Jump to content

Baljuna Covenant: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
starting
 
m Add good article icon
(30 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{good article}}
The '''Baljuna Covenant''' was an [[oath]] sworn by [[Temüjin]] and nineteen companions in 1203 AD, at Baljuna Lake in present-day [[Mongolia]]. In a time of great hardship, Temüjin swore that he would reward these loyal followers when he took power. When he was acclaimed as Genghis Khan at the [[kurultai]] of 1206, the oath-takers became high-ranking figures at the core of the [[Mongol Empire]].
{{Use Oxford spelling|date=June 2023}}
{{Short description|Oath sworn by Temüjin (Genghis Khan) in 1203}}
[[File:YuanEmperorAlbumGenghisPortrait.jpg|thumb|right|upright=1.4|alt=A painting depicting an old man in white robes and cap, wearing earrings and a long pointed beard.|Temüjin, portrayed as Genghis Khan, in a 14th-century [[Yuan era]] album]]
The '''Baljuna Covenant''' was an [[oath]] sworn in summer 1203 AD by [[Temüjin]], the future Genghis Khan, and a small group of companions, hence known as the ''Baljunatu''. Having [[Rise of Genghis Khan|risen in power]] as a subject to the [[Kereit]] chieftain [[Toghrul]], the [[Mongol]] Temüjin had aroused the enmity of several leading aristocrats, including Toghrul's son Senggum. In spring 1203, when Temüjin proposed a marriage alliance between him and Toghrul, a greatly offended Senggum convinced his father that Temüjin was angling to usurp them. Escaping two successive ambushes, the Mongol leader was cornered and comprehensively defeated at the [[Battle of Qalaqaljid Sands]], suffering severe losses.

Temüjin regrouped the scattered remnants of his forces, and retreated to Baljuna, an unknown river or lake in south-eastern [[Mongolia]]. There, he and his closest companions swore an oath of mutual fidelity, promising to share hardships and glories with each other. Having spent the summer recruiting warriors attracted by the ideals of his campaign, Temüjin amassed enough of a force to defeat the Kereit in battle that autumn. Three years later in 1206, having defeated all enemies on the steppe, Temüjin entitled himself Genghis Khan at a [[kurultai]] and honoured the ''Baljunatu'' with the highest honours of his new [[Mongol Empire]].

==Background==
[[Temüjin]] was born between 1155 and 1167 AD to [[Yesugei]], a [[Mongols|Mongol]] chieftain, and his [[Olkhonud]] wife [[Hoelun]]. Yesugei died when Temüjin was nine and he, his mother, and six other siblings, were all abandoned by their tribe. The family survived, however, and Temüjin began to collect a small group of companions, especially after he swore loyalty to his father's ''anda'' ({{literally}} "[[blood brother]]"), the chieftain [[Toghrul]] of the central [[Kereit]] tribe.{{sfnm|Morgan|1986|1pp=57–60|Ratchnevsky|1991|2pp=28–33|3a1=Fitzhugh|3a2=Rossabi|3a3=Honeychurch|3y=2009|3p=101}} His ambitions were stymied by [[Jamukha]], his own ''anda'', whom he intermittently fought from the 1180s onwards. Although the Kereit were ostensibly the most powerful tribe on the [[Eurasian Steppe|Mongol steppe]] by 1201, the tribe's nobility began to fear that they too would soon be usurped by the rapidly-rising Temüjin, who had become dominant in eastern [[Mongolia]]. These aristocrats were led by Toghrul's son Senggum, who was afraid for his own inheritance.{{sfnm|Atwood|2004|1pp=98, 259–260|May|2018|2pp=34–36}}

