Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Zaccar

Eric Zaccar

Eric Zaccar (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views) – (View log)

(Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL)

A minor local playwright and musician. I don't believe this person meets the requirements of WP:BIO (and specifically WP:AUTHOR and WP:MUSIC). There are no reliable sources about the subject, and I can find very little about him. Even taking the unsourced article, all it asserts is that he's written some plays which have been performed by local groups; there's no indication any of these performances are notable, that the plays were reviewed by anyone, and certainly nothing like WP:AUTHOR's criterion that he is in any way an "important figure or is widely cited by their peers or successors." The only coverage at all I can find about him is a single NY Times local-section mention of his play (here) which has little detail about him, and some mentions of a jury trial of which he was foreman (here). His musical and photographic efforts appear to be of similarly marginal significance. So I don't believe he's anything other than a very minor local figure with no general relevance, influence, or importance, and so that it's inappropriate that Wikipedia have an article devoted to him. Finlay McWalter • Talk 21:55, 18 October 2009 (UTC)

• Qualifying what I said above, the Ken Starr play has been reviewed, but only in very very minor local publications and then only to a very small degree. -- Finlay McWalter • Talk 22:28, 18 October 2009 (UTC)
• Delete – I was going to stick a {{PROD}} on this piece of vanispamcruftisement after putting some lipstick on it, but this works, too … there may be beau coup "references", but they don't amount to "significant coverage" as defined by WP:N. — 141.156.161.245 (talk) 19:47, 19 October 2009 (UTC)

• • 'Keep Article The New York Post, the New York Times, and New York Newsday can hardly be called " very very minor local publications" as the user below has suggested. Eric Zaccar's work has been written about in all of those publications, and discussed at length on national major market radio programs, like Howard Stern, Joe Franklin and Joey Reynolds. Eric is listed as a prominant playwright and lyricist in Joseph Papp's Public Theater archives, and Mr. Papp was widely considered to be the most renowned theater producer of the latter half of the twentieth century. By all projections, Mr. Zaccar's upcoming feature film, WITHOUT HATE, is going to be a serious contender in the market. His plays have been produced all around New York City, and his last screenplay, ON THE OTHER SIDE, was produced as a feature film and distributed internationally. Though the user below seems to a gifted artist and photographer, he does not seem to be in New York, or the United States. I'm not sure exactly how he is receiving his information about an American writer, or why he seems to be on a personal vendetta against someone that he does not know, and knows little about. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Dreamdesignernow (talk • contribs) 21:06, 19 October 2009 (UTC)

Dreamdesignernow put this comment at the top of the page (so "the user below" means the nomination); I've moved it down to its place in the contemporaneous stream of comments -- Finlay McWalter • Talk 21:21, 19 October 2009 (UTC)

• • There isn't a shred of evidence for most of what you say in the article. The Post and Newsday mentions are tiny scraps on minor pages. The NY times story discusses the play, not Zaccar, and is in the local pages. The local pages of the times are like the local pages of any other US newspaper, and are no more evidence of notability than the same 3 column inches would be in the Sheboygan Press or the Duluth Tribune. None of these amounts to even a tiny review of a single play; one can hardly claim to be a noted playwright when no noted theatre critic has reviewed your play. -- Finlay McWalter • Talk 21:26, 19 October 2009 (UTC)
• Delete Unless I am missing something, the only thing I can find on Google is Zaccar's comments following jury duty. I don't see anything about being a famous playwright. Warrah (talk) 02:37, 20 October 2009 (UTC)

• 'Keep Article Google again, Warrah. Of the thousand plus articles and pages that come up about Eric Zaccar, less than ten per cent of them deal with said jury trial. Of course, all of that should be changing soon. The buzz in the business is, Eric's new screenplay, Without Hate, based on the afore mentioned case, is in pre-production and should be a major motion picture, within the year. I've been around the New York theater and independent film scene for quite a while, and I can tell you that Eric is rather well known, and well regarded. If I have to vote, I'm obviously going to say keep the article! —Preceding unsigned comment added by Robroams (talk • contribs) 04:56, 20 October 2009 (UTC)