Jump to content

Gask Ridge

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 2a02:c7f:b42f:6900:dcae:d214:c37b:6325 (talk) at 14:59, 16 September 2018 (Changed a significant number of inaccuracies previously written by people who have not picked up one of the many books on the Roman occupation of Scotland and who are unaware of the different occupation phases in the north of Scotland and have made unsubstantiated claims, particularly about Cawdor. They also don't know the difference between camps and forts.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Forts and Fortlets associated with the Gask Ridge from south to north[1] Balmuildy, Cadder, Castlecary, Mumrills, Camelon, Drumquhassle, Malling, Doune, Glenbank, Bochastle, Ardoch, Sheilhill, Strageath, Dalginross, Midgate, Bertha, Fendoch, Cargill, Cardean, Inchtuthil, Inverquharity, Stracathro[2]

The Gask Ridge is the modern name given to an early series of fortifications, built by the Romans in Scotland, close to the Highland Line. Modern excavation and interpretation has been pioneered by the Roman Gask Project, with Birgitta Hoffmann and David Woolliscroft. The ridge fortifications: forts, fortlets and watchtowers were only in operation for a short number of years, probably a single digit number.[3]

Name

The name "Gask Ridge" refers to the 10-mile (16 km) ridge of land to the north of the River Earn in Perthshire.[4] In Scottish Gaelic, a gasg is a projecting tail or strip of land.[5] In the early 20th century, a line of Roman signal-towers (or watch-towers) was discovered along this ridge between the Roman forts of Strageath and Bertha.[6]

History

The Gask Ridge system was constructed sometime between 70 and 80 A.D..[7] Construction on Hadrian's Wall was started 42 years after completion of the Gask Ridge (from 122 to 130 AD), and the Antonine Wall was started just 12 years after completion of Hadrian's Wall (from 142 to 144 AD). Although the Gask Ridge was not a wall, it may be Rome's earliest fortified land frontier.[8] The fortifications approximately follow the boundary between Scotland's fertile Lowlands and mountainous Highlands, in Perth and Kinross and Angus. The later Hadrian's Wall and Antonine Wall were further south and by taking advantage of the indented coastline of Great Britain, were considerably shorter.

Ditches and ramparts of Ardoch Roman Fort

The principal forts of the Gask Ridge frontier system were (from south to north):[9] Camelon, Drumquhassle, Malling, Doune, Glenbank (fortlet), Bochastle, Ardoch, Kaims Castle (fortlet), Strageath, Dalginross, Bertha, Fendoch, Cargill (fort and fortlet), Inchtuthil (Legionary fortress), Cardean, Inverquharity (fortlet) and Stracathro.

Glenblocker forts

The forts of Drumquhassle, Menteith/Malling, Bochastle, Doune, Dalginross and Fendoch in the south-west were collectively referred to as glenblocker forts in the older literature; they are also called the Highland line forts.[10] Glenblocker refers to their location at the exit of some of the glens (narrow valleys) or straths (a broad valleys) and can thus supervise traffic.

All of the forts were originally built during the Flavian occupation in Scotland. A broader group consists of

  • Drumquhassle (near Drymen), overlooking the southern end of Loch Lomond and the road back to the Clyde)
  • Malling (on the Lake of Menteith, overlooking the access to the Duke's Pass and a narrow point between the mountains and the Forth Mosses)
  • Bochastle (near Callander), overlooking the road to Loch Katrine and the Pass of Leny
  • Dalginross (near Comrie) overlooking the Eastern end of Loch Earn
  • Fendoch (north of Crieff) overlooking the Sma' Glen
  • Inchtuthil (below Dunkeld) The legionary fortress at the mouth of Strath Tay, guarding the main roads to Inverness
  • Inverquharity (near Kirriemuir) a fortlet-sized station at the east end of Glen Clova

It is debatable whether Cardean, Stracathro and Doune should be listed among these, as they are sited further away from their respective traffic corridors, although fulfilling the same function.

Role

It has traditionally been thought that these forts were meant to prevent invasions out of the Scottish Highlands into Roman-held territory.[11] This may have been the intention, in cooperation with the other forts on the Gask Ridge and along Strathmore, as only the legionary fortress of Inchtuthil with 5,000–6,000 soldiers would have been strong enough to deal with a major incursion. The smaller forts were more likely to serve as a disincentive to small-scale raiding parties.[12]

The relationship between the Glenblocker forts and the Gask Ridge has in the past been seen as a staged withdrawal.[13] Recent research suggests that the three elements are part of the same frontier system, stretching roughly from Loch Lomond to Montrose. In this hypothesis, the Glenblocker forts controlled access to valleys in the frontier area, which loop back into the frontier, rather than link with the Iron Age settlements further north. Their value as a block to invasion is doubtful, as their situation would have allowed supervision but they lacked the manpower to deter anything but cattle rustling.

Only the legionary fortress at Inchtuthil, conveniently situated for access into Braemar and its hinterland, is large enough to have functioned as a defensive fortification or a jumping-off point for an invasion. The Gask Road and the towers alongside it in this hypothesis guarded the strategically-important link to the harbours at the Firths of Tay and Forth and the southern part of the province.[14]

Site of a Roman signal tower at Kirkhill

Tacitus writes in De vita Iulii Agricolae that Agricola was fighting in the area in around 80 AD; the latest coinage dates from 86 AD. This would suggest that the forts were occupied for six years at most. Recent archaeology has shown that many of the forts on the Gask Ridge were rebuilt, sometimes twice, without evidence of destruction through warfare. Further digs may cast some light on this apparent contradiction.

