Popular democracy

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Not to be mistaken with Irish or Marxist-Leninist People's Democracy. For the Italian party see Popular Democracy (United Left). For the Ecuatorian party see Christian Democratic Union (Ecuador)

Popular democracy is a notion of direct democracy based on referendums and other devices of empowerment and concretization of popular will. The concept evolved out of the political philosophy of Populism, as a fully democratic version of this popular empowerment ideology, but since it has become independent of it, and some even discuss if they are antagonistic or unrelated now (see Values). Though the expression has been used since the 19th century and may be applied to English Civil War politics, at least the notion (or the notion in its current form) is deemed recent and only recently got fully developed.

Early usages of the terms and/or the concept[edit]

Some figures, like TV documentary producer, director and writer Colin Thomas, see the Levellers, resistance of groups to both the Stuart monarchy and Oliver Cromwell’s English Republic as early popular democracy advocacy groups. Thomas sees the line of this early popular democracy going through the dissenting church, to the American Revolutionaries and later British trade unionism.[1]

Thomas Paine's Common Sense is sometimes considered to defend a form of popular democracy.[2] Andrew Jackson was considered a defendant of popular democracy as a politician and president,[3][4][5] and his presidency is considered as having made the transition from republic (Jeffersonian democracy) to popular democracy (Jacksonian democracy) in the United States[6]

Walt Whitman uses the word in Democratic Vistas as description of the vague notion of masse democracy with universal suffrage of a more or less direct and participatory type he defended. He admitted that the system had some dangers, but it "practically justifies itself beyond the proudest claims and wildest hopes of its enthusiasts".[7] William Jennings Bryan may be considered a popular democrat for his support of a democracy based on popular sovereignty.[8]

Teddy Roosevelt is considered a defender of a popular democrat insurgency against big business and elitism.[9]

In the end of the first half of the 20th century, the Christian democratic parties preferred the term "popular democrats" to Christian democrats.[10]

Mid-20th century[edit]

In post-independence India, popular democracy, together with economic and social liberalism and hindu nationalism, is considered one of the main currents who tried to define Indian politics since 1947.[11]

Iran is sometimes referred as having a history of Popular Democracy in parallel with the Pahlevi Monarchy before the overthrowing of Mossadeq and reinstating of the Shah.[12]

Eugene McCarthy was seen as a popular democrat presidential campaigner in 1968.[9]

In 1969 Muammar al-Gaddafi overthrows the pro-western monarchy and created a system he claims to be a popular democracy.[13]

Late 20th century[edit]

Similarly to Gathafi, Hafez al-Assad, officially ended the one party state of Ba'ath Syria created by the 1963 coup d'état in 1970, declaring the creation of a multi-party popular democracy.[14]

In 1975 Al Gathafi wrote The Green Book, where he defends his political system as a form of "direct and popular democracy" based on the will of the people instead of representative parliaments.

After the fall of Ferdinand Marcos in 1986 it was created in the Philippines a research and advocacy centre called Institute for Popular Democracy, who frequently criticizes "elite politics" and defends reformist local social movements.

Some Burkinabé Communists founded a group who supported a Marxist-Leninist People's Democracy (though with a free-market economic plan) in 1989, the Organization for Popular Democracy - Labour Movement. In 1991 they renounced Marxism-Leninism and transformed their Marxism-Leninism into a form of popular democrat philosophy.[15]

Václav Havel's civil-society-centered democratic Czechoslovakia was considered another form of popular democracy by some.[16]

In 1996 the popular democratic Organization for Popular Democracy - Labour Movement created the Congress for Democracy and Progress, being the current ruling party in Burkina Faso.

Today[edit]

The internet is sometimes considered as a vital part or an example of modern popular democratic practices.[17]

Some Marxist groups consider that the current Middle East is currently prepared for and wishes popular democracy (which in this context may be referring to Marxist People's Democracy) but that the "neoconservative design upon the region" and American power prevents this.[18]

There are some signs interpreted by analysts as possibilities of popular democracy, in Nigeria,[19] Abkhazia and Georgia[20] and Somaliland.[21]

Former Venezuelan president Hugo Chávez was sometimes considered to either be practicing[22] or simulating[23] popular democracy.

