Wikipedia:Avoid imitating MediaWiki user interface elements
 | This page is currently inactive and is retained for historical reference. Either the page is no longer relevant or consensus on its purpose has become unclear. To revive discussion, seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump. See WP:SMI for the current guideline related to this topic. |
The nutshell just about says it all. If possible, keep discussion to the talk page.
Reasoning behind it
[edit]- An editor may be doing a systematic task (like reverting vandalism or tagging talk pages) when they are interrupted to consider an anomaly, whether an element coded differently, or a false talk page message.
- Bots that look for elements (like new message boxes) may become confused and stop functioning.
- People find it annoying.
- Such a link could lead users off-site, possibly to a virus site or pornography site.
Reasoning against it
[edit]- The Wikipedia community is tolerant, and shouldn't crush jokes just because they're irritating
- It's a bad idea to have MediaWiki UI elements that place themselves in the content box and are indistinguishable from wikitext, and the correct solution is for the devs to change this and refrain from repeating the mistake in the future.
Qualification
[edit]- Replacing page titles is not disruptive on user or user talk pages, unless it seeks to hide information.
Consequences of doing so
[edit]This policy, in itself, should never warrant a block. Ever. If there is a dispute about whether a certain element should go on a certain page, an admin should protect the page, not block a user. If a user is putting such elements on one or more remotely visible pages to prove a point or disrupt Wikipedia, this may warrant a block.