Ontological argument: Revision history

28 September 2024

• curprev 06:4706:47, 28 September 2024‎ WikiCleanerBot talk contribs‎ m 76,630 bytes 0‎ v2.05b - Bot T20 CW#61 - Fix errors for CW project (Reference before punctuation) undo Tag: WPCleaner
• curprev 04:2304:23, 28 September 2024‎ Citation bot talk contribs‎ 76,630 bytes +40‎ Altered pages. Add: jstor, doi. Removed parameters. Formatted dashes. | Use this bot. Report bugs. | Suggested by Whoop whoop pull up | #UCB_webform 475/3370 undo

26 September 2024

• curprev 22:1822:18, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ m 76,590 bytes +24‎ changed "in the 1975 version of the argument" to "in the version of the argument in God, Freedom and Evil", since that work was also published in 1974 undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 21:4621:46, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 76,566 bytes −36‎ Deleted the claim that Plantinga's argument relies on axiom 5 of S5 (which had no citation). Replaced it with a reference to Graham Oppy, who writes that it relies on a system B or system S5 modal logic. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 21:3621:36, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ m 76,602 bytes +15‎ extremley nitpicky: replaced "conclusion" with "validity of this argument". This is because the truth of an argument's conclusion relies on the validity of the argument and on the truth of its premises. The considerations that follow this sentence concern the validity of the argument. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 21:1221:12, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ m 76,587 bytes +48‎ Three minor changes: 1) added clarification of what it means to exist necessarily at the first mention of this term; 2) replaced "our world" with "actual world" (to use the proper technical terminology and for greater consistency); 3) replaced "In an attempt to resolve this problem" with "In an attempt to make the argument immune to his criticism" (to make it clear that Plantinga is fixing an issue he sees ... that isn't there in Hartshorne) undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 15:3715:37, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ m 76,539 bytes +1‎ I mistakenly wrote a sentence that belongs in the Plantinga section in the Sankara's dictum section. I have now corrected its placement. It says that, according to Oppy, S5 is the right system for Plantinga's purposes. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 15:1115:11, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ m 76,538 bytes +9‎ I mistakenly changed the format of "Sankara's dictum" in a previous edit. Here, I changed it back to sub-heading-1 undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 15:0515:05, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 76,529 bytes −2‎ The page used to read "Richard M. Gale aruged that premise three, the 'possibility premise', begs the question". I replaced "three" with "one" given that in the reconstruction this refers to (by William Craig), the possibility premise is premise 1, not 3. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 14:5914:59, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 76,531 bytes +428‎ Added that according to Graham Oppy, system S5 gives us the right meanings for "necessary" and "possible" for Plantinga's purposes. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 14:5614:56, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ m 76,103 bytes +12‎ Replaced the phrase "On S5 systems in general" with "On systems of modal logic in general". This is because Garson is not just talking about system S5, but about the aptness of different systems of modal logic in general, depending on the way we want to use "necessarily" and "possibly". undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 14:4414:44, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 76,091 bytes +319‎ Added that Plantinga anticipated the objection that his argument begs the question and stated his response. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 14:3414:34, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 75,772 bytes +703‎ Added that in the final renditions of his argument, Plantinga phrases it in terms of instantiations of properties rather than in terms of possible beings. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 14:2714:27, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 75,069 bytes +890‎ Added that there are many different reconstructions of Plantinga's argument accross the literature. Referenced a few examples (Graham Oppy, Joshua Rasmussen, Gregory Stacey, Jordan Sobel). undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 13:5213:52, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 74,179 bytes +476‎ Added a reconstruction of Plantinga's argument by Graham Oppy. I added it because it is simple and because Oppy is a reliable source. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 13:3313:33, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 73,703 bytes +478‎ Corrected "greatness" and "excellence" to "maximal greatness" and "maximal excellence" Added Plantinga's definitions of "maximal greatness" and "maximal excellence". undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 13:2213:22, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 73,225 bytes +309‎ Added Sobel's defense of Hartshorne against Plantinga's criticism. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 12:4612:46, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 72,916 bytes +105‎ Added a concluding sentence to a paragraph. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 12:3912:39, 26 September 2024‎ Applesandoranges501 talk contribs‎ 72,811 bytes +1,659‎ I added an explanation of how Plantinga conflates Malcom's and Hartshorne's argument. I then added that Jordan Sobel disagrees with Plantinga's rendition of Hartshorne. Sobel argues that Hartshorne's argument is not vulnerable to the criticism that Plantinga raises for Malcom. I then improved the explanation of Plantinga's criticism of Malcom. Lastly, I corrected a citation mistake. Plantinga's "God, Freedom and Evil" was 1st published in 1974, not 1975. undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 12:0512:05, 26 September 2024‎ Niinjja talk contribs‎ 71,152 bytes −37‎ I tried to implement revisions based on previous critical remarks (that I only just noticed, sorry for that) undo
• curprev 11:0411:04, 26 September 2024‎ Niinjja talk contribs‎ 71,189 bytes +1,473‎ Rearrangement of and addition to existing contents. Underlying aim: addition of Hartshorne's modal argument for the existence of god. For maximal clarity regarding contents and visuals, I then incorporated a small section for each philosopher (Malcolm and Hartshorne), and rearranged existing contents accordingly. undo Tag: Manual revert
• curprev 10:5610:56, 26 September 2024‎ Remsense talk contribs‎ 69,716 bytes −1,473‎ Undid revision 1247853260 by Niinjja (talk): having sections "A" and "B" in supersection "A and B" is not good structuring. generally not an improvement. undo Tags: Undo Reverted
• curprev 10:5310:53, 26 September 2024‎ Niinjja talk contribs‎ 71,189 bytes +1,473‎ I rearranged and added to existing contents. I did not delete any sections. I gave each philosopher undo Tag: Reverted