In 2003 it was published one of the main book-length appraisals of popular democracy, Hilary Wainwright's Reclaim the State: Experiments in Popular Democracy, a criticism of both Social Democracy and Big government and Neoliberalism and Big Business.

The Chinese democracy movement sometimes chooses a popular democrat system as the easiest democratic model from which the People's Republic of China could evolve out of the current one-party system ("people's democracy"), something which has already been criticized as a 'sell-out' by some Chinese democracy activists.[24]

Values[edit]

As Popular democracy is an ideal of direct and participatory democracy based on grassroots, there aren’t exactly very defined values beyond support of this kind of democracy over more representative types. But some attempts have been made for define Popular democrat ideals based around the idea that this direct democracy is just a step for a full democracy. Some proposals of Popular democratic common values have been:

Participatory budget and the policies of the Porto Alegre Forum are also associated with popular democracy by some left-wing authors.[27]

As the ideal of Popular democracy came out of prepositions of Populism (ex: popular rule in democracy is fairer than elitist parliaments; decisions by general referendums are fairer than decisions by limited groups like parliaments and governments), and as platforms of certain groups claiming to be popular democratic are very similar to those of various democratic and undemocratic populist movements, there is discussion on the relation between both political philosophies.[28][29][30]

Support[edit]

This ideal is currently supported by Glenn Smith[31] (who was connected to the Rockridge Institute,[32] a now defunct organization) and many other Progressive, Liberal and Populist Democrats.

Taking advantage of the vagueness of the concept many parties in a wide range of ideologies call themselves Popular Democratic Party, Popular Democrat Party or People's Democratic Party, or even Democratic Popular Party or Democratic People's Party and support or claim to support popular sovereignty in some form of popular democracy.

Alistair McConnachie writes frequent articles supporting popular democracy[25][26] for the think tank Sovereignty, which he directs.

Self-described Populist Harry C. Boyte adopts some popular democrat themes in his support of grassroots democracy.

The Nepalese Maoists also support a socialist, non-elitist, form of popular democracy ,[33] which may be understood as a form of Maoist people's democracy but based more on popular participation and less on Vanguard parties.

Criticism[edit]

Whitman wrote Democratic Vistas in answer to criticism of universal suffrage and full democracy of Thomas Carlyle in Latter-Day Pamphlets, who considered the popular democratic system too many rights given to uneducated masses of the people, as rule should be kept in the hands of highly educated people and aristocrats.[34] This criticisms have been repeated numerous times as a way of showing popular democracy as just another word for mob rule.

The idea of majoritarian, popular-will based democracy has been accused of facilitating the persecution of Sri Lankan Tamils.[35]

