Talk:Obsesii/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Paparazzzi (talk · contribs) 02:30, 26 March 2020 (UTC)

Expect a review soon. --Paparazzzi (talk) 02:30, 26 March 2020 (UTC)

Lead and infobox

• " the black and white clip sees Stan and several dancers..." replace "sees" with "depicts"
• "on the native Airplay 100 chart." Replace "native" with another word that implies the chart is Romanian

Is "local" alright?

• The artwork needs an Alt description

Background and reception

• Lucan prdoduced
• Isn't there any other information about how this song was created? I'm talking about an interview, maybe, where Alexandra or one of the producers describe the process of making this song

I follow her activity closly and sadly she didn't talk further on the song's creation. This is very unfortunate, and is the case with several of her tracks.

• I'm not sure about the reliability of CelebMix. Is it actually reliable?

I've had this discussion with several people, and we never gotten to a consensus. However, I used CelebMix for my past article due to the fact that Jonathan Currinn, is a journalist and reviewer with a degree and because he always cites his sources if what he writes isn't a review.

• You could add more information about the performance of the song on the Romanian chart: the date and position it debuted at, the date it reached its peak position, how many weeks it lasted on the chart...

Added. The song is still running on the chart.

• Mention the length and the genre of the track, they are both vital information for songs

I mentioned the length, however I cannot include the genre without a source to back it up.

Music video

• the clip sees Stan... same as above
• "They wear loose shirts to symbolize freedom." According to who? the singer herself or an editor of some website?

InfoMusic is a source which reports news and press conferences, I think they wrote about that the label sent them. It's safe to not name any author.

• Is Aficia reliable?

It's the same as with CelebMix

• Could you add information about the performances of the song? I'm referring to the costumes, stage, etc

There was unfortunately nothing too spectacular about these performances, and there is no source going in detail with what she wore etc.

• "Furthermore, she appeared on Kiss FM later that month" so she performed the song there or just gave an interview? this sentence is not very clear

Fixed.

Credits

• Spotify only showed me the songwriters, and with YouTube it was really hard to find the credits and it does not mention Radu Bolfea as a producer. I would rather use Tidal as the source for the credits. Here is the link.
• If you are going to use the term "songwriter" which includes both composers and lyricists, then remove "composer"

Fixed it another way

Sources

• Add the language for the German release
• The Afia article only shows the clip

The text "Alexandra Stan est de retour sur nos écrans avec le clip de “Obsesii”. Sobre, intime et sensuel à la fois…" is shown. If translated, it backs up what I wrote.

• I could not find the part of the article saying she performed the song on Vorbește lumea

There is a video loading. I also included the mark where the performance starts.

• For ref 9 mention the time mark where she stars performing
• Ref 11: I can't confirm if the song actually placed at number 50 because I could not listen to the audio. Find a better source if possible.

These are the official Kiss FM podcasts, but for the sake of this article, I included a new written source.

External links

• Remove this section since the music video has been already featured on the infobox

Verdict

Putting this on hold until my comments are addressed. Regards, Paparazzzi (talk) 04:21, 26 March 2020 (UTC)

@Paparazzzi: Thank you very much for the review. I solved anything unless where commented on. Greets; Cartoon network freak (talk) 15:02, 31 March 2020 (UTC)

Nomination is passed. Congratulations! --Paparazzzi (talk) 23:35, 2 April 2020 (UTC)