Talk:Hoarding (economics)

This article is or was the subject of a Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment.

This is not the usual meaning of the term.

Hoarding may mean private individuals storing hoards of gold, jewels or money for their own use, with an implication that they do not intend to use or dispose of it.

In economics, it usually refers to private individuals keeping unusually high stocks of goods for their own use, rather than relying on the market. They may see this as a way of attaining food security in a high-risk situation. Hoarding has been perceived to be extremely important in wartime and in famine situations, where it can lead to significant amounts of food and other products being removed from the market, so that people cannot buy them at a time when enough exists to supply the market at the normal price. In hyperinflation situations, they may hoard any non-perishable goods in the belief that they will no longer be able to buy them at future prices. Less dramatically, people may hoard sugar, say, if there is a rumour that the supermarkets are running out of, with the effect that the supermarkets, which keep low stocks, do in fact run out for a week or two. Governments frequently launch anti-hoarding campaigns in such circumstances, suggesting that hoarding is unnecessary, unpatriotic, or anti-social, so the word has emotional overtones. There is often an implication that hoarding occurs because individuals do not believe that the market will operate efficiently in current or expected conditions.

In a long career working with international organizations in many countries around the world I have never seen economists using this word for normal commercial stocks, or speculation. Nor does the Oxford English Dictionary mention this usage. It does turn up with politicians, journalists and civil servants.

I could turn up a lot of references to anti-hoarding campaigns etc, but is it really necessary? AidWorker (talk) 11:01, 2 June 2017 (UTC)

The example of a commercial firm charging for parking does not meet any of the usages of 'hoarding' that I have seen. It does not seem any different from the other uses of land, labour and capital. One does not talk of hoarding when a hotel rents out rooms, when a landowner rents land to a farmer, when people work on a salary, rather than jumping from one employer to another every half hour, when the bank charges interest on a loan. Sorry, but you have to produce not just verification claiming that one person uses the word in this way WP:VERIFY, but exceptional verification for this. WP:EXCEPTIONAL, WP:EXTRAORDINARY AidWorker (talk) 11:25, 2 June 2017 (UTC)

References

==Wiki Education assignment: Introduction to Digital Humanities== This article was the subject of a Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment, between 19 January 2022 and 9 May 2022. Further details are available on the course page. Student editor(s): JJAtSchool (article contribs). Peer reviewers: TenCatsInATrenchcoat.