Learned treatise

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

A learned treatise, in the law of evidence, is a text that is sufficiently authoritative in its field to be admissible as evidence in a court in support of the contentions made therein.

Under the common law, such evidence was at one time considered hearsay - a statement made out of court being introduced to prove the truth of the statement - and was not admissible except to rebut the testimony of an opposing expert witness. There were four ways to introduce such evidence:[citation needed]

  1. Adduce testimony that the opposing expert witness actually used that text to reach his conclusions;
  2. Adduce testimony by the opposing expert admitting that the text is an authority in the field;
  3. Have a friendly expert witness testifying against the opposing expert witness attest to the authoritativeness of the text.
  4. Have the judge take judicial notice of the text, if it is sufficiently notable that the average person would know that it is an authority (for example, Gray's Anatomy[1][2]).

Under the Federal Rules of Evidence 803 (18), either party can introduce a learned treatise as evidence, irrespective of whether it is being used to rebut the opposing party. Such texts are now considered an exception to hearsay, with two limitations:[3]

  1. For the learned treatise to be introduced, there must be an expert witness on the stand;
  2. Like a recorded recollection, the actual learned treatise does not go to the jury, but instead comes into evidence only by being read to the jury.

References[edit]

  1. ^ "ADA Policy Statement on Sleep Disordered Breathing From a Lawyer's Perspective by Ken Berley, DDS, JD, DABDSM". Dental Sleep Practice. March 23, 2018. Retrieved May 8, 2018. For example, courts throughout the country have universally recognized Gray’s Anatomy textbook as a learned treatise
  2. ^ Ohio Rules of Evidence (PDF), Supreme Court of Ohio, July 1, 1998, Rule 706, p. 66, retrieved May 8, 2018
  3. ^ Federal Rules of Evidence, Legal Information Institute, December 1, 2015, Rule 803 (18), retrieved May 8, 2018