These fears would soon be realized. Aiming to secure control over the Kereit line of succession, Temüjin proposed that his eldest son [[Jochi]] be married to Toghrul's daughter Cha'ur Beki, promising one of his own daughters to Senggum's son in return for the establishment of ''quda'' ({{literally}} "marriage alliance"). Senggum conclusively rejected this proposal: not only was his position as heir to the Kereit at risk, but he found the proposal disrespectful because of Jochi's possible illegitimacy.{{efn|Jochi had been born after his mother [[Börte]] had been kidnapped and raped by members of the [[Merkit]] tribe. Although Genghis always treated him as a legitimate son, doubts concerning Jochi's paternity followed him throughout his life.{{sfn|Atwood|2004|p=278}}}} He was supported in his position by the tribal aristocracy, which included Altan and Kuchar, two of Temüjin's relatives, and Jamukha, who urged immediate action against his old ''anda''.{{sfnm|May|2018|1p=37|Ratchnevsky|1991|2pp=38, 67}} Toghrul's position in the dispute is unclear—according to the ''[[Secret History of the Mongols]]'', he was torn between his close ties to Temüjin and his love for his son, only choosing to support the latter when presented with an [[ultimatum]]. On the other hand, according to the ''[[Jami al-tawarikh]]'' of [[Rashid al-Din Hamadani|Rashid al-Din]] and oral histories recounted by [[Marco Polo]], Toghrul was already predisposed against Temüjin and reacted angrily to the marriage proposal.{{sfnm|Ratchnevsky|1991|1p=68|Man|2004|2p=96}} It is possible that Toghrul's mind was swayed by a merchant delegation from [[Central Asia]] containing representatives from the [[Qara Khitai]] and the [[Uighurs]], whom Temüjin was likely to exclude from the [[Silk Road]] trade structures were he to gain ascendancy; it is also likely that Temüjin's own ambitions were somewhat to blame for the rupture in relations.{{sfn|McLynn|2015|p=72|2a1=Fitzhugh|2a2=Rossabi|2a3=Honeychurch|2y=2009|2p=102}}

In the end, Senggum's arguments prevailed over Toghrul. Desiring to avoid open conflict if possible, the Kereit leader devised a [[Military deception|plan of deception]]: he informed Temüjin that he had decided to accept the [[Arranged marriage|proposed marriages]] and intended to hold a celebratory [[banquet]]. An unsuspecting Temüjin set off with a minimal guard to the feast,{{efn|[[Rashid al-Din Hamadani|Rashid al-Din]] mentions two companions, whereas the ''[[Secret History of the Mongols]]'' counts ten.{{sfn|Ratchnevsky|1991|p=69}}}} where the conspirators had planned to [[ambush]] and kill him; warned of hostile rumours by his father's old retainer Münglig, he halted. Led by Senggum, the Kereit then took to the field in force, and Temüjin only escaped here because two [[herder|herdsmen]] named Badai and Kishlik overheard the plans and came to warn him.{{sfnm|Ratchnevsky|1991|1pp=68–69|May|2018|2p=37|Weatherford|2004|3p=56}} Decisively outnumbered, Temüjin was forced into headlong flight—he rode with his companions to the borders of [[Jin dynasty (1115–1234)|Jin China]], where he hoped to find reinforcements and seek sanctuary across the border if necessary. Even though he received some [[defectors]] from the Kereit force, including Kuildar of the [[Manghud|Mankut]] and Jurchedei of the {{ill|Uru'ud|ru|Уруты}}, Temüjin was decisively defeated at the [[Battle of Qalaqaljid Sands]] in spring 1203. The defections proved crucial in allowing Temüjin to escape—Jurchedei wounded Senggum with an [[arrow]], halting the Kereit attack—but Toghrul also chose not to pursue, reasoning that his enemy was out of the strategic picture.{{sfnm|Ratchnevsky|1991|1pp=69–70|McLynn|2015|2pp=73–74}}

