Talk:Cumgirl8: Difference between revisions
→Proposed Deletion Claims: new section |
missed a claim refutation |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
-"This article is an orphan, as no other articles link to it." - This claim was true at the time but only because I had just started work on the article. I have since introduced links to the article on [[Suicide Squeeze Records]] and [[post-punk]] pages and will add more soon. |
-"This article is an orphan, as no other articles link to it." - This claim was true at the time but only because I had just started work on the article. I have since introduced links to the article on [[Suicide Squeeze Records]] and [[post-punk]] pages and will add more soon. |
||
-"The topic of this article may not meet Wikipedia's notability guideline for music." This article meets multiple notability guidelines. The band has been the subject of numerous non-trivial articles in independent publications including heavy hitters like Vogue and The Fader. There is plenty of coverage of this band in the media to meet notability, there are entire articles dedicated to individual members of the band even! What was the point of claiming this if you didn't do minimal amount of research yourself?? On top of that, the band is signed to a well-known independent music label that has its own Wikipedia page. I have edited the article to add this information which I would've done anyway soon enough. |
|||
-"The topic of this article may not meet Wikipedia's notability guideline for music." |
|||
-"This article is an autobiography or has been extensively edited by the subject or by someone connected to the subject." - This claim is completely baseless and I struggle to imagine how the user came up with it. For over a decade I have focused on writing article about artists who are female, queer, people of color, or otherwise from a marginalized backgrounds. I do this for artists in a multitude of fields from music to comedy, film, literature, and fine art. I authored the original article for [[Eric André]], [[Kate Berlant]], [[Sam Jay]], [[Eliza Legzdina]], [[Pixel Grip]], Brendan O'Hare, [[Megan Ellison]], [[Bogosav Živković]], [[Dominik Lang]], [[Alejandro Zambra]], [[Dulcé Sloan]], [[Nicolás Pereda]], [[The Funkees]], [[Day Wave]], [[Joseph Crepin]], [[Elspeth Davie]], [[Rafael Bernal]]. cumgirl8 fits into my chosen editorial agenda on Wikipedia and there is no grounds to accuse me of being connected to the subject in any way whatsoever. Frankly, I find it offensive to suggest otherwise. |
-"This article is an autobiography or has been extensively edited by the subject or by someone connected to the subject." - This claim is completely baseless and I struggle to imagine how the user came up with it. For over a decade I have focused on writing article about artists who are female, queer, people of color, or otherwise from a marginalized backgrounds. I do this for artists in a multitude of fields from music to comedy, film, literature, and fine art. I authored the original article for [[Eric André]], [[Kate Berlant]], [[Sam Jay]], [[Eliza Legzdina]], [[Pixel Grip]], Brendan O'Hare, [[Megan Ellison]], [[Bogosav Živković]], [[Dominik Lang]], [[Alejandro Zambra]], [[Dulcé Sloan]], [[Nicolás Pereda]], [[The Funkees]], [[Day Wave]], [[Joseph Crepin]], [[Elspeth Davie]], [[Rafael Bernal]]. cumgirl8 fits into my chosen editorial agenda on Wikipedia and there is no grounds to accuse me of being connected to the subject in any way whatsoever. Frankly, I find it offensive to suggest otherwise. |
||
Revision as of 23:01, 1 December 2022
 | This page was proposed for deletion by SparklingSnail (talk · contribs) on 1 December 2022. |
Proposed Deletion Claims
@SparklingSnail has made a number of incorrect claims when proposing that this page be deleted. I will address each claim in turn:
-"This article is an orphan, as no other articles link to it." - This claim was true at the time but only because I had just started work on the article. I have since introduced links to the article on Suicide Squeeze Records and post-punk pages and will add more soon.
-"The topic of this article may not meet Wikipedia's notability guideline for music." This article meets multiple notability guidelines. The band has been the subject of numerous non-trivial articles in independent publications including heavy hitters like Vogue and The Fader. There is plenty of coverage of this band in the media to meet notability, there are entire articles dedicated to individual members of the band even! What was the point of claiming this if you didn't do minimal amount of research yourself?? On top of that, the band is signed to a well-known independent music label that has its own Wikipedia page. I have edited the article to add this information which I would've done anyway soon enough.
-"This article is an autobiography or has been extensively edited by the subject or by someone connected to the subject." - This claim is completely baseless and I struggle to imagine how the user came up with it. For over a decade I have focused on writing article about artists who are female, queer, people of color, or otherwise from a marginalized backgrounds. I do this for artists in a multitude of fields from music to comedy, film, literature, and fine art. I authored the original article for Eric André, Kate Berlant, Sam Jay, Eliza Legzdina, Pixel Grip, Brendan O'Hare, Megan Ellison, Bogosav Živković, Dominik Lang, Alejandro Zambra, Dulcé Sloan, Nicolás Pereda, The Funkees, Day Wave, Joseph Crepin, Elspeth Davie, Rafael Bernal. cumgirl8 fits into my chosen editorial agenda on Wikipedia and there is no grounds to accuse me of being connected to the subject in any way whatsoever. Frankly, I find it offensive to suggest otherwise.
- "Some of this article's listed sources may not be reliable." - Again, what is the basis for this claim? If you're going to propose deletion and make wild claims about my editorial work, you owe to Wikipedia to post some evidence on the talk page. Mbroderick271 (talk) 22:56, 1 December 2022 (UTC)