On April 3, 2004 Henderson got in a motorcycle accident. He lost control of the bike while making a turn at a high speed and there was no indication that Henderson was speeding or that alcohol or drugs were involved in the accident. He has since gained full recovery from the accident and held positions at the University of West Georgia in Carrollton, Georgia and Murray State University as a defensive backs coach. He was a paraprofessional at Carrollton Jr. High School and was helping coach track and football at Carrollton High School, Carrollton, Georgia. On June 15, 2014 Jamie married his long time love, Monica Mitcherson and became step-father to her daughter, Melai.