==The Baljuna Covenant==
Temüjin's forces had suffered severe losses during the [[Withdrawal (military)|withdrawal]] from the battle and several of his captains were missing. Despite the danger he waited through the following night for his surving troops to collect. [[Bo'orchu]] arrived at dawn, having lost his horse at Qalaqaljid, and he was shortly followed by [[Boroqul]], who was tending to [[Ogedei]], Temüjin's third son, who had suffered a serious neck injury. Temüjin then retreated, stopping only to bury Kuildar, who had been killed during the battle.{{sfnm|Ratchnevsky|1991|1pp=70–71|Atwood|2004|2p=342|Cleaves|1955|3p=389}} His forces eventually reached a lake or river named Baljuna, a place of unknown location. Scholars have alternately identified it as a tributary of the [[Ingoda (river)|River Ingoda]], or as [[Lake Balzino]] in [[Buryatia]]. The most likely location however lies on the [[Khalkhyn Gol|Kalka River]], which Temüjin might have retreated along and which lies close to the Jin frontier in south-eastern [[Mongolia]].{{sfnm|Man|2004|1pp=96–97|Ratchnevsky|1991|2p=71}}

At this juncture in summer 1203, the size of the Mongol force was very small at either 2,600 or 4,600 warriors; [[biographies]] in the ''[[History of Yuan|Yuán Shǐ]]'' emphasise the situation's exigency by stating Temüjin was accompanied by only nineteen followers, but this might well just refer to the [[Company (military unit)|company]] leaders.{{sfnm|Ratchnevsky|1991|1pp=71, 73|Cleaves|1955|2p=397}} According to the ''Yuán Shǐ'', the starving men killed a fortuitously [[Przewalski's horse|wild horse]], eating its flesh and using its [[Animal product|by-products]] to safely drink the muddy water:{{sfnm|Cleaves|1955|1p=397|Man|2004|2p=97}}

{{Blockquote|text=Temüjin, raising his hands towards the sky, swore thus: "If I finish 'the Great Work' then I shall share with you men the sweet and the bitter. If I break this word then let me be like this river, drunk up by others." Among officers and men there was none who was not moved to tears.}}

This retelling likely masks the historical events. The poetic Baljuna Covenant encapsulates the themes—a potent mixture of [[social equality]] and personal [[asceticism]]—Temüjin would emphasise to potential recruits. Temüjin in all probability spent a large portion of the summer attempting to recruit warriors to his cause: those he succeeded with included the [[Onggirat]], the tribe of his wife Börte, the Ikires, and some of the Nirun Mongols. Others included [[Khitan people|leaders of the Khitan tribe]], who saw in Temüjin a route to revenge against the Jin, and the [[Muslim]] merchants Ja'far and Hasan, who would have thought that Temüjin could offer economic and [[protection|personal protection]], along with favourable [[trade agreement|trade pacts]]. He even recruited members of Toghrul's Kereit tribe, such as [[Chinqai]] who became a prominent administrator under Ogedei.{{sfnm|Ratchnevsky|1991|1pp=71–72|2a1=Fitzhugh|2a2=Rossabi|2a3=Honeychurch|2y=2009|2p=102}}

Historians have emphasised the social, cultural, and religious [[heterogeneity]] of the Baljuna oath-takers. There were no Mongols, apart from Temüjin and his brother [[Qasar]] in the traditional nineteen—they instead included Khitans, [[Tangut people|Tanguts]], Keireits, [[Naimans]], Central Asians, and possibly even [[South Asian ethnic groups|South Asians]], in a total of nine different clans. Swearing loyalty to Temüjin, a devout worshipper of [[Tengrism]], were three Muslims and several [[Nestorian Christianity|Christians]] and [[Buddhists]]. In transcending traditional avenues of community, the Baljuna Covenant was "a type of brotherhood [akin to] modern civic citizenship based upon personal choice and commitment", in the words of the historian [[Jack Weatherford]].{{sfnm|Biran|2012|1p=38|Weatherford|2004|2p=58}}

