Wikipedia:Portal peer review/Ancient Greece/archive1
Portal:Ancient Greece[edit]
This portal hadn't been edited for along time. I did my best and want to know what I can do to improve it more or is it fine the way it is? Bewareofdog (talk) 19:59, 8 January 2008 (UTC)
Review by Seaserpent85
- Overall, good work - only a few issues that I can see from a first glance:
- Font colour in the title bars could do with being changed as it's quite hard to read.
Done - The introduction section could benefit from another paragraph and maybe the addition a relevant image if possible. Done
- The images in all the randomised content sections would benefit from captions, see Portal:Iceland for an example. Done
- Selected pictures should provide credit to the author, see Portal:Amusement parks as an example. Done
- Consider expanding the categories section, maybe make use of <categorytree> to produce an automatic category tree. Done
- No need for the "purge selections" link at the bottom, there's already a "show new selections" link further up the page. Done
- Perhaps you could add a few of the tasks from the to do list to the "things to do" section.
- Font colour in the title bars could do with being changed as it's quite hard to read.
Other than those, the portal looks great. Once you've expanded the randomised sections a bit further and made a final few adjustments, you could consider nominating it for Featured Portal status. Many thanks, Seaserpent85 15:05, 20 January 2008 (UTC)