Jonathon Edington (born October 29, 1976) is a Fairfield, Connecticut, United States, patent lawyer who achieved national notoriety when, on August 28, 2006, he murdered his neighbor, Barry James, after being told that James had molested Edington's two-year-old daughter. There has been no evidence found that Barry James molested Edington's daughter or anyone else. On August 30 Edington was released on $1 million bond. It was widely expected that Edington would attempt to mount a psychiatric defense at his murder trial, however Edington instead pleaded guilty to the crime and was sentenced to 12 years in prison on August 31, 2007.
The story had generated a large amount of press coverage in the United States and overseas.
Court documents released on September 12, 2006 state that a 2-year-old girl had complained to her mother, Christina Edington, that her neighbor, Barry James, had repeatedly molested her. Christina Edington was in Rhode Island with her daughter visiting relatives when the murder took place. The girl had just told Mrs. Edington when she immediately called to inform her husband, Jonathon Edington. According to the affidavit, within minutes Edington went next door to 101 Colony Street in Fairfield, where he found Barry James, 59, and stabbed him thirteen times in the heart, chest and hand. James died about an hour later at Bridgeport Hospital.
James' estate hired attorney Peter Ambrose, who issued a statement on behalf of the James family that disputed the allegations: "The family of Barry James stand together in defending the unfounded allegations of molestation. They are vicious and hurtful, and the family only wishes that their son and brother had the opportunity to defend himself. When all of the facts are made known, we are confident that Barry will be cleared of these allegations."
On October 10, 2006, Edington pleaded "not guilty" to all charges. On October 19, 2006, the Fairfield police concluded that James did not molest Edington's daughter. Further, after investigating the molestation allegation and saying they found no evidence to back it up, they also revealed that Edington's wife, Christina, refused to cooperate with the investigation into the slaying, and prosecutor Jonathan Benedict has said a defense psychiatrist determined Edington's wife suffered from postpartum depression.
In June 2007, Edington pleaded guilty to a reduced charge of first degree manslaughter. He was sentenced Friday, August 31, 2007, to 12 years in prison for first-degree manslaughter. Prosecutor Jonathon Benedict had recommended that Edington serve 20 years in prison. The judge suspended eight years of that, leaving 12 years to serve, plus five years probation.
The estate of Barry James filed an order in the Bridgeport Superior Court for a $5 million lien against Edington's property. The lien would be used to secure any verdict reached against Edington. James' 87-year-old mother lived with him and would be a beneficiary of the estate. She is legally blind and discovered the body. After she showed police the body, they found Edington at home in his kitchen with blood on his hands and forearms, authorities said. An attorney for the Jameses served Christina Edington with a wrongful death lawsuit, accusing her of triggering the stabbing and making up the abuse claim. A similar lawsuit is pending against Edington.
- Connecticut Department of Correction Inmate Information
- Avi Salzman, Told His Daughter Was Molested, a Lawyer Kills His Neighbor, Police Say, New York Times, 8/31/06
- Lisa Siegel, Attorney Arrested in Murder Case May Be Able to Mount 'Emotional Disturbance' Defense, The Connecticut Law Tribune, 9/5/06
- Avi Salzman and Stacey Stowe, Two Lives, Colliding Violently, Details of Fatal Stabbing Emerge, New York Times, 9/1/06
- Alison Leigh Cowan, Girl, 2, in Murder Case Told of Repeated Abuse, September 13, 2006, via NYTimes.com.
- Associated Press, Girl described abuse before neighbor killed, September 12, 2006, via MSNBC.com.
- Bill Bittar, Out on $1 million bail, suspect pleads not guilty in neighbor murder case, The Fairfield Minuteman, October 12, 2006.
- Police Say Metro Lawyer's Daughter Was Not Molested By Neighbor He's accused of Killing, Associated Press, October 20, 2006.
- Dave Goldiner, Tragic twist in slay, N.Y. Daily News, October 20, 2006.
- Associated Press, , CNN, August 31, 2007.
- Lawyer Pleads Guilty in Fatal Stabbing, Washington Times, June 17, 2007.
- Family sues neighbor for $5 million in fatal stabbing, Stamford Advocate, January 17, 2007.