regime for Earned Wage Access Services | Insights | Greenberg Traurig LLP".
- ^ "Fintech's Latest Scheme". The Prospect. May 2023.
- ^ FCA (29 July 2020). "FCA sets out views on Employer Salary Advance Schemes". Financial Conduct Authority.
- ^ Bell; Cominetti; Slaughter, Torsten; Cominetti; Slaughter. "A new settlement for the low paid" (PDF). Resolution Foundation.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ Siegel Bernard, Tara (2020-10-02). "Apps Will Get You Paid Early, for a Price". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2020-10-27.
- ^ "The Power of the Salary Link". www.hks.harvard.edu. Retrieved 2020-10-27.