Paul Weiss (philosopher)
May 19, 1901|
New York City
|Died||July 5, 2002
|Alma mater||City College of New York
Catholic University of America
|Being consists of a plurality of individuals that are unified by universality, which gives a structure to all there is|
Paul Weiss grew up on the Lower East Side of New York City. His father, Samuel Weiss (d. 1917), was a Hungarian emigrant who moved from Europe in the 1890s. He worked as a tinsmith, a coppersmith, and a boilermaker. Paul Weiss's mother, Emma Rothschild (Weiss) (d. 1915), was a German emigrant who worked as a servant until she married Samuel. Born into a Jewish family, Paul lived among other Jewish families in a working-class neighborhood in the Yorkville section of Manhattan. Originally given the Hebrew name "Peretz," Weiss says in his autobiography that the name "Paul" was his "registered name" and "part of his mother's attempt to move upward in the American world." He had three brothers, two older and one younger.
Weiss graduated from Public School #77. He later enrolled at the High School of Commerce where he learned shorthand and how to type; however, he felt that he did not benefit much from the available courses. His grades began to fall, and with a little encouragement from his mother, he eventually dropped out of high school. After working many odd jobs, Weiss enrolled at the College of the City of New York in 1924. He took free night classes in philosophy, graduating cum laude in 1927. At the College of the City of New York, he studied with Morris R. Cohen, who awakened in him an interest in the American pragmatist and logician Charles Sanders Peirce. During this period he also met Victoria Brodkin (d. 1953), whom he later married on October 27, 1928. They had two children: Judith, who was born in 1935, and Jonathan, who was born in 1939.
Upon receiving his B.A. from the City College of New York, Weiss immediately enrolled at Harvard where he studied philosophy under Étienne Gilson, William Ernest Hocking, C. I. Lewis, Ralph Barton Perry, and Alfred North Whitehead. Under the direction of Whitehead, Weiss received his Ph.D. from Harvard in 1929. Weiss's first semester at Harvard proved to be a busy one. He volunteered to help Charles Hartshorne in the monumental task of editing the thousands of scattered pages Charles S. Peirce had left behind for publication by Harvard University Press. C. I. Lewis, who was at the time the department chair of philosophy at Harvard, eventually approved Weiss to work alongside Hartshorne for the remainder of the project. The first six volumes of Peirce's work were published between 1931 and 1935. Weiss was mainly responsible for the second, third, and fourth volumes. Two more volumes edited by Arthur Burks appeared in the 1950s. Weiss later founded the scholarly journal The Review of Metaphysics in 1947 and the Metaphysical Society of America in 1950.
In 1931 Paul Weiss left Harvard and began teaching philosophy at Bryn Mawr. As Weiss explains, Bryn Mawr was at the time "the self-chosen destination of the most intellectual, intelligent, determined, and well-prepared young women in America." Some fifteen years later in 1946, Weiss was invited to teach at Yale for a term as a substitute for Brand Blanshard. He accepted and what began as a temporary job turned into a permanent position that lasted for twenty four years. Weiss was the first Jewish full professor at Yale. He comments that his experience at Yale was quite different from Bryn Mawr. "I was there faced with men—no women were enrolled in the undergraduate school until more than two decades later—many of whom had just returned from military service. They were older, some having gone through searing experiences, no longer enjoying the cozy atmosphere of their preparatory schools. I seemed to be just the teacher they needed and wanted." Weiss remained at Yale until 1969 when he reached Yale's mandatory retirement age. Shortly after, he was offered the Schweitzer Chair of philosophy at Fordham University, but the offer was quickly retracted, allegedly due to Weiss's age. Weiss challenged Fordham's decision in an age discrimination lawsuit, but in the end he lost. In the early 1970s, Weiss began teaching at the Catholic University of America. In 1992 Weiss's contract with the university was not renewed. Again he felt that age discrimination played a role in the university's decision. Weiss and his son Jonathan, a lawyer and director of Legal Services for the Elderly in New York, challenged the Catholic University of America's decision. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigated the case and eventually ruled in Weiss's favor. His contract with the Catholic University of America was renewed until 1994 when Weiss voluntarily retired.
