Jump to content

User talk:SusanaB2008

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Dear <DisillusionedBitterAndKnackered>, I have had a look at the contribution that "SusanaB2008" has made and l honestly can not understand why it has been removed. Please could you explain yourself "DisillusionedBitterAndKnackered" ? 1.) You are deleting her contribution for adding a very good performance link of the organ piece when you want to keep video links on that page that don't even work like the i.e. "*Performed by Marie-Claire Alain at St. Etienne de Caen". She is making a very valuable contribution by replacing a hoax link with a very good performance of the piece the page is about. The performance crucially relevant to the page.I honestly can not see why you have removed her very good contribution. 2.) Are you a qualified organist? I have been a cathedral organist in France for over 30 years now. Somehow l feel you have very limited knowledge on Organ Compositions and Symphonies. I have taken the time to listen to the other video links on the page and the "Clegg peformance" video by far has the highest and clearest sound quality. Maybe you should listen for your self and you will soon see the difference. The "Clegg performance" is definatley one of the best performances l have seen in many years of my profession. His/hers technical articulation is perfect. I am very grateful for "SusanaB2008" for finding this video and sharing it with me and my colleges on this page.

Please explain to me why musically this performance is not of a higher enough standard for you to list it amoungst the others and that you find it more useful for viewers to have access to hoax links rather than good performances of a piece. I am sorry but this is completely beyond me.

Start a discussion with SusanaB2008

Start a discussion