===Aftermath and legacy===
In autumn 1203, a revitalized Temüjin marshalled his forces and defeated the Kereit in a hard-fought three-day battle at the Jeje'er Heights on the lower [[Kherlen river]]. The fleeing Toghrul was killed by a Naiman [[Picket (military)|sentry]] who did not recognise him, while Senggum fled first to [[Tibet]] and then [[Kashgar]], where he was later killed. Over the next three years, he defeated the Naimans and [[Merkit]]s, uniting the Mongol steppe under one ruler. In 1206, he held a great [[kurultai]] on the [[Onon River]], at which he took the title "Genghis Khan" and rewarded those who brought him to power. These included the herdsmen Badai and Kishlik who had warned him of Toghrul's betrayal—they were honoured with the Kereit leader's [[yurt|palace tent]], furnishings, and [[bodyguard]].{{sfnm|Atwood|2004|1pp=98–99|Ratchnevsky|1991|2pp=79–81|3a1=Fitzhugh|3a2=Rossabi|3a3=Honeychurch|3y=2009|3p=102}} The men who swore the Baljuna Covenant, who became known as ''Baljunatu'' ({{literally}} "Baljuna men", or "Muddy Water Drinkers") were honoured with the highest titles and were remembered as late as the 1300s.{{sfnm|Atwood|2004|1p=30|Ratchnevsky|1991|2p=73}} Many took prominent positions in Genghis' [[Mongol Empire]]—these included Chinqai, the Muslim merchant and [[diplomat]] Ja'far Khoja, and Qaban, an [[Uriankhai]] whose son [[Subutai]] became one of the most formidable Mongol generals.{{sfn|Atwood|2004|pp=103, 257, 520}}

==References==
===Notes===
{{notelist}}

===Citations===
{{reflist}}

===Sources===
{{refbegin}}
* {{cite book |last=Atwood |first=Christopher P. |date=2004 |title=Encyclopedia of Mongolia and the Mongol Empire |publisher=Facts on File |location=New York |isbn=978-0-8160-4671-3 |url=https://www.academia.edu/8855875 |access-date=2 March 2022}}
* {{cite book |last=Biran |first=Michal |title=Genghis Khan |year=2012 |series=Makers of the Muslim World |publisher=[[Oneworld Publications]] |location=London |url=https://www.academia.edu/32453356 |isbn=978-1-78074-204-5}}
* {{cite journal |last=Cleaves |first=Francis Woodman |author-link=Francis Woodman Cleaves |date=1955 |journal=[[Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies]] |title=The Historicity of The Baljuna Covenant |volume=18 |issue=3 |pages=357–421 |doi=10.2307/2718438 |jstor=2718438 |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/2718438}}
* {{cite book |editor-last1=Fitzhugh |editor-first1=William W. |editor-link1=William W. Fitzhugh |editor-last2=Rossabi |editor-first2=Morris |editor-link2=Morris Rossabi |editor-last3=Honeychurch |editor-first3=William |year=2009 |title=Genghis Khan and the Mongolian Empire |publisher=Mongolian Preservation Foundation |location=Washington |isbn=978-0-295-98957-0 |url=https://archive.org/details/genghiskhanmongo00medi |url-access=limited }}
* {{cite book |last=Man |first=John |author-link=John Man (author) |date=2004 |title=Genghis Khan: Life, Death and Resurrection |location=London |publisher=[[Bantam Press]] |url-access=registration |url=https://archive.org/details/genghiskhanlifed0000manj |oclc=1193945768}}
* {{cite book |last=May |first=Timothy |date=2018 |title=The Mongol Empire |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.3366/j.ctv1kz4g68 |location=Edinburgh |publisher=[[Edinburgh University Press]] |jstor=10.3366/j.ctv1kz4g68.11 |isbn=9780748642373}}
* {{cite book |last=McLynn |first=Frank |title=Genghis Khan: His Conquests, His Empire, His Legacy |year=2015 |publisher=Hachette Books |isbn=978-0-306-82395-4 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=jcQzCgAAQBAJ}}
* {{cite book |last=Morgan |first=David |author-link=David O. Morgan |date=1986 |title=The Mongols |series=The Peoples of Europe |publisher=[[Blackwell Publishing]] |location=[[Oxford]] |isbn=978-0-631-17563-6 |url-access=registration |url= https://archive.org/details/mongolspeoplesof00davi }}
* {{cite book |last=Ratchnevsky |first=Paul |year=1991 |translator=Thomas Haining |translator-link=Thomas Haining |title=Genghis Khan: His Life and Legacy |publisher=[[Blackwell Publishing]] |location=Oxford |url=https://archive.org/details/genghiskhan00paul/ |url-access=registration |isbn=978-06-31-16785-3}}
* {{cite book |last=Weatherford |first=Jack |title=Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World |date=2004 |publisher=[[Crown Publishing Group]] |location=New York |isbn=978-0-307-23781-1 |url = https://archive.org/details/genghiskhanmaki00jack |url-access=registration }}
{{refend}}

