User:Wikibofh/Japanese Articles

This page is used to summarize the reasons I vote Keep on all of the Empire of Japan articles from the editor User:Wlad k, mostly editing as an anon from IP numbers 200.46.X.Y . i am only seeing for curiosity,and ,iwhen your analisis about me if terrible,yours too liked to agressive actions too!

Wladk:

Well,i am present:

the name of your uhknowed server are Wellington Perez Ishikawajima,i am from of Peru.

my nickname are Wladk for Wladimir Kamisky,i readed over German-Russian war and liked the history of Pro-axis russian military leader Bronislav Kaminsky. i am stay more prided of history of my great country and in my limits mantain contact with other japanese citizens why knowed about history in Japan and outside.

my farests ancestors are japanese and poses family in central america,Mexico ane Europe.i for working reasons staying preciselly in central america,in ones parents.

i sta more disgusts with theirs for your actions why in first thinked in good faith and comprension but in last days appareing agressive attacks,no one adequate recomendation or similar.

for this i knowed much of japanese history and poses more information at respect.preciselly i am debt at my nearests of Jap web sources,treated to publish some interesting info,but uhknowed why stay violating certain rigth laws.

i am are one interests in jap history in much detail overall the specific topic previously mentioned. i am knowed one panamenian why mentioned at me over your farests japanese ancestors,secret agents,jap plans against panama canal,and present some bibliography.

i stay more disillucioned with yours,if totally certain why poses more troubles in my grammar or no poses writing habilities,but i writing in good faith ,lamentably,yours stay in these strict media with correct inflexible rules,and i no poses well diction for participed in this.if more lamentably why having occured this.

in present days stay in these country,but for working reasons i traveled to Europe in route to Madagascar or South Africa.i am decided no return at your media i stay more desappointed and disgust with theirs!

Sirs,for my part no poses troubles,i am no agreed much idea ofwriting in your media other time,if more terrible for me!

PLEASE,DELETE ALL ARTICLES OF MY AUTORITY,IF ONLY ARTICLES WITHOUT VALUE OR NONE IMPORTACE,NO CONTINUINGDESTRUCTIVE WORDS AGAINST ME

The problem with these articles is obvious:

They look like a copyvio from somewhere
They look like a bablefish translation of some other article
They are not sourced
They are hard to understand.
The information is worthless
The titles are terrible
No one is going to work on these articles

What these articles would greatly benefit from is cleanup. It looks impossible, it is not. The best list of the documents is Charles Matthews page. Please do not put them up for VfD. People are working on them, and this contributor is very prolific. Now, let's address the points above.

They look like a copyvio from somewhere

They are not. They are an English->Spanish->English translation of portions of various books that are no longer in print. They are probably fair use without the translatios, with them, they are clearly no longer copyvio.

They look like a bablefish translation of some other article

As addressed above, they aren't. They are translations of a well meaning author with limited English skills. However, the information provides a valuable historical perspective.

They are not sourced

This is true. He has provided some sources, and I'll include them below. I would love for someone to get some of these books and take a look at the originals.

They are hard to understand

Again, this is true, but not a problem. That is what the cleanup tag is for.

The information is worthless

This information is not supposed to be a detailed analysis of current life and thinking. What it does a very good job of is providing an historical perspective, and that is how they should be viewed.

The titles are terrible

Again, yes, but this is easy to change. Ideally the articles should be moved into a better name probably, cleaned up, and then if the content needs to be merged that should be done.

No one is going to work on these articles

Working on these articles is slow going, but is going. Here are selected edits that I have made, others have also worked on them.

Sources

Cressey,G.B.Peoples and lands of Asia
Scion,Jules. Asie des Moussons(english edition)
Behr,Edward.The Last Emperor
Book Asia,the great Continent
Newman, Joseph. "Goodbye Japan"
Whitney Hall, John."Japanese Empire"
Gonzales-Hontoria,M.African and Asian States(Estados Asiaticos y Africanos)
Max,Alphonse.Southwest Asia,Reality and Destiny.
American First-hand and Chinese side relate "China In Weapons"