In the following year the team was renamed New York Euphoria and the LFL was expanded by two more teams (Chicago Bliss and Dallas Desire). After defeating Chicago Bliss in the Eastern Final (one of the Semi-Finals which included a Skill Test, a 3-on-2 match and a dance competition) they met again with Team Dream (now named Los Angeles Temptation) at the final of Lingerie Bowl II and lost.
In 2006 they defeated Chicago Bliss again in the Semi-Final and for the first time defeated Los Angeles Temptation and thus won Lingerie Bowl III with a winning margin of only one point (obtained through a conversion) with a total score of 13-12.
The team was not carried over to the LFL when it made a full launch in 2009. Instead, New York was ostensibly represented by the New York Majesty (though its stadium was in fact in Reading, Pennsylvania).