Thomas Hodgskin

Thomas Hodgskin (b. 12 December 1787 Chatham, Kent, d. - 21 August 1869 Feltham, Middlesex) was an English socialist writer on political economy, critic of capitalism, free-market anarchist and defender of free trade and early trade unions.

Born of a father who worked in the Chatham Naval Dockyard, Hodgskin joined the navy at the age of 12. He rose rapidly through the ranks in the years of naval struggle with the French to the rank of first lieutenant. Following the naval defeat of the French the opportunities for advancement closed and Hodgskin increasingly ran into disciplinary trouble with his superiors, eventually leading to his court martial and dismissal in 1812. This prompted his first book An Essay on Naval Discipline (1813) a scathing critique of the brutal authoritarian regime then current in the navy.

Entering Edinburgh University for study he later came to London in 1815 and entered the utilitarian circle around Francis Place, Jeremy Bentham and James Mill. With their support he spent the next five years in a programme of travel and study around Europe which resulted, inter alia, in a second book "Travels in North Germany" (1820).

After 3 years in Edinburgh, Hodgskin returned to London in 1823 as a journalist. Influenced by, amongst others, Jean Baptiste Say, his views on political economy had diverged from the utilitarian orthodoxy of David Ricardo and James Mill. During the controversy around the parliamentary acts to first legalise and then ban worker's "combinations" Mill and Ricardo had been in favour of the ban whereas Hodgskin supported the right to organise. Taking Ricardo's labour theory of value he used it to denounce the appropriation of the most part of value produced by the labour of industrial workers as illegitimate. He propounded these views in a series of lectures at the London Mechanics Institute where he debated with William Thompson with whom he shared the critique of capitalist expropriation but not the proposed remedy. The results of these lectures and debates he published as "Labour Defended against the Claims of Capital" (1825), "Popular Political Economy" (1827) and "Natural and Artificial Right of Property Contrasted" (1832). The title of "Labour Defended" was a jibe at James Mill's earlier "Commerce Defended" and signalled his opposition to the latters taking sides with the capitalists against their employees.

Though his criticism of Employers appropriation of the lion's share of the value produced by their employees went on to influence subsequent generations of socialists, including Karl Marx, Hodgskin's fundamental Deist beliefs identified production and exchange based on the labour theory of value (freed from the supposedly illegitimate expropriations of rent, interest and owner's profits) as part of "natural right", the divinely ordained proper relations of society contrasted to "artificial" contrivances — the source of disharmonies and conflicts. He rejected the proto-communism of William Thompson and Robert Owen by the same appeal to "natural right".

In 1823 Hodgskin joined forces with Joseph Clinton Robinson in founding the "Mechanics Magazine". In the October 1823 edition Hodgskin and Francis Place wrote a manifesto for a Mechanics Institute. This would be more than a technical school but a place where practical studies could be combined with practical reflection about the condition of society. The inaugural meeting to found the Institute took place in 1823 but the idea was taken over by people of less radical views concerned about Hodgskin's unorthodox economic views including George Birkbeck a well known educator from Glasgow.

Despite his high profile in the agitated revolutionary times of the 1820s, he retreated into the realm of Whig journalism after the Reform Act 1832. He became an advocate of free trade and spent 15 years writing for The Economist. He worked on the paper with its founder James Wilson and with the young Herbert Spencer. Hodgskin viewed the demise of the Corn Laws as the first step to the downfall of government and his libertarian anarchism was regarded as too radical by many of the liberals of the Anti-Corn Law League. He left the Economist in 1857. He continued working as a journalist for the rest of his life.

References

• David Stack, Nature and Artifice: The Life and Thought of Thomas Hodgskin 1787-1986 Boydell & Brewer Ltd 1998
• Edward Sallis, The Social and Political Thought of Thomas Hodgskin 1787-1869, MA Social Studies Dissertation University of Newcastle upon Tyne 1971
• Elie Halevy, Thomas Hodgskin (Paris 1903), English translation A J Taylor 1956

External links

• Labour Defended against the Claims of Capital