Revision as of 07:41, 18 June 2023

A painting depicting an old man in white robes and cap, wearing earrings and a long pointed beard.
Temüjin, portrayed as Genghis Khan, in a 14th-century Yuan era album

The Baljuna Covenant was an oath sworn in summer 1203 AD by Temüjin, the future Genghis Khan, and a small group of companions, hence known as the Baljunatu. Having risen in power as a subject to the Kereit chieftain Toghrul, the Mongol Temüjin had aroused the enmity of several leading aristocrats, including Toghrul's son Senggum. In spring 1203, when Temüjin proposed a marriage alliance between him and Toghrul, a greatly offended Senggum convinced his father that Temüjin was angling to usurp them. Escaping two successive ambushes, the Mongol leader was cornered and comprehensively defeated at the Battle of Qalaqaljid Sands, suffering severe losses.

Temüjin regrouped the scattered remnants of his forces, and retreated to Baljuna, an unknown river or lake in south-eastern Mongolia. There, he and his closest companions swore an oath of mutual fidelity, promising to share hardships and glories with each other. Having spent the summer recruiting warriors attracted by the ideals of his campaign, Temüjin amassed enough of a force to defeat the Kereit in battle that autumn. Three years later in 1206, having defeated all enemies on the steppe, Temüjin entitled himself Genghis Khan at a kurultai and honoured the Baljunatu with the highest honours of his new Mongol Empire.

Background

Temüjin was born between 1155 and 1167 AD to Yesugei, a Mongol chieftain, and his Olkhonud wife Hoelun. Yesugei died when Temüjin was nine and he, his mother, and six other siblings, were all abandoned by their tribe. The family survived, however, and Temüjin began to collect a small group of companions, especially after he swore loyalty to his father's anda (lit. "blood brother"), the chieftain Toghrul of the central Kereit tribe.[1] His ambitions were stymied by Jamukha, his own anda, whom he intermittently fought from the 1180s onwards. Although the Kereit were ostensibly the most powerful tribe on the Mongol steppe by 1201, the tribe's nobility began to fear that they too would soon be usurped by the rapidly-rising Temüjin, who had become dominant in eastern Mongolia. These aristocrats were led by Toghrul's son Senggum, who was afraid for his own inheritance.[2]