The forts of Ardoch, Strageath and Bertha on the Gask Road, as well as the forts of Cargill in Strathmore and the so-called glenblocker fort of Dalginross have also produced Antonine material attesting to a reuse of the sites contemporary with the Antonine Wall.[15] In the Severan period the army passed through the area, although there are a number of camps across Scotland which are dated to this period (for example, Kair House in Aberdeenshire and the fort at Carpow Roman Fort which is on the Firth of Tay[16].

North of the Gask Ridge

The permanent sites are complemented by a series of large marching camps (large camps date to the 3rd century) from the Scottish Lowlands into Aberdeenshire and Moray. The Roman legions in the 1st century established a chain of forts at Ardoch, Strageath, Inchtuthil, Battledykes (which is unlikely to date from the same period as the Gask sites), Stracathro and Raedykes, taking the Elsick Mounth on the way to Normandykes, before going north to Glenmaillen and Auchinhove. Contrary to wikipedia, the sites at Bellie and Balnageith are unconfirmed as Roman. A cursory glance at the excavation reports for Cawdor, clearly do not show any Roman fortifications, something supported by the lack of Roman artefacts.

In the 1990s researchers discovered new possible Roman fortifications north of Inverness and the Moray Firth. The most important are Tarradale and Portmahomack. These are being studied by RCAHMS to verify that they are Roman.[17] Several chronological reconstructions of their role have been made.

This inaccurate map shows some Roman camps in northern Scotland. The possible Roman camp at Bellie is likely to be the northernmost fortification constructed by the Imperial machine in Scotland.

See also

References

  1. ^ "Gask Ridge". Scribble Maps. Retrieved 9 June 2018.
  2. ^ "Gask Ridge Map". HeritageDaily. Retrieved 9 June 2018.
  3. ^ "Gask Ridge Frontier". Castles, Forts, Battles. Retrieved 30 June 2018.
  4. ^ "Gask Ridge". Gazetteer for Scotland. Retrieved 2011-05-19.
  5. ^ William John Watson, 1973, The history of the Celtic place-names of Scotland, page 362. Irish University Press
  6. ^ D. J. Woolliscroft. "Signalling and the Design of the Gask Ridge System". The Roman Gask Project. Retrieved 2011-05-19.
  7. ^ "Shades of Empire: The Roman Presence in Scotland". BBC. Retrieved 30 June 2018.
  8. ^ Woolliscroft & Hoffmann 2007
  9. ^ Gazetteer at The Roman Gask Project
  10. ^ L. Keppie, Scotland's Roman Remains. Edinburgh 1986) p. 156 ff.
  11. ^ L. Keppie, Scotland's Roman Remains. Edinburgh 1986) p. 156
  12. ^ D. J. Woolliscroft & B. Hoffmann, Rome's First Frontier (Stroud: Tempus 2006)
  13. ^ Breeze 1982
  14. ^ Woolliscroft & Hoffmann 2007
  15. ^ Woolliscroft & Hoffmann 2007, updating Hanson & Maxwell 1986
  16. ^ Breeze 2007
  17. ^ Portmahomack

Bibliography

  • Breeze, D. Northern Frontiers of Roman Britain (1982)
  • Breeze, D. 'Roman Scotland (2007)
  • Hanson William, G.Maxwell. Rome's North-west Frontier: The Antonine Wall (1986)
  • Hanson, William S. "The Roman Presence: Brief Interludes", in Edwards, Kevin J. & Ralston, Ian B. M. (Eds) (2003) Scotland After the Ice Age: Environment, Archaeology and History, 8000 BC – AD 1000. Edinburgh. Edinburgh University Press.
  • Hanson, William S. Roman Campaigns North of the Forth-Clyde Isthmus: The Evidence of the Temporary Camps, Proc Soc Antiq Scot, vol. 109 142, 145 Edinburgh, 1980.
  • Macdonald, G. (1916) The Roman Camps at Raedykes and Glenmailen, Proc Soc Antiq Scot, vol. 50 348–359
  • Maxwell, G. S. (1980) Agricola's Campaigns: The Evidence of the Temporary Camps, Scot Archaeol Forum, vol. 12, 34, 35, 40, 41
  • Moffat, Alistair (2005) Before Scotland: The Story of Scotland Before History. London. Thames & Hudson. ISBN 0-500-05133-X
  • Pitts, L. Inchtuthil. The Roman Legionary Fortress. Britannia Monograph Series 6 (1985)
  • Robertson, A. S. (1976) Agricola's Campaigns in Scotland and their Aftermath, Scot Archaeol Forum, vol. 7 4
  • St Joseph, J. K. (1951) Air Reconnaissance of North Britain, J Roman Stud, vol. 41 65
  • Woolliscroft, D. and Hoffmann, B. The First Frontier. Rome in the North of Scotland (Stroud: Tempus 2006)
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Gask Ridge.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Gask_Ridge&oldid=859827505"