Yes, I'll admit some of the references were a bit dodgy but does that necessitate removal of all mention of CDs, television appearances, the fact that is played on more than one show plus a perfectly good ref indicating how frequently it is downloaded? --➨Candlewicke :) Sign/Talk00:31, 17 November 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Well you seem to have removed quite a lot of stuff I didn't write. In fact pretty much the entire article. Which I recently did some tidy-up work on. Perhaps you would care to explain more explicitly what you mean by that message. Oh, and please sign your name when you leave a message. I have done so at the end just to show you a good example. (Logging in would also be more convenient for us all). --➨Candlewicke :) Sign/Talk00:27, 17 November 2008 (UTC)[reply]
"daily and is ranked number one in the national radio listenership category of 20-44 year olds"
It is!
Cite us please.
"The series features almost 100 characters, including BIFFO, Enda Kenny, Plastic Selecting and dozens more"
It does! (granted a rewording is needed)
Crufty Goodness - read the link I provided initially
"The album debuted at #5 on the Irish Albums Chart ahead of Amy Winehouse and Bruce Springsteen"
It did! (my contribution to that was, I think, removing the erroneous inclusion of Britney Spears or some such person which was inaccurate)
More crufty goodness - if I want to know what it was above, I'd look it up. This is more of the OMG GR8 LOL Sunday World type PR fluff.
"Some of this seems to have been written by Callan as it comes across as a first year PR student effort. He's just short of finishing every sentence with a series of exclamation marks."
That's an opinion. I am not him and have never met him. I tried to improve a difficult page; if you check out the state it was in before my edits you should hopefully see that.
"Links to CDworld - this is clearly just to get more orders in for this CD."
Inaccurate statement. From my viewing that particular "link" is a reference. As far as I can see it serves the purpose of proving the CD's existence until a more reliable source can be located... I am fairly sure there is a difference between blatant overlinking and including an inline citation.
No need for it, the CD must exist if it sold so well, no?
"and fourthly, the Irish Wikipedian's favourite, NPOV"
???!!! :/
"No explanation needed, I hope!"
I'm afraid so... that could be implying any number of things... :(
Why are you using an IP address for a conversation like this? It's not being kept in one place, which makes it difficult to be tracked. I'm assuming that since you are under a different identity that you didn't read fully the message I left under your previous one. Had you done so you would not need to ask that question. Or, putting it another way, you could persistently ask it and I could persistently deny it and neither of us would be any the better. But I amn't. I'm building up quite a collection of assumed identities at this stage; one would think that given my widespread edits to both RTÉ and independent media related articles, that common sense would prevail I would not be one of RTÉ's employees. However, I grow ever more intrigued by your continued usage of IP addresses... who are YOU? Perhaps that would be more to the point... could you kindly rule yourself out of the running as one of his former employers, friends, acquaintances, etc, who have become sour at his success? --➨Candlewicke :) Sign/Talk21:37, 17 November 2008 (UTC)[reply]
"The album debuted at #5 on the Irish Albums Chart ahead of Amy Winehouse and Bruce Springsteen"
Oh, and if you're still there, in relation to the above. I did NOT add that! Check the history please. In fact, I'll remove it if you haven't already done so... --➨Candlewicke :) Sign/Talk21:42, 17 November 2008 (UTC)[reply]
