Talk:Ann Sheehy

This article was nominated for deletion on 23 March 2007. The result of the discussion was redirect to APOBEC3G.

Nomination for deletion

I am nominating his article fo deletion. The Notabillity criteria holds that "A topic is generally notable if it has been the subject of coverage that is independent of the subject, reliable, and attributable. The depth of coverage and quality of sources must be considered in determining the number of sources required and whether the coverage establishes notability."

As a quick google search finds, the only entries relevant to the object of this topic are the persons own professional homepage, departmental homepage, and her publications. There is no record of notabillity or record to support the derivation of this article, ie, that she is credited with discovering APOBEC3G, other than that she's the primary author of the original paper. A search of notable profiles in Nature describes APOBEC3G as the most famous work of somebody called Michael Malim. There is however mention of Ann Sheehy as his post-doctoral fellow. On the above criteria, I think the article should be deleted as it is both factually wrong and does not satisfy Notabillity criteria.Dudewheresmywallet 11:36, 23 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]