Other limitations of popular democracy have been indicated in its relation to other social movements (as feminism and trade unionism).[36]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Off With Their Heads – Bristol Radical History Week 2008, Bristol Radical History Group, section The Levellers Are Dead – Long Live The Levellers! – Colin Thomas
  2. ^ Common Sense: The Rhetoric of Popular Democracy, A We The People Resource, EDSITEment!.neh.org
  3. ^ Jacksonian Era, American History.About.com
  4. ^ JACKSON COMES TO POWER: THE ELECTION OF 1828
  5. ^ The Reader's Companion to American History, ed. Eric Foner, John Arthur Garraty, Society of American Historians, Houghton-Mifflin, 1991, section "JACKSONIAN DEMOCRACY"
  6. ^ American Lion: Andrew Jackson in the White House, by Jon Meacham, Powell's.com
  7. ^ What Whitman Knew, David Brooks, fourteenth paragraph
  8. ^ Where Did the Party Go?: William Jennings Bryan, Hubert Humphrey, and the Jeffersonian Legacy, Jeff Taylor, University of Missouri Press, 2006
  9. ^ a b Insurgency campaigns and the quest for popular democracy: Theodore Roosevelt, Eugene McCarthy, and party monopolies
  10. ^ The Christian Democrat International, Roberto Papini, page 32
  11. ^ Reinventing India: Liberalization, Hindu Nationalism and Popular Democracy, eu.Wiley.com
  12. ^ Obama, Hillary and full circle on Iowa, Sidney Morning Herald, Sidney Morning Herald Blog, third comment
  13. ^ Libya: Popular Democracy Or Police State?, Youtube.com
  14. ^ President Hafez Assad, official Bashar al-Assad website
  15. ^ Political Parties of the World (6th edition, 2005), ed. Bogdan Szajkowski, page 96.
  16. ^ Popular Democracy in Prague after the Velvet Revolution, Metta Spencer, Peace Magazine, Aug-Sep 1990
  17. ^ The Impact of the Internet on Popular Democracy in the United States, Gabriel J. Gubash, Saint Mary's University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, May, 1997
  18. ^ Marxism mailing list archive, re: The growing striving for popular democracy in the MiddleEast - striving where?, Marxism mailing list, 16 May 2005
  19. ^ Good Governance, A Desiderata For Popular Democracy In Nigeria, Prince Charles Dickson, Nigeria Village Square, 22 March 2008
  20. ^ Abkhazie-Géorgie : essai de démocratie populaire, Mathilde Damoisel, Caucaz Europenews, 1 June 2003, (in French)
  21. ^ Somaliland: A Historic Move To Popular Democracy, Somaliland Forum, Somaliland Times, 15–25 November 2008
  22. ^ Monthly Review, Nepal and Venezuela: For Popular Democracy, against Ceremonial Democracy, Pratyush Chandra Monthly Review magazine, 23 April 2006
  23. ^ Travel to Venezuela: Popular Democracy
  24. ^ Charter 08: Chinese Activists Question Effectiveness Of Popular Democracy Charter, Joel Schectman, Huffington Post, February 23, 2009 (published online by Overseas Chinese Democracy Coalition News and Article Release Issue Number: A443-O132, at the Wei Jingsheng Foundation)
  25. ^ a b c d e f THE FIVE PRINCIPLES OF DEMOCRACY, Alistair McConnachie, Sovereignty, March 2005
  26. ^ a b c THE SOVEREIGNTY STRATEGY TO REGAIN CONTROL OF OUR GOVERNMENT, Alistair McConnachie, Sovereignty, February 2002
  27. ^ Participatory Budgeting: from Porto Alegre, Brazil to the U.S., Mike Menser and Juscha Robinson, Popular Economics.org
  28. ^ Populism or Popular Democracy? The UDF, Workerism and the Struggle for Radical Democracy in South Africa, David Howarth, in Populism And The Mirror Of Democracy, ed. Francisco Panizza, Verso, 2005
  29. ^ Authoritarian Populism: A Reply to Jessop et al, Stuart Hall, New Left Review I/151, May–June 1985
  30. ^ Democratically Aestheticized Politics, Jon Simons, American Political Science Association, Aug 30, 2007
  31. ^ The Promise of Popular Democracy, Part II: Solidarity of the Shaken, Glenn W. Smith, Rockridge Institute, Sun Apr 27, 2008
  32. ^ The support of the Rockridge Institute to popular democracy can be seen in their website's The Promise of Popular Democracy series
  33. ^ Nepal and Venezuela: For Popular Democracy, against Ceremonial Democracy, by Pratyush Chandra
  34. ^ What Whitman Knew, David Brooks, ninth paragraph.
  35. ^ The Specter of Popular Democracy: How Majoritarianism is Facilitating Genocide in Sri Lanka, Moggy on March 8, Zimbio, 2009
  36. ^ The limits of popular Democracy: women's organisations, feminism and the UDF, Shireen Hassim, in Transformation 51, 2003

External links[edit]