17 September 2024

• curprev 17:4417:44, 17 September 2024‎ HeyElliott talk contribs‎ 69,716 bytes −28‎ Redundant, WP:SORTKEY undo Tag: 2017 wikitext editor

30 July 2024

• curprev 14:2914:29, 30 July 2024‎ Alfedda talk contribs‎ 69,744 bytes +35‎ No edit summary undo Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit

25 July 2024

• curprev 14:0214:02, 25 July 2024‎ Pirhayati talk contribs‎ m 69,709 bytes +4‎ Richard M. Gale undo

1 July 2024

• curprev 18:4618:46, 1 July 2024‎ SimLibrarian talk contribs‎ m 69,705 bytes +3‎ rm contractions, URL update undo Tag: Visual edit

22 June 2024

• curprev 01:3801:38, 22 June 2024‎ Citation bot talk contribs‎ 69,702 bytes +27‎ Alter: pages, doi. Formatted dashes. | Use this bot. Report bugs. | #UCB_CommandLine undo

20 June 2024

• curprev 01:0501:05, 20 June 2024‎ SnowFire talk contribs‎ 69,675 bytes +452‎ →‎Gaunilo: add a more modern use of this critique. undo

3 June 2024

• curprev 15:3615:36, 3 June 2024‎ FlantasyFlan talk contribs‎ m 69,223 bytes +34‎ Added that ontological arguments are deductive, like all a priori reasoning. undo Tag: Visual edit

2 June 2024

• curprev 22:5422:54, 2 June 2024‎ CommonsDelinker talk contribs‎ 69,189 bytes +17‎ Replacing Kant_foto.jpg with File:Immanuel_Kant_-_Gemaelde_2.jpg (by CommonsDelinker because: File renamed: Criterion 3 (obvious error)). undo

16 May 2024

• curprev 19:1319:13, 16 May 2024‎ WJ94 talk contribs‎ 69,172 bytes −328‎ →‎Automated reasoning: Removing unsourced material undo