These fears would soon be realized. Aiming to secure control over the Kereit line of succession, Temüjin proposed that his eldest son Jochi be married to Toghrul's daughter Cha'ur Beki, promising one of his own daughters to Senggum's son in return for the establishment of quda (lit. "marriage alliance"). Senggum conclusively rejected this proposal: not only was his position as heir to the Kereit at risk, but he found the proposal disrespectful because of Jochi's possible illegitimacy.[a] He was supported in his position by the tribal aristocracy, which included Altan and Kuchar, two of Temüjin's relatives, and Jamukha, who urged immediate action against his old anda.[4] Toghrul's position in the dispute is unclear—according to the Secret History of the Mongols, he was torn between his close ties to Temüjin and his love for his son, only choosing to support the latter when presented with an ultimatum. On the other hand, according to the Jami al-tawarikh of Rashid al-Din and oral histories recounted by Marco Polo, Toghrul was already predisposed against Temüjin and reacted angrily to the marriage proposal.[5] It is possible that Toghrul's mind was swayed by a merchant delegation from Central Asia containing representatives from the Qara Khitai and the Uighurs, whom Temüjin was likely to exclude from the Silk Road trade structures were he to gain ascendancy; it is also likely that Temüjin's own ambitions were somewhat to blame for the rupture in relations.[6]

In the end, Senggum's arguments prevailed over Toghrul. Desiring to avoid open conflict if possible, the Kereit leader devised a plan of deception: he informed Temüjin that he had decided to accept the proposed marriages and intended to hold a celebratory banquet. An unsuspecting Temüjin set off with a minimal guard to the feast,[b] where the conspirators had planned to ambush and kill him; warned of hostile rumours by his father's old retainer Münglig, he halted. Led by Senggum, the Kereit then took to the field in force, and Temüjin only escaped here because two herdsmen named Badai and Kishlik overheard the plans and came to warn him.[8] Decisively outnumbered, Temüjin was forced into headlong flight—he rode with his companions to the borders of Jin China, where he hoped to find reinforcements and seek sanctuary across the border if necessary. Even though he received some defectors from the Kereit force, including Kuildar of the Mankut and Jurchedei of the Uru'ud [ru], Temüjin was decisively defeated at the Battle of Qalaqaljid Sands in spring 1203. The defections proved crucial in allowing Temüjin to escape—Jurchedei wounded Senggum with an arrow, halting the Kereit attack—but Toghrul also chose not to pursue, reasoning that his enemy was out of the strategic picture.[9]

The Baljuna Covenant

Temüjin's forces had suffered severe losses during the withdrawal from the battle and several of his captains were missing. Despite the danger he waited through the following night for his surving troops to collect. Bo'orchu arrived at dawn, having lost his horse at Qalaqaljid, and he was shortly followed by Boroqul, who was tending to Ogedei, Temüjin's third son, who had suffered a serious neck injury. Temüjin then retreated, stopping only to bury Kuildar, who had been killed during the battle.[10] His forces eventually reached a lake or river named Baljuna, a place of unknown location. Scholars have alternately identified it as a tributary of the River Ingoda, or as Lake Balzino in Buryatia. The most likely location however lies on the Kalka River, which Temüjin might have retreated along and which lies close to the Jin frontier in south-eastern Mongolia.[11]

At this juncture in summer 1203, the size of the Mongol force was very small at either 2,600 or 4,600 warriors; biographies in the Yuán Shǐ emphasise the situation's exigency by stating Temüjin was accompanied by only nineteen followers, but this might well just refer to the company leaders.[12] According to the Yuán Shǐ, the starving men killed a fortuitously wild horse, eating its flesh and using its by-products to safely drink the muddy water:[13]

Temüjin, raising his hands towards the sky, swore thus: "If I finish 'the Great Work' then I shall share with you men the sweet and the bitter. If I break this word then let me be like this river, drunk up by others." Among officers and men there was none who was not moved to tears.

