Talk:BeForU discography

Bemani soundtracks?

I looked at the revision history of this page and saw that at one point DDR soundtracks were on here, but they were taken out. What's the general consensus on this? Should bemani soundtracks be on the discography, or not? アンジェリーク★Angelique 20:32, 22 June 2007 (UTC)[reply]

     I would say bemani soundtracks have as much right to be on the discography page as the rest. Probably in their own section (BeForU songs on other soundtracks maybe?) with only the relevent songs on the soundtracks mentioned.Ncnc123 (talk) 20:21, 12 December 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Request for Comment

There is a dispute over the formatting of the album names for BeForU II and BeForU III. Also disputed is whether or not the true... single is on Riyu Kosaka's begin album. 06:22, 28 July 2007 (UTC)

Statements by editors previously involved in dispute

While BeForU First Album is widely referred to with the "first album" text intact, this primarily functions to distinguish discussion of the album from the band, and the use of the name stems from Konami marketing it as "BeForUファーストアルバム" ("first album" in katakana)[1][2]. The name of the album is definitely just "BeForU", as indicated by the 「」 around "BeForU"; however, the phrase "BeForU first album" is used heavily by fans and may be notable. While Konami used the same text to market BeForU II[3], the album is very rarely referred to by fans as "BeForU Second Album," since there is no need for distinction from the band. BeForU III was produced under Avex, and has never officially been marketed as "BeForU Third Album". I have also never seen the term used by fans. While it may be appropriate to refer to the self-titled as "BeForU First Album", I feel that it is inappropriate to use those titles for BeForU II and III.

Also, while true... was Riyu Kosaka's first single, it was not included on her first album, begin. I feel this is fairly straightforward, as any tracklisting will reflect this[4][5][6]; however, a consensus has not been reached.

I have attempted to discuss these issues with the other user involved, with no response[7]; I have also posted about this issue here[8]. This seems like the logical next step, but let me know if there is something else I should do. アンジェリーク★Angelique 06:22, 28 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Comments