14 May 2024

• curprev 20:3720:37, 14 May 2024‎ Samcast12345 talk contribs‎ 69,500 bytes −37‎ The previous author suggested in the argument that a greatest possible being that can be imagined with a being than which none greater can be imagined which is a significant assumption, and a significant departure from the language of Anselm's argument in Proslogion II. It is significant because one need not be able to conceive a possible being (as Anselm later suggests God is greater than one can conceive), just unable to conceive a greater being. undo Tag: Visual edit

18 April 2024

• curprev 06:2506:25, 18 April 2024‎ Citation bot talk contribs‎ 69,537 bytes +29‎ Added title. | Use this bot. Report bugs. | Suggested by Jay8g | #UCB_toolbar undo

17 April 2024

• curprev 21:0221:02, 17 April 2024‎ Remsense talk contribs‎ 69,508 bytes −73‎ →‎G. W. F. Hegel: trying to cohere this a little more, forgive me undo
• curprev 20:3720:37, 17 April 2024‎ Burraron talk contribs‎ m 69,581 bytes +4‎ link undo
• curprev 20:3620:36, 17 April 2024‎ Burraron talk contribs‎ 69,577 bytes +27‎ →‎G. W. F. Hegel undo

10 April 2024

• curprev 08:0408:04, 10 April 2024‎ 176.200.70.182 talk‎ 69,550 bytes +14‎ →‎External links: link to WQ undo
• curprev 00:4700:47, 10 April 2024‎ JR0576 talk contribs‎ 69,536 bytes +4‎ →‎Mulla Sadra: +lk undo

21 February 2024

• curprev 22:0322:03, 21 February 2024‎ CustodianOfClara talk contribs‎ 69,532 bytes +2‎ Literal translation previous to edit was not actually literal, because it included implied words, so I added brackets to make that clear. undo

17 November 2023

• curprev 20:5120:51, 17 November 2023‎ Citation bot talk contribs‎ 69,530 bytes −198‎ Add: encyclopedia, authors 1-3. Removed proxy/dead URL that duplicated identifier. Removed parameters. Some additions/deletions were parameter name changes. | Use this bot. Report bugs. | Suggested by Countercheck | #UCB_webform undo
• curprev 20:4820:48, 17 November 2023‎ Countercheck talk contribs‎ 69,728 bytes +2‎ adjusted a picture size using upright to match other pictures undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 20:4720:47, 17 November 2023‎ Countercheck talk contribs‎ 69,726 bytes +99‎ copyedit of fourth quarter of article undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 20:3620:36, 17 November 2023‎ Countercheck talk contribs‎ 69,627 bytes +203‎ light copyedit of third quarter of article undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 20:2020:20, 17 November 2023‎ Countercheck talk contribs‎ 69,424 bytes +265‎ copyedit of second quarter of article undo Tag: Visual edit
• curprev 19:3419:34, 17 November 2023‎ Countercheck talk contribs‎ 69,159 bytes +314‎ copyedit of first quarter of article; converted px to upright undo Tag: Visual edit

27 October 2023

• curprev 16:2216:22, 27 October 2023‎ 2600:4040:9e20:c00:a1e8:8dad:c5f4:1eec talk‎ 68,845 bytes +36‎ No edit summary undo

23 August 2023

• curprev 20:1020:10, 23 August 2023‎ WJ94 talk contribs‎ 68,809 bytes −1,683‎ →‎Other formulations: The source for this is not reliable; without a reliable secondary source I am removing this section undo
• curprev 14:0214:02, 23 August 2023‎ Mach61 talk contribs‎ 70,492 bytes −1,202‎ →‎Meta-logical approach: removed uncited section undo

9 August 2023

• curprev 16:3816:38, 9 August 2023‎ Tgeorgescu talk contribs‎ 71,694 bytes −100‎ Reverted 1 edit by 36.85.221.107 (talk): WP:LEDE undo Tags: Twinkle Undo