This retelling likely masks the historical events. The poetic Baljuna Covenant encapsulates the themes—a potent mixture of social equality and personal asceticism—Temüjin would emphasise to potential recruits. Temüjin in all probability spent a large portion of the summer attempting to recruit warriors to his cause: those he succeeded with included the Onggirat, the tribe of his wife Börte, the Ikires, and some of the Nirun Mongols. Others included leaders of the Khitan tribe, who saw in Temüjin a route to revenge against the Jin, and the Muslim merchants Ja'far and Hasan, who would have thought that Temüjin could offer economic and personal protection, along with favourable trade pacts. He even recruited members of Toghrul's Kereit tribe, such as Chinqai who became a prominent administrator under Ogedei.[14]

Historians have emphasised the social, cultural, and religious heterogeneity of the Baljuna oath-takers. There were no Mongols, apart from Temüjin and his brother Qasar in the traditional nineteen—they instead included Khitans, Tanguts, Keireits, Naimans, Central Asians, and possibly even South Asians, in a total of nine different clans. Swearing loyalty to Temüjin, a devout worshipper of Tengrism, were three Muslims and several Christians and Buddhists. In transcending traditional avenues of community, the Baljuna Covenant was "a type of brotherhood [akin to] modern civic citizenship based upon personal choice and commitment", in the words of the historian Jack Weatherford.[15]

Aftermath and legacy

In autumn 1203, a revitalized Temüjin marshalled his forces and defeated the Kereit in a hard-fought three-day battle at the Jeje'er Heights on the lower Kherlen river. The fleeing Toghrul was killed by a Naiman sentry who did not recognise him, while Senggum fled first to Tibet and then Kashgar, where he was later killed. Over the next three years, he defeated the Naimans and Merkits, uniting the Mongol steppe under one ruler. In 1206, he held a great kurultai on the Onon River, at which he took the title "Genghis Khan" and rewarded those who brought him to power. These included the herdsmen Badai and Kishlik who had warned him of Toghrul's betrayal—they were honoured with the Kereit leader's palace tent, furnishings, and bodyguard.[16] The men who swore the Baljuna Covenant, who became known as Baljunatu (lit. "Baljuna men", or "Muddy Water Drinkers") were honoured with the highest titles and were remembered as late as the 1300s.[17] Many took prominent positions in Genghis' Mongol Empire—these included Chinqai, the Muslim merchant and diplomat Ja'far Khoja, and Qaban, an Uriankhai whose son Subutai became one of the most formidable Mongol generals.[18]

References

Notes

  1. ^ Jochi had been born after his mother Börte had been kidnapped and raped by members of the Merkit tribe. Although Genghis always treated him as a legitimate son, doubts concerning Jochi's paternity followed him throughout his life.[3]
  2. ^ Rashid al-Din mentions two companions, whereas the Secret History of the Mongols counts ten.[7]

Citations

  1. ^ Morgan 1986, pp. 57–60; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 28–33; Fitzhugh, Rossabi & Honeychurch 2009, p. 101.
  2. ^ Atwood 2004, pp. 98, 259–260; May 2018, pp. 34–36.
  3. ^ Atwood 2004, p. 278.
  4. ^ May 2018, p. 37; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 38, 67.
  5. ^ Ratchnevsky 1991, p. 68; Man 2004, p. 96.
  6. ^ McLynn 2015, p. 72.
  7. ^ Ratchnevsky 1991, p. 69.
  8. ^ Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 68–69; May 2018, p. 37; Weatherford 2004, p. 56.
  9. ^ Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 69–70; McLynn 2015, pp. 73–74.
  10. ^ Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 70–71; Atwood 2004, p. 342; Cleaves 1955, p. 389.
  11. ^ Man 2004, pp. 96–97; Ratchnevsky 1991, p. 71.
  12. ^ Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 71, 73; Cleaves 1955, p. 397.
  13. ^ Cleaves 1955, p. 397; Man 2004, p. 97.
  14. ^ Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 71–72; Fitzhugh, Rossabi & Honeychurch 2009, p. 102.
  15. ^ Biran 2012, p. 38; Weatherford 2004, p. 58.
  16. ^ Atwood 2004, pp. 98–99; Ratchnevsky 1991, pp. 79–81; Fitzhugh, Rossabi & Honeychurch 2009, p. 102.
  17. ^ Atwood 2004, p. 30; Ratchnevsky 1991, p. 73.
  18. ^ Atwood 2004, pp. 103, 257, 520.

Sources