The man and the philosopher
As a philosopher, Weiss is mainly known for his metaphysical writings such as Being and Other Realities. His other philosophical works include books and articles on theology and cosmology. He even published eleven volumes under the title Philosophy in Process, detailing his continuing and sometimes daily reflections over the years 1955–1987. A seminal point of Weiss's philosophy is that Being consists of a plurality of individuals that are unified by universality, which gives a structure to all there is, but that is also irreducible in four distinct ways. During his prime, Weiss maintained a style of philosophy that was considered by many to be out-of-date. In fact, Weiss opposed the philosophies of the analytics, the logical positivists and the Marxists. His was a philosophy on the grand scale-philosophical system-building in the style of Kant, Hegel, or Peirce.
As a man, Weiss could be "fierce in argument" while maintaining "gentleness" and "personal regard for his students." John Silber, one of Weiss's former students says, "In order to study philosophy with Paul, one had to philosophize. And Paul's dialectical powers gave credence to Plato's account of those powers exercised by Socrates himself." However, in his older years he seemed to become smug and resistant to new ideas and arguments. In an exchange with James Baldwin on the nationally televised Dick Cavett show, Weiss lectured Baldwin about excessive focus on the Black experience, even as he acknowledged that he had not heard Baldwin's full comments. The recording of this embarrassing exchange, which was shown in Raoul Peck's documentary I Am Not Your Negro, was described by A. O. Scott: the "spectacle of mediocrity condescending to genius is painful", and served to diminish the reputation of the scholarly Weiss.
Paul Weiss died in 2002 at age 101. His final book, Surrogates, was published shortly after his death. Most of Weiss's papers were donated to the Morris Library at Southern Illinois University at Carbondale. After his death, his remaining papers and his extensive library (and also the legal papers, French and Russian translations, novels, and other non fiction books of his son) were bequeathed to the Institute for American Thought housed at Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) and the IUPUI university library.
- Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, vol. 1: Principles of Philosophy (co-editor). Cambridge (Mass.), Harvard University Press. 1931.
- Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, vol. 2: Elements of Logic (editor). Cambridge (Mass.), Harvard University Press. 1932.
- Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, vol. 3: Exact Logic (editor). Cambridge (Mass.), Harvard University Press. 1933.
- Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, vol. 4: The Simplest Mathematics (editor). Cambridge (Mass.), Harvard University Press. 1934.
- Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, vol. 5: Pragmatism and Pragmaticism (co-editor). Cambridge (Mass.), Harvard University Press. 1935.
- Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce, vol. 6: Scientific Metaphysics (co-editor). Cambridge (Mass.), Harvard University Press. 1935.
- Reality. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press. 1938.
- Man's Freedom. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1950.
- Modes of Being. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press, 1958.
- Our Public Life. Bloomington, Indiana University Press.1959.
- Nine Basic Arts. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press.1961.
- The World of Art. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press. 1961.
- History: Written and Lived. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press. 1962.
- The God We Seek. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press.1964.
- The Making of Men. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press. 1967.
- Right & Wrong: A Philosophical Dialogue Between Father and Son. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press 1967.
- Beyond All Appearances. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press 1974.
- Cinematics. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press, 1975.
- Creativity and Common Sense: Essays in Honor of Paul Weiss. Albany (N.Y.), State University of New York Press, 1987.
- Philosophy in Process, Vol. 1–11. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University Press. 1966–1989.
- Emphatics. Nashville, Vanderbilt University Press, 2000.
- Surrogates. Bloomington (IN), Indiana University Press, 2002.
- Weiss, Paul. The Philosophy of Paul Weiss. Ed. Lewis Hahn. Chicago : Open Court, 1995.
- Castiglione, Robert L. “Paul Weiss (1901–2002). Dictionary of Modern American Philosophers Vol. 4. Ed. Shook. England. Thoemmes. 2005.
- Weiss, Paul. “Lost in Thought: Alone with Others.” The Library of Living Philosophers Vol. 23: The Philosophy of Paul Weiss. Ed. L.E. Hahn. Chicago. Open Court. 1995.
- Kennedy, Kevin. "Paul Weiss's method(s) and system(s)." The Review of Metaphysics. Vol. 50. No. 1. (Sept. 1996).
- Silber, John. "In Memoriam: Paul Weiss (1901–2002)." The Review of Metaphysics. Vol. 56. No. 1. (Sep. 2002), pp. 253–254.
- Scott, A.O. "Review: ‘I Am Not Your Negro’ Will Make You Rethink Race", New York Times, 2/2/2017
- Langford, C. H. (1936). "Review: Collected Papers of Charles Peirce, Vol. III, Exact Logic, and Vol. IV, The Simplest Mathematics, ed. by Charles Hartshorne and Paul Weiss" (PDF). Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 42 (11): 795. doi:10.1090/S0002-9904-1936-06439-6.