Quango: Difference between revisions
Line 26: | Line 26: | ||
Depending upon one's point of view, the separation of a quango from government might be either to allow its specified functions to be more commercially exercised, independently of politics and changeable government priorities, and unencumbered by civil service practices and bureaucracy; or else to allow an elected minister to exercise patronage, and extend their influence beyond their term of office, while evading responsibility for the expenditure of public money and the exercise of legal powers. |
Depending upon one's point of view, the separation of a quango from government might be either to allow its specified functions to be more commercially exercised, independently of politics and changeable government priorities, and unencumbered by civil service practices and bureaucracy; or else to allow an elected minister to exercise patronage, and extend their influence beyond their term of office, while evading responsibility for the expenditure of public money and the exercise of legal powers. |
||
The Times has accused quangos of bureaucratic waste and excess.<ref>[http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article3953922.ece Waste mounts as £100 billion web of quangos duplicates work]</ref> In 2005 Dan Lewis, author of ''The Essential Guide to Quangos'', for example, claimed that the UK had 529 quangos, many of which were useless and duplicated the work of others. In August 2008 a report by the pressure group the |
The Times has accused quangos of bureaucratic waste and excess.<ref>[http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/article3953922.ece Waste mounts as £100 billion web of quangos duplicates work]</ref> In 2005 Dan Lewis, author of ''The Essential Guide to Quangos'', for example, claimed that the UK had 529 quangos, many of which were useless and duplicated the work of others. In August 2008 a report by the right-leaning pressure group the Taxpayers' Alliance, claimed that £15 billion was being wasted by the [[regional development agency|regional development agencies]], quangos set up with the stated goal of encouraging economic development in their respective English regions.<ref>{{Cite web |
||
|url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/7548573.stm |
|url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/7548573.stm |
||
|title=Agencies branded 'waste of money' |
|title=Agencies branded 'waste of money' |
Revision as of 15:44, 20 March 2010
Quango or qango is an acronym (variously spelt out as quasi non-governmental organisation, quasi-autonomous non-governmental organisation, and quasi-autonomous national government organisation) used notably in the United Kingdom, Ireland, Australia and elsewhere to label colloquially an organisation to which government has devolved power. In the United Kingdom the official term is "non-departmental public body" or NDPB.
History
The term has its origin in a humorous shortening of quasi-autonomous NGO, an ostensibly non-governmental organisation performing governmental functions, often in receipt of funding or other support from government,[1] while mainstream NGOs mostly get their donations or funds from the public and other organizations that support their cause. Numerous quangos were created from the 1980s onwards. Examples in the United Kingdom include those engaged in the regulation of various commercial and service sectors, such as the Water Services Regulation Authority.
An essential feature of a quango in the original definition was that it should not be a formal part of the state structure. The term was then extended to apply to a range of organisations, such as executive agencies providing (from 1988) health, education and other services. Particularly in the UK, this occurred in a polemical atmosphere in which it was alleged that proliferation of such bodies was undesirable and should be reversed (see below).[2] This spawned the related acronym qualgo, a 'quasi-autonomous local government organisation'.[3]
The less contentious term non-departmental public body (NDPB) is often employed to identify numerous organisations with devolved governmental responsibilities. The UK government's definition in 1997 of a non-departmental public body or quango was:
- "A body which has a role in the processes of national government, but is not a government department or part of one, and which accordingly operates to a greater or lesser extent at arm's length from Ministers."[4]
Use
United Kingdom
The use in the UK of executive agencies charged with service delivery functions has arisen alongside so-called non-departmental public bodies. These agencies do not usually have a legal identity separate from that of their parent department; and, unless they have trading fund status, their accounts form part of the accounts of the parent department. The National Health Service also has bodies called special health authorities, technically neither NDPBs nor executive agencies. The Department of Health chooses to designate all three types as "arm's length bodies".
Network Rail, responsible for the UK's railway infrastructure, may be regarded as a quango, subject, however, to the question of whether the entity is, as its formal structure might suggest, a non-governmental private company, or a state-owned enterprise.
According to the Tax Payers Alliance, tax payers funded 1,162 Quangos' at a cost of nearly £64bn; equivalent to £2,550 per household.[5]
Ireland
Ireland in 2006 had more than 800 quangos, 482 at national and 350 at local level, with a total of 5,784 individual appointees and a combined annual budget of €13 billion.[6]
Criticism
Depending upon one's point of view, the separation of a quango from government might be either to allow its specified functions to be more commercially exercised, independently of politics and changeable government priorities, and unencumbered by civil service practices and bureaucracy; or else to allow an elected minister to exercise patronage, and extend their influence beyond their term of office, while evading responsibility for the expenditure of public money and the exercise of legal powers.
The Times has accused quangos of bureaucratic waste and excess.[7] In 2005 Dan Lewis, author of The Essential Guide to Quangos, for example, claimed that the UK had 529 quangos, many of which were useless and duplicated the work of others. In August 2008 a report by the right-leaning pressure group the Taxpayers' Alliance, claimed that £15 billion was being wasted by the regional development agencies, quangos set up with the stated goal of encouraging economic development in their respective English regions.[8]
Popular culture
Britpop band Blur released a song called 'Mr. Robinson's Quango' on their 1995 album The Great Escape. The lyrics allude to Mr. Robinson being a 'dirty dealer' and a mason, as well as not doing very much, amongst other things.
Quangos were mentioned in several episodes of the popular British sitcom Yes Minister, which satirised political life. In particular, the chairmanship of a quango played a central role in the episode Jobs for the Boys from the first series of the sitcom.
See also
- Executive agency
- Departments of the United Kingdom Government
- Scottish public bodies
- Off-budget enterprise
- Non-governmental organization
- GONGO
References
- ^ Wettenhall, R 1981 'The quango phenomenon', Current Affairs Bulletin 57(10):14-22.]
- ^ "You've Been Quangoed!" by Roland Watson
- ^ The Times "New body's waste plea." (April 18, 1986): NA. Newspapers Online. Gale. Gale Document Number:CJ117886677. Retrieved 5 Apr, 2008. "...London Waste Regulation Authority, the first 'qualgo' formed after abolition of the Greater London Council, ... The new body is a joint board of councilors from London boroughs. 'Qualgo' stands for 'quasi-autonomous local government organization', the municipal equivalent of a quango, in which members are appointed by other councilors. "
- ^ Public Bodies 1997, "Introduction"
- ^ Focus: THE UNSEEN GOVERNMENT OF THE UK
- ^ According to a survey carried out by the think-tank Tasc in 2006. Focus: What's wrong with quangos? — The Sunday Times newspaper article, 29 October 2006
- ^ Waste mounts as £100 billion web of quangos duplicates work
- ^ "Agencies branded 'waste of money'". bbc.co.uk. BBC News. 2008-08-08. Retrieved 2008-08-08.
Quangos set up to improve the fortunes of the English regions have been branded a costly and ineffectual waste of money by a pressure group.
External links
- Defining Quango Article From political site Governing Dynamo
- Cabinet Office - Agencies and Public Bodies
- Economic Research Council - online database of all UK quangos 1998-2006
- The Sunday Times Article on Quangos - Sept 2006
- Richard Allen and Dimitar Radev, "Managing and Controlling Extrabudgetary Funds", OECD Journal of Budgeting, Vol. 6, No. 4, 2006
- Carsten Greve, Matthew Flinders, Sandra Van Thiel (1999), Quangos—What's in a Name? Defining Quangos from a Comparative Perspective, Governance 12 (2), 129–146 doi:10.1111/0952-1895.951999095
- UK government site